The Whispering Hillock Dilemma: To Free or To Kill in The Witcher 3
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The question of whether to free or kill the spirit in the Whispering Hillock is one of the most agonizing choices in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. It’s a moral quandary that tests the player’s perception of the “lesser evil,” offering no truly happy ending. There’s no simple answer, as both paths lead to significant, devastating consequences. Ultimately, the “best” choice depends on your priorities and the weight you place on different lives. Generally, killing the spirit results in a less chaotic immediate outcome, saving the village of Downwarren, but at the tragic cost of the orphans’ lives, while freeing the spirit saves the orphans but dooms Downwarren.
However, focusing solely on a binary choice misses the nuance. The consequences ripple outward and intertwine, impacting multiple characters. Let’s delve deeper.
The Consequences of Killing the Spirit
If you choose to kill the spirit, you effectively eliminate a threat to the Crones, the vile witches residing in Crookback Bog. The immediate results are that:
- Downwarren is saved: The villagers, who have been tormented by the spirit, are spared.
- The orphans are lost: The Crones will take the children from Crookback Bog and, as it is heavily implied, devour them. This is perhaps the most heart-wrenching outcome.
- Anna Strenger suffers: The Baron’s wife, Anna, doesn’t become a water hag. However, she suffers a severe mental breakdown, driven mad by the loss of the children. The Baron then takes her to the mountains hoping to find a healer.
This path offers a sense of stability and prevents immediate chaos. The village of Downwarren continues its existence, albeit with a heavy conscience. However, the sacrifice of the children, the most innocent victims, is a significant moral burden.
The Consequences of Freeing the Spirit
Choosing to free the spirit unleashes a different set of consequences, characterized by immediate violence and tragedy:
- Downwarren is massacred: The freed spirit, vengeful and powerful, decimates the village of Downwarren. This is an extremely violent and brutal outcome.
- The orphans are saved: The spirit keeps its promise and rescues the orphans from the clutches of the Crones, releasing them into the swamp. Though it is implied their fate is uncertain in the wild.
- Anna Strenger is transformed: Anna is transformed into a Water Hag, ultimately succumbing to her new monstrous form. The Baron’s fate is uncertain but it is usually said he will die shortly after these events.
This outcome prioritizes the lives of the innocent children. However, it does so at the expense of an entire village. The spirit also exacts a brutal retribution, leaving a path of destruction. The tragedy of Anna becoming a Water Hag, and what happens to the Baron, makes this path very difficult for the player.
The Moral Gray Area
The brilliance of this quest lies in its inherent moral ambiguity. There is no clear “good” choice. The game forces you to confront difficult questions:
- Is it justifiable to save a few at the expense of many?
- What is the value of innocence versus experience?
- Can one choose between lives when all options are terrible?
The “lesser evil” changes based on individual priorities. Some players prefer saving the children, viewing their innocence as paramount. Others find the destruction of an entire village an unacceptable price. Some prioritize saving Anna, and in this situation that path is to kill the spirit.
The Impact on the Narrative
Both choices have ramifications later in the game. While the immediate impacts are apparent, the echoes of your decision resonate through the narrative. This highlights how player agency shapes the world of the Witcher 3, making you culpable and responsible for the outcomes of your actions.
Ultimately, the Whispering Hillock dilemma is a masterclass in ethical decision-making within a video game. It emphasizes the grim, realistic nature of The Witcher 3 universe, where choices are rarely simple and the best outcome might be one where you are only choosing between evils.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What happens if you kill the spirit in Whispering Hillock?
Killing the spirit saves Downwarren, but the Crones take the children, and Anna goes insane. The Baron is spared from having to kill Anna. He takes her to the mountains seeking treatment.
2. What happens if you free the spirit in Whispering Hillock?
Freeing the spirit causes the massacre of Downwarren, saves the orphans, and transforms Anna into a Water Hag.
3. Is there a way to save both the children and the people of Downwarren?
No, there is no way to save both. The quest is designed to force a terrible choice between the two groups. It is the very heart of what makes this quest so memorable.
4. Can Anna be saved in The Witcher 3?
Anna can technically be saved from becoming a Water Hag, but with a negative consequence: she will go insane after the loss of the children. This outcome is only possible if you kill the spirit.
5. What is the best choice in the Whispering Hillock quest?
There is no objectively “best” choice. The generally considered “least worst” choice is to kill the spirit, though this depends on individual perspectives. Most players agree saving the children is better, even at the cost of Downwarren.
6. What are the Crones of Crookback Bog?
The Crones are powerful, ancient, and evil witches who reside in Crookback Bog. They are heavily implied to eat the children sent to them.
7. How does the spirit get trapped in the Whispering Hillock?
The spirit, known as “The Mother,” is a powerful nature spirit. It was trapped beneath the Whispering Hillock by the Crones.
8. What happens if I complete the Whispering Hillock quest after meeting the Crones?
Completing it after meeting the Crones does affect the narrative but not in terms of the outcomes. The same outcomes happen depending if you kill or free the spirit. The order in which you complete things mostly only affects dialogue and how things unfold.
9. Does killing the spirit affect the Crones?
Yes, killing the spirit aids the Crones, as they are freed from one of their enemies. It makes their victory easier.
10. Does the Baron always die in The Witcher 3?
The Baron’s fate depends on the choices made in the game. Choosing to free the spirit often leads to the Baron dying shortly after the death of Anna.
11. What does the “Return to Crookback Bog” quest reveal?
This quest reveals the consequences of your Whispering Hillock decision. If you killed the spirit, Anna is mad. If you freed the spirit, Anna is a water hag.
12. What is the significance of the doll in Crookback Bog’s cellar?
In the “Return to Crookback Bog” quest, Geralt must choose the correct doll that represents Anna to lift the curse on her. The doll with the hollyhock blossom is the correct one, as it’s her favorite flower.
13. Can you fight the Crones in The Witcher 3?
Yes, you face off against the Crones during the “Bald Mountain” quest. Two die during this fight, and the third Crone is dealt with later in the game by Geralt and Ciri.
14. Why are the Crones considered evil?
The Crones are evil due to their cruel and sadistic nature. They prey on the vulnerable, especially children, and their practices involve dark magic and human sacrifice.
15. What is the “lesser evil” philosophy in The Witcher?
The “lesser evil” philosophy involves choosing between two undesirable options, trying to minimize the negative outcome. The Whispering Hillock quest embodies this concept perfectly, highlighting the moral ambiguity prevalent in The Witcher universe.