Unraveling the Mystery: What Happens After Giving D the Dagger in Elden Ring?
After handing the Weathered Dagger to D, Hunter of the Dead, a chain of events is set in motion that significantly impacts several questlines and character arcs within Elden Ring. Directly after giving him the dagger, D will acknowledge it, expressing his intent to return it to its rightful owner. The next key event unfolds upon your next visit to Roundtable Hold. A door, previously locked, will now be open in the hallway past Smith Master Hewg and Roderika. Inside this room, you’ll discover D murdered, with Fia standing over his corpse. This act marks a turning point in Fia’s questline and opens up new avenues for exploration and character interaction.
The Immediate Aftermath: Death and Discovery
The discovery of D’s murder is a pivotal moment. Fia’s presence over the body confirms her involvement, adding a layer of complexity to her character. She violates the sacred laws of the Roundtable Hold, where violence is forbidden amongst the Tarnished. This act solidifies her position as a figure operating outside the established order.
This event also kicks off a secondary quest involving D’s twin brother. Players are presented with the option to give D’s brother his armor. Doing so will eventually lead to him seeking revenge on Fia. Choosing to intervene and avenge D is a significant decision that influences the story’s direction.
Long-Term Consequences and Questline Implications
The consequences of this event extend far beyond the immediate aftermath:
- Fia’s Questline Progression: D’s death is essential for advancing Fia’s questline, which eventually leads to the Age of the Duskborn ending.
- D’s Twin Brother Questline: Finding D’s brother at the Aqueduct-Facing Cliffs in Siofra Aqueduct and providing him with the Twinned Armor Set will trigger his quest for revenge.
- Access to New Areas: D’s death indirectly grants access to new areas. Completing Fia’s questline allows entry to the Deathbed Dream and the fight against Lichdragon Fortissax.
- Rewards and Items: Completing the various stages related to this event unlocks access to unique items, including the Mending Rune of the Death Prince, required for the Age of the Duskborn ending, and D’s equipment if you choose to give his brother the armor.
The interactions stemming from giving D the dagger are not mere side quests; they are integral to understanding the overarching narrative and achieving specific endings. The choices made after this point will have profound consequences on the world and your character’s destiny.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about D and Fia’s Questline
1. Where do I find D after giving him the dagger?
After giving D the Weathered Dagger, you will find him dead in the room past Smith Master Hewg in the Roundtable Hold upon your next visit. Fia will be standing over his body.
2. Where is Fia after killing D?
Fia remains in the room near Hewg, standing over D’s corpse. You can interact with her to progress her questline.
3. Should I give D, Hunter of the Dead, the Weathered Dagger?
Yes, giving D the Weathered Dagger is crucial for progressing both D’s and Fia’s questlines. Refusing to give it will halt their respective storylines.
4. What do I do after D is killed by Fia?
After finding D’s body and Fia, speak to her to learn more about her motives. Then, seek out D’s twin brother at the Aqueduct-Facing Cliffs in Siofra Aqueduct and consider giving him the Twinned Armor Set to pursue revenge. Continue with Fia’s questline to ultimately gain the Mending Rune of the Death Prince.
5. Does it matter if D kills Fia?
D himself doesn’t kill Fia. His twin brother does, but only if you give him the Twinned Armor Set. If you choose this path, he will eventually seek out and kill Fia later in her questline.
6. What happens when Fia kills D?
When Fia kills D, it violates the sacred law of the Roundtable Hold. It also progresses Fia’s questline and opens up the opportunity to find D’s twin brother and seek revenge.
7. Is Fia in Elden Ring evil?
Whether Fia is “evil” is a matter of perspective. She acts out of a desire to protect Those Who Live in Death, and her actions are driven by her belief in their right to exist. Her methods, including killing D, are controversial, but her motivations are not simply malicious.
8. When should I give the dagger to D?
You should give the Weathered Dagger to D as soon as you receive it from Fia in the Altus Plateau. This triggers the next stage of their respective questlines.
9. Should I show Deathroot to D?
Showing D Deathroot is a separate but related questline. While not directly tied to the Weathered Dagger quest, showing him Deathroot will unlock further dialogue and insights into his mission to eradicate Those Who Live in Death.
10. Does killing Fia affect the ending?
Killing Fia before completing her questline will prevent you from obtaining the Mending Rune of the Death Prince and achieving the Age of the Duskborn ending. However, if D’s brother kills her after she gives you the rune, it does not affect the ending.
11. Should I give D’s brother the armor?
Giving D’s brother the Twinned Armor Set will lead to him killing Fia later in her quest. This doesn’t affect the availability of the Age of the Duskborn ending, but it does alter the narrative flow and gives you his weapon, the Twinned Knight Swords. This is a matter of personal preference.
12. What happens if you let Fia hold you?
Letting Fia hold you grants you the Baldachin’s Blessing, an item that temporarily boosts your poise. However, it also applies a debuff that reduces your maximum HP by 5%. You can return to Fia for additional blessings if needed.
13. Can I get D’s sword?
Yes, you can obtain D’s sword, the Twinned Knight Swords, but only after giving the Twinned Armor Set to his brother. After he kills Fia and you defeat Lichdragon Fortissax, you can find the swords in the Deeproot Depths where his brother was resting.
14. Can I do both Fia and Ranni’s questlines?
Absolutely! Completing both Fia’s and Ranni’s questlines is possible and unlocks multiple ending options. In fact, completing Ranni’s quest is even required to finish Fia’s. There are no conflicts between the two. The Games Learning Society emphasizes the importance of complex narratives and choices in games, and these intertwined quests perfectly exemplify that principle.
15. Can I stop D’s brother from killing Fia?
Yes, you can prevent D’s brother from killing Fia by not giving him the Twinned Armor Set. If you keep the armor, he will remain asleep and Fia will survive until the end of her quest.
This intricate web of choices and consequences is what makes Elden Ring such a compelling and rewarding experience. By understanding the implications of your actions, you can shape the fate of the Lands Between and achieve the ending you desire. For more information on game design and narrative complexity, check out GamesLearningSociety.org.