Table of Contents

Should Markus Accept or Refuse John in Detroit: Become Human?

The pivotal moment arrives early in Detroit: Become Human: should Markus accept or refuse the FBI agent, John’s, deal? The answer, definitively, is Markus should refuse the deal. This decision is not just a matter of in-game mechanics; it’s a cornerstone that dictates the potential for the “Good Ending” and the survival of key characters. Accepting John’s offer locks Markus into a path of android detainment and severely limits his ability to lead a successful, peaceful revolution. This article will delve into why refusing the deal is crucial, explore the consequences of both choices, and answer related FAQs to fully understand the implications.

The Critical Choice: Refuse the Deal

The game presents a tempting proposition: an FBI agent promises safety in exchange for android cooperation. The agent, John, attempts to sway Markus with assurances, but this is a trap. Accepting this deal immediately diverts Markus’s narrative towards a destructive path. Here’s why refusing is non-negotiable for a positive outcome:

Good Ending Lockout: The game makes it clear that accepting the deal prevents the “Good Ending.” This ending requires a peaceful demonstration, a path blocked entirely if Markus agrees to the FBI’s terms.
Android Detainment: Acceptance leads to the detainment of all androids, including critical allies like Josh and Simon. This removes their potential contributions to the revolution and effectively dismantles any resistance.
Lost Opportunity for Peaceful Protest: Refusing the deal allows Markus to return to the barricade and rally his people, culminating in a powerful speech that influences character relationships and the overall direction of the narrative.
Subsequent Events: The events after refusing John’s offer are specifically designed to challenge Markus. He experiences a bombing and faces immediate danger. However, this is the road to a peaceful resolution.

Consequences of Accepting the Deal

The immediate and long-term ramifications of accepting John’s offer are severe and detrimental:

No Revolution: By accepting the deal, Markus effectively surrenders his agency. The androids are rounded up and placed into trucks. There’s no opportunity for organized resistance or a fight for their rights.
No Allies: The androids, including potential key allies, are detained alongside Markus. Without a unified group, the chances of freedom and liberation are minimal.
Loss of Potential: The game offers no avenue for a good outcome if Markus complies with the FBI. The narrative closes off, leaving no room for exploration, character development, or the achievement of liberation.
Bad Ending Trigger: Accepting John’s proposal leads toward what most consider a ‘bad’ outcome for Markus, as all androids are taken by the FBI.

The Path to the Good Ending: Choosing Demonstration

Refusing the deal is not just a matter of avoiding a bad outcome; it’s the only way to unlock the game’s best ending. Here’s what follows when Markus chooses to refuse:

Return to the Barricade: Markus returns to the android community, reinforcing his leadership and commitment to freedom.
The Speech: Markus delivers an impactful speech that rallies the androids and shapes public perception. The relationships between characters are influenced significantly.
Peaceful Demonstration: The speech serves as the catalyst for a peaceful demonstration, a risky but ultimately rewarding strategy for achieving liberation.
Survival of Key Characters: Choosing the peaceful path and maintaining a high level of public opinion significantly increases the chances for character survival, particularly Markus and his allies.
North’s Role: Notably, having North as a lover is critical. If Markus is hurt during the demonstration, North will shield him, giving her life for him, but also ensuring Markus’s survival.

The Role of Public Opinion

The success of Markus’s journey heavily depends on maintaining a positive Public Opinion of the android movement. When opting for peace, a positive public perception can influence both the choices of other characters and the overall success of the demonstration. While a violent approach is viable, it does not require positive public opinion.

John’s Sacrifice and Other Key Events

Several events and character choices affect the course of the game, with some being crucial for unlocking the best possible outcome:

John’s Sacrifice: If John joined Jericho in “Spare Parts” and the player has Markus attacked or lose to the police during the protest, John will sacrifice himself to save Markus.
Connor’s Deviance: Connor’s choice to become deviant can support Markus’s cause, joining him at Jericho to further support the revolution.
The rA9 Concept: Understanding that rA9 is a story created by androids for hope provides important context to the androids’ motivations.

FAQs: Detroit: Become Human

1. What happens if Markus accepts the deal from the FBI agent?

Accepting the deal results in all androids being detained. Markus effectively fails in his goal for freedom and the storyline heads towards a bad ending.

2. How do I get the good ending in Detroit: Become Human?

For the good ending, Markus must refuse the deal, lead a peaceful protest, and maintain a positive public opinion. Key character relationships, like a love relationship with North, is important as well.

3. Can Connor join Markus?

Yes, if Connor becomes deviant during the “Crossroads” chapter, he can choose to join Markus. This requires making specific choices earlier in the game, such as letting the Traci escape from Eden.

4. Does public opinion matter?

Yes, public opinion is crucial for a peaceful revolution. A high positive public opinion will be necessary to get certain endings.

5. Who is rA9?

rA9 is a story or a religious figure created by androids to give them hope and something to believe in. One of the Morse codes in the game translates to “rA9 is a fake.”

6. What happens if Connor kills Markus?

If Connor kills Markus during the protest, the mission succeeds for Cyberlife. However, this will be a game over for Markus. The other option is that Connor spares Markus, but Amanda will take control of Connor’s program.

7. What happens if Markus chooses to be violent?

A violent revolution is a path in the game. However, it can lead to character deaths and a less-than-optimal ending for the androids.

8. Can Markus kiss North?

Yes, during a specific chapter, Markus can choose to initiate a romantic relationship with North which will then allow him to kiss her. This is a critical relationship for the good ending.

9. Who should you sacrifice in Detroit?

In order to get the best ending with Markus, you should sacrifice no one. When Markus leads a peaceful protest, the group can freely cross the border without any sacrifices. However, if violence is chosen, Jerry can be sacrificed.

10. Can Luther be saved?

Yes, Luther can be saved by taking a pacifist approach as Markus and pleading with the government officer at the border.

11. Did John give his life to save Markus?

Yes, if John joined Jericho, and if Markus is attacked and fails to escape from the police, John will sacrifice himself to protect Markus.

12. Should you detonate the dirty bomb?

No, detonating the dirty bomb results in a horrible outcome, and should never be chosen.

13. Does Zlatko know Alice is an android?

Yes, Zlatko recognizes Alice as an android because she’s a YK500 model. He often refers to Alice as “it”.

14. Can androids eat?

No, androids are never seen eating human foods, but they can replenish blue blood.

15. Will there be a Detroit: Become Human 2?

While nothing is confirmed, there are hints of a sequel, but details are vague. The announcement of “Human Tokyo Stories” suggests development is underway.

In conclusion, for the optimal outcome in Detroit: Become Human, Markus must unequivocally refuse the deal offered by John. It is a pivotal choice that determines whether the androids find freedom through a peaceful revolution or are subjected to detainment and defeat. Refusal unlocks the path to the good ending, promotes character survival, and ultimately allows for the androids to become human. Understanding the far-reaching consequences of this decision is critical to achieving the best possible narrative conclusion.

Should Markus accept or refuse John?