Should You Keep Silas Alive in The Quarry? A Comprehensive Guide
The question of whether to spare or eliminate Silas Vorez, the central werewolf antagonist in The Quarry, is a critical decision that significantly impacts the game’s outcome. The short answer is: no, you should not keep Silas alive. While the game presents several branching paths and possibilities, allowing Silas to live ultimately leads to a significantly worse ending for the main characters and leaves the werewolf curse unresolved. This article will delve into why killing Silas is the optimal choice and explore the consequences of alternative decisions, followed by 15 key FAQs to fully address this crucial aspect of The Quarry.
Why Killing Silas is the Best Outcome
The narrative of The Quarry revolves around a curse passed down through werewolf bites, stemming from the original werewolf, Silas. The game makes it clear that the curse is tied directly to him. The game explicitly states that killing Silas breaks the curse chain, meaning that all infected individuals, or at least those who were bitten by Silas directly, are cured. This includes pivotal characters like Nick, who is almost certain to become a werewolf unless Silas is eliminated.
The ‘True Good Ending’
The game explicitly labels the ending where Silas is killed as the “true good ending”. This is not merely an opinion; it’s a narrative point strongly supported by in-game evidence. This conclusion isn’t just about ending the immediate threat; it’s about saving the majority of the cast from a life-altering curse. By eliminating Silas, you secure the survival and well-being of most, if not all, of the counselors, effectively completing the goal of the story and solving the core mystery of the game. This outcome is also tied to the White Wolf achievement, further emphasizing its narrative importance.
The Consequences of Letting Silas Live
Choosing to spare Silas will lead to multiple negative consequences. First and foremost, Laura and Sheriff Travis Hackett will almost certainly die. The conflict continues, and without the root cause of the werewolf curse eliminated, their inevitable fight escalates to a fatal confrontation. This not only sacrifices important characters, but also undermines the hard work of the players who tried to navigate the intricate web of choices made throughout the game. The survivors will remain infected and potentially become dangerous, thus further complicating the ending. Additionally, not killing Silas prevents Nick from being cured and ultimately makes the story feel unresolved and tragic.
The Importance of the ‘Raise Gun’ Option
In the final confrontation, when the game prompts you, the correct choice is to select the ‘Raise Gun’ option. This sets up the opportunity to directly engage Silas with the correct outcome. If you try to take a different path or simply fail the Quick Time Events (QTE) during the confrontation, you might find yourself forced into an option where Silas survives, thus leading to an unsatisfactory ending.
Beyond the Immediate Encounter
Beyond the immediate encounter, consider the broader implications of Silas’ survival. It’s more than just about escaping the night; it’s about resolving the very curse that has plagued the Hacketts and the campers. Allowing Silas to live ensures that the werewolf threat continues, making the hard earned victory feel pyrrhic, leaving more questions than answers.
Related Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Does Killing Silas Cure Everyone?
Yes, killing Silas directly breaks the curse for those directly infected by him, effectively curing characters like Nick if he is alive. This resolution is a key part of the “true good ending.”
2. Is Silas Truly Evil?
Silas is the main antagonist in The Quarry because he is a source of the werewolf curse. While his origins are tragic, his actions make him dangerous and he is the core of the werewolf problem.
3. What Happens If Laura Refuses to Shoot Silas?
If Laura refuses, Travis will try to take the gun, which will likely lead to a fatal confrontation between the two or with Silas depending on the choices the player makes during the QTE.
4. Can You Save Everyone Without Killing Silas?
No, you cannot save everyone without killing Silas. The game is structured so that his death is necessary to break the curse and secure the best possible outcome for the majority of the counselors.
5. Why Do the Hacketts Cover Themselves in Blood?
The Hackett family covers themselves in blood as a means of protection from the werewolves, believing it can disguise their human scent.
6. What Happens If You Don’t Shoot the Grandma in The Quarry?
If Constance Hackett isn’t killed in the exchange, she’ll argue with Travis and Jedediah about Laura. You’ll then face a choice involving Bobby and Ryan, which only changes the order of events, not the overall outcome.
7. Did Silas Bite Dylan?
Yes, Dylan can be bitten by Silas during the radio hut attack. This makes Dylan another character whose fate is tied to killing Silas for a possible cure.
8. Can You Save Kaylee Hackett?
No, Kaylee Hackett will always die. She is shot by Laura in a case of mistaken identity. No decision can change this outcome.
9. Does Laura Have to Bite Ryan?
Yes, Laura should bite Ryan if he has a serious wound that is making him weak. This is to save his life. If Ryan doesn’t consent to the bite he will die later on from blood loss.
10. Does Nick Turn Into a Werewolf?
Yes, Nick will turn into a werewolf unless Silas is killed to break the curse, making it even more important to ensure Silas is defeated.
11. Can Abi Get Infected in The Quarry?
Yes, Abi can be infected through a few different scenarios. This emphasizes that the werewolf threat is not just limited to one or two characters.
12. Why Was Travis Killed off?
In relation to the Fear the Walking Dead context, Travis’s actor, Cliff Curtis, was already in Avatar filming sequels. As for the narrative within that series, the death was meant to move the story forward by putting other characters in the spotlight and driving the plot.
13. What Does Travis See in the Mirror?
Travis sees a reflection of himself as other people would see him in his final moments, a man who committed murder, regardless of circumstance.
14. Should Max Stay on the Island?
No, Max should not stay on the island. If he swims to shore, he will be immediately killed by a werewolf. Staying on the island is the better alternative until morning.
15. Who Is the Easiest to Save in The Quarry?
Nick Furcillo is often considered the easiest character to save because he’s directly impacted by the final confrontation with Silas. His fate hinges on that single moment.
Conclusion: The Path to a Happy Ending Lies Through Silas
In conclusion, while The Quarry presents multiple choices, the decision regarding Silas is pivotal. Allowing Silas to live not only results in the deaths of key characters, but also undermines the central narrative of overcoming the werewolf curse. The best and most satisfactory ending is achieved by eliminating Silas, breaking the curse chain, and saving the infected counselors. This outcome is consistent with the game’s narrative and provides a more fulfilling resolution. By choosing to raise the gun and ending Silas’ threat, you secure the best possible future for the survivors of Hackett’s Quarry.