Table of Contents

Should You Free the Ghost in the Tree? A Witcher 3 Dilemma Decoded

The Whispering Hillock. Just the name sends shivers down the spine of even seasoned witchers. Within its gnarled embrace lies a spirit, trapped and seemingly yearning for release. The quest “The Whispering Hillock” presents one of the most morally ambiguous choices in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt, a game renowned for them. Should you free the ghost in the tree?

The short answer? Probably not. While the spirit spins a convincing tale of innocence and promises to save orphans from the clutches of the Crones, the long-term consequences of freeing it are far more devastating than the immediate satisfaction of believing you’ve done the right thing. Understanding the implications of your choice requires a deep dive into the lore and a careful consideration of the ramifications for Velen and its inhabitants.

Understanding the Stakes: Crones, Barons, and Orphans

Before making your decision, it’s crucial to understand the key players and their roles:

The Crones: These ancient, malevolent beings are the rulers of Crookback Bog and the undisputed powers of Velen’s darker side. They demand tribute, feed on children, and revel in cruelty. While seemingly unbeatable, they do have weaknesses and are not necessarily acting out of pure malice, but rather fulfilling their own twisted sense of order.
The Bloody Baron (Phillip Strenger): A complex and flawed character, the Baron is the ruler of Velen. He’s a drunkard and abuser, but also deeply regrets his actions and genuinely loves his wife, Anna, and daughter, Tamara. His story is one of redemption, but its success hinges on the choices you make in the game.
Anna Strenger: The Baron’s wife, Anna, is trapped in Crookback Bog, serving the Crones. Her fate is directly tied to the events surrounding the Whispering Hillock.
The Orphans: Children from Velen are often sent to Crookback Bog, ostensibly to be cared for by the Crones. In reality, they are groomed for servitude or worse – a grim fate that hangs heavy over the entire narrative.

The Two Paths: Freedom vs. Destruction

You are presented with two primary choices:

Free the Spirit: Trust the spirit’s promises, perform the ritual to release it, and let it fulfill its alleged goal of saving the orphans.
Kill the Spirit: Heed the warnings of the villagers, confront the spirit, and destroy it to prevent further harm.

The Consequences of Freedom

If you choose to free the spirit, several significant events unfold:

Downwarren is Destroyed: The freed spirit, in its equine form, rampages through the village of Downwarren, slaughtering its inhabitants. The promises of a benevolent savior are shattered as the true nature of the entity is revealed.
The Baron’s Tragedy: Anna, due to the Crones’ fury at the escape of the orphans, is cursed and transformed into a water hag. The Baron, consumed by grief, eventually hangs himself. This results in one of the most bleak and tragic endings possible.
The Orphans are Saved (Initially): The spirit does manage to rescue the orphans from the Crones’ clutches, at least temporarily. They are initially safe, but their future remains uncertain, having lost their homes and families.

The Consequences of Destruction

Choosing to kill the spirit results in a different set of consequences:

Downwarren is Spared: The village remains intact, and its inhabitants are safe from the spirit’s wrath.
The Baron Has a Chance at Redemption: While Anna remains in the Crones’ clutches, there is still a possibility of curing her and achieving a more hopeful ending for the Baron’s storyline.
The Orphans Are Doomed: The Crones retain control over the orphans, condemning them to a grim fate within Crookback Bog.

Why Killing the Spirit is the “Lesser Evil”

While neither choice is perfect, killing the spirit generally leads to a less devastating outcome. Here’s why:

The Spirit’s Deception: The spirit is not what it seems. It uses the plight of the orphans as a manipulative tactic to achieve its own goals, regardless of the cost to human lives.
A Choice Between Two Evils: In the world of The Witcher, rarely are there truly “good” choices. You are often forced to choose between two undesirable outcomes. Sacrificing the orphans to potentially save Downwarren and give the Baron a chance at redemption is arguably the lesser evil.
Long-Term Impact: While the immediate impact of saving the orphans might seem appealing, the long-term consequences of releasing the spirit are far more detrimental, leading to widespread death and suffering.

Considering the Lore

The lore surrounding the Crones and ancient spirits within the Witcher universe suggests that these entities are often powerful, dangerous, and ultimately self-serving. Trusting them blindly is almost always a mistake. The article “Teaching Complex Systems Through Games” published by the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org indicates that, like many system based video games, careful deliberation, and research within the game are necessary to be successful, and to avoid pitfalls within the game.

Making Your Choice

Ultimately, the decision of whether to free the spirit or kill it is a personal one. There is no “right” or “wrong” answer. However, based on the evidence presented within the game and the potential consequences of each choice, killing the spirit is generally the more responsible and ethically sound option. It minimizes the overall suffering and provides a glimmer of hope for a better future, however slim.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Here are 15 frequently asked questions that address specific aspects of the “Whispering Hillock” quest:

What happens if I free the spirit before meeting the Crones? If you free the spirit before interacting with the Crones, Anna’s fate is slightly altered. She still suffers, but instead of transforming into a water hag, she goes mad. The Baron will then attempt to take her away to find a cure.
Can I save both the orphans and Anna? Unfortunately, no. The game’s narrative structure prevents you from achieving a truly happy ending for everyone involved. Your choices force you to sacrifice one group to potentially save another.
Is the Ghost in the Tree good or bad? The Ghost in the Tree is presented as a morally ambiguous character, but its actions ultimately reveal its destructive and self-serving nature. It cannot be considered a “good” entity.
What does the spirit promise if I free it? The spirit promises to save the orphans from the Crones and provide them with a better life. However, this promise comes at the cost of innocent lives.
Does freeing the spirit affect other quests? Yes, freeing the spirit directly impacts the quests related to the Baron and Anna, significantly altering their storylines.
Can I kill the spirit after agreeing to free it? No, once you commit to freeing the spirit by performing the ritual, you cannot change your mind and kill it.
What is the best ending for the Baron? The “best” ending for the Baron involves saving Anna, even if she’s not fully cured, and him taking her away to seek further treatment. This outcome is only possible if you kill the spirit.
What are the consequences of ignoring the Whispering Hillock quest? Ignoring the quest will result in the Crones continuing to control the orphans and potentially worsening the situation in Velen.
Is there a way to trick the spirit? There is no way to trick the spirit into acting benevolently or altering the outcome of its release.
How do I kill the spirit in the tree? To kill the spirit, refuse to help it when it asks you to perform the ritual. Instead, inform the ealdorman of Downwarren and participate in the hunt to slay the monster.
What rewards do I get for completing the Whispering Hillock quest? The rewards for completing the quest vary depending on your choices. You may receive experience points, gold, and potentially a weapon.
Does the choice affect my relationship with any characters? Yes, the choice affects your relationship with the Baron and the villagers of Downwarren, depending on your actions.
Why do the Crones want to punish Anna? If you free the spirit, the Crones become enraged because Anna is seen as complicit in breaking a promise. This is why freeing the spirit after speaking to the crones has especially nasty consequences for Anna.
Can I avoid the consequences by completing the quest in a specific order? While the order of completing quests can influence minor details, the fundamental consequences of freeing or killing the spirit remain the same.
Is there any way to know for sure what the spirit’s true intentions are? The game provides strong hints and clues that suggest the spirit is not trustworthy, but ultimately, you must rely on your own judgment and understanding of the Witcher universe to make your decision.