Table of Contents

Should I Sell My Legendary Animal Pelts in Red Dead Redemption 2? A Trapper’s Guide

The question of whether or not to sell your legendary animal pelts in Red Dead Redemption 2 is a common one, fraught with potential regret if mishandled. The definitive answer is YES, absolutely sell your legendary pelts to the Trapper. There’s a caveat, of course, but understanding the game’s mechanics will ensure you maximize your profits and unlock the incredible outfits and gear the Trapper has to offer. Neglecting to do so means missing out on some of the game’s most unique and stylish cosmetic items, as well as practical gear that enhances Arthur’s abilities.

Why Selling to the Trapper is Essential

The Trapper is your go-to artisan for crafting unique clothing and gear from legendary pelts. He operates in a few fixed locations around the map, and his services are crucial for completing your wardrobe and unlocking specific in-game benefits. While you do receive a small amount of cash for selling the pelt to him, the primary reason to sell isn’t the immediate financial gain. It’s that selling the pelt unlocks the crafting recipes that are unique to each legendary animal. Without selling the pelt, you simply can’t access these recipes and the corresponding clothing.

The game does not allow you to craft these items without first giving him the necessary materials and unlocks that only selling allows.

Think of it like this: you’re not just selling a pelt; you’re paying for the Trapper’s craftsmanship and unlocking the potential of that pelt to be transformed into something extraordinary. He doesn’t need to physically possess the pelt after the transaction to retain its crafting information; it’s more like he now has access to the animal’s “essence” for crafting purposes.

Perfect Pelts: Pearson vs. The Trapper

Another source of confusion is the distinction between perfect pelts from regular animals and legendary pelts. While the Trapper is the only one who can handle legendary pelts for crafting, other types of pelts can be used for a variety of things. Regular perfect pelts should typically be given to Pearson at your camp. Pearson uses these pelts to upgrade your camp, crafting satchels and other essential items. Prioritize these upgrades, as they significantly improve your carrying capacity and overall gameplay experience.

However, any pelts that Pearson cannot use, especially three-star (perfect) pelts, can be sold to the Trapper for extra money.

The Fence: Dealing with Legendary Animal Parts

While the Trapper is the master of pelts, the Fence specializes in trinkets and talismans crafted from other legendary animal parts, such as claws, teeth, and horns. These items provide permanent stat boosts and passive abilities, making them highly valuable. Be sure to visit the Fence after hunting legendary animals to unlock these benefits. Selling the legendary animal parts to the Fence unlocks the crafting of unique trinkets that will enhance Arthur’s skills. Each trinket requires specific legendary animal parts, as well as other rare items found throughout the world.

Prioritizing Sales and Donations

Here’s a quick guide to prioritizing where to take your hunting spoils:

Legendary Pelts: Sell only to the Trapper.
Legendary Animal Parts (claws, teeth, horns): Sell only to the Fence.
Perfect Pelts (3-star animals): Give to Pearson first for camp upgrades, then sell any extras to the Trapper.
Good and Poor Pelts: Sell to the Trapper or general stores for cash.
Carcasses: Sell to the Trapper or butcher (skinned carcasses are worth half the price).
Meat: Cook for sustenance or sell to the butcher or general store.

Don’t Worry About Ruining Legendary Pelts

One of the most forgiving aspects of hunting in Red Dead Redemption 2 is that legendary pelts are always perfect, and cannot be ruined by improper hunting techniques. Feel free to use whatever weapon is most convenient, even explosives, without fear of damaging the pelt’s quality. Once you skin the animal, the pelt will always be a perfect legendary pelt, ready to be sold to the Trapper.

Legendary Animals Don’t Respawn, But You Get What You Need

It’s a common misconception that legendary animals respawn in Red Dead Redemption 2. While this isn’t true, the game provides a safety net to ensure you can obtain all the necessary materials for crafting. Even if you die after killing a legendary animal but before skinning it, the game will automatically add the legendary pelt to the Trapper’s inventory and the legendary parts to the Fence, ensuring you don’t miss out on the opportunity to craft the unique items.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Legendary Pelts

Here are 15 frequently asked questions about legendary animal pelts in Red Dead Redemption 2, designed to address common confusions and provide additional valuable information:

What happens if I accidentally lose a legendary pelt? Don’t panic! If you lose a legendary pelt, it will automatically appear at the Trapper’s inventory after a short amount of time. You will not get the monetary value for selling it, but you will have unlocked the crafting options it provides.
Can I donate legendary pelts to Pearson? No. Pearson will not accept legendary pelts. They are exclusively for the Trapper. If you attempt to give Pearson a legendary pelt, he will simply refuse it.
Does the type of weapon I use affect the quality of legendary pelts? No. Legendary pelts are always perfect, regardless of the weapon used to kill the animal. This is a major difference compared to hunting regular animals.
What’s the best way to transport a legendary pelt? Simply load the pelt onto the back of your horse. It will remain securely attached unless your horse is killed or you manually remove it.
How do I find the Trapper? The Trapper has multiple locations marked on the map with a paw print icon. Visit any of these locations to access his services.
Do I need to sell the entire legendary animal carcass to the Trapper? No, only the pelt is required for crafting. You can sell the carcass to the Trapper or butcher for additional cash, but it’s not essential for unlocking crafting recipes.
What happens if I die before skinning a legendary animal? The game automatically adds the legendary pelt to the Trapper’s inventory.
Is there a limit to how many legendary pelts I can carry? No, there is no limit.
Can I store legendary pelts at my camp? No, legendary pelts cannot be stored in the camp’s satchel or on the horse. They must be sold directly to the Trapper to unlock the crafting recipes.
What are some of the best items I can craft with legendary pelts? Some of the most popular and useful items include the various outfits that protect against extreme weather, satchels that increase carrying capacity, and trinkets that provide permanent stat boosts.
Do legendary animals respawn? No, legendary animals do not respawn after being killed. However, the game ensures you can obtain all the necessary materials for crafting.
What’s the difference between a pelt and a hide? Generally, “pelt” refers to the skin of a smaller animal, while “hide” refers to the skin of a larger animal, but there is no functional difference in Red Dead Redemption 2. Both can be sold to the Trapper or used for crafting.
How much money do you get for selling a legendary pelt? The amount of money you receive for selling a legendary pelt varies depending on the animal, but it’s typically a relatively small sum. The primary benefit is unlocking the crafting recipes. As mentioned earlier, selling the Legendary Fox Pelt gets you $22.
Can I sell legendary animal parts to anyone other than the Fence? No, legendary animal parts (claws, teeth, horns) can only be sold to the Fence. Other merchants will not accept them.
Is there a specific order in which I should hunt legendary animals? There’s no specific order required, but it’s generally recommended to hunt the easier animals early on to unlock some basic crafting recipes and gear. Exploring the map and discovering the locations of legendary animals organically is part of the fun!

The study of games and learning, including how video games engage players in complex problem-solving and decision-making, is a fascinating field. Learn more about the impact of games on education and society by visiting the GamesLearningSociety.org website at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/.

In conclusion, selling your legendary animal pelts to the Trapper in Red Dead Redemption 2 is not just recommended; it’s essential for unlocking the full potential of the game. Don’t miss out on the unique outfits, gear, and stat boosts that these legendary hunts provide. Happy hunting!

Should I sell my legendary animal pelts?