The Brutal Choices of Liberty City: A Deep Dive into GTA IV’s Deal vs. Revenge Endings
The culmination of Grand Theft Auto IV (GTA IV) hinges on a pivotal decision that irrevocably shapes the narrative and the fates of its characters: the “Deal” or “Revenge” ending. This choice, presented to Niko Bellic in the penultimate mission, dictates the final mission he undertakes and the ultimate consequences he must bear. Let’s break down each ending and explore the ripple effects they have on the story.
In the “Deal” ending, Niko accepts a deal orchestrated by mob boss Jimmy Pegorino to engage in a drug transaction with the main antagonist, Dimitri Rascalov. This decision, driven by a desire for financial stability, proves catastrophic. The deal goes awry, and during Roman Bellic’s wedding, Dimitri’s assassin fatally shoots Roman.
Conversely, the “Revenge” ending sees Niko rejecting the deal and instead pursuing vengeance against Dimitri Rascalov. Niko succeeds in killing Dimitri, only to face the wrath of Jimmy Pegorino. In retaliation for Niko’s actions, Pegorino attacks Roman’s wedding, resulting in the death of Kate McReary, Niko’s love interest.
Essentially, one choice sacrifices financial gain for a chance at retribution, while the other gambles on a business deal that ultimately explodes in violence and heartbreak. Regardless of the decision, Niko experiences profound loss, highlighting the game’s central themes of betrayal, the corrupting influence of money, and the elusive nature of the American Dream.
Understanding the Deal Ending: A Path to Tragedy
The Drug Deal Gone Wrong
In the “Deal” ending, Niko agrees to participate in the drug deal, hoping to secure a substantial sum of money to start a new life with Roman and Mallorie. However, Dimitri Rascalov, a master of double-crossing, betrays Pegorino and steals the drugs and the money, plunging Niko into a desperate situation.
Roman’s Wedding and a Devastating Loss
Despite the failed deal, Roman proceeds with his wedding to Mallorie. The wedding scene is meant to be a moment of joy and hope, but it’s quickly shattered by tragedy. Dimitri, seeking to eliminate all loose ends, sends an assassin who aims for Niko but tragically kills Roman instead. This loss devastates Niko, leaving him consumed by grief and a renewed thirst for revenge.
The Final Confrontation with Dimitri
Niko, fueled by rage and a desire to avenge Roman, hunts down Dimitri for a final showdown. The confrontation is brutal and cathartic, ultimately leading to Dimitri’s demise. However, the victory is hollow, as Niko is left with the haunting reality of Roman’s death. The deal, intended to bring financial security, instead brought unimaginable pain and loss.
Exploring the Revenge Ending: A Pyrrhic Victory
Rejecting the Deal and Seeking Vengeance
In the “Revenge” ending, Niko rejects Pegorino’s offer, understanding that dealing with Dimitri is inherently treacherous. Instead, he chooses to eliminate Dimitri, believing it to be the only way to truly break free from his past and protect those he cares about.
Roman’s Wedding and Another Heartbreaking Loss
Despite eliminating Dimitri, the violence doesn’t end. Jimmy Pegorino, enraged by Niko’s betrayal and the disruption of his plans, launches an attack on Roman’s wedding as an act of revenge. In the chaos, Kate McReary, who has grown close to Niko and represents a chance at genuine happiness, is tragically killed.
The Final Showdown with Pegorino
Niko, heartbroken and driven by vengeance, pursues Pegorino to a final confrontation. The battle is intense, culminating in Niko finally killing Pegorino and avenging Kate’s death. However, this victory is bittersweet. While Niko achieves his revenge, he does so at the cost of the woman he loved, leaving him with profound regret and a lasting sense of loss.
Which Ending is Canon? The Debate Rages On
Rockstar Games has never explicitly stated which ending of GTA IV is considered canon within the Grand Theft Auto universe. However, there are subtle hints that suggest the “Revenge” ending might be the preferred narrative path.
Hints and Implications
- Character Development: The “Revenge” ending allows for Roman to live and potentially start a family, offering a glimmer of hope amidst the darkness. This aligns better with the overall theme of seeking a better life.
- Narrative Impact: The death of Kate McReary carries a heavier emotional weight, highlighting the tragic consequences of Niko’s past and the cyclical nature of violence.
While the “Revenge” ending is often perceived as the more fitting conclusion, the ambiguity allows players to interpret the story in their own way. The brilliance of GTA IV lies in its ability to present morally complex choices with lasting consequences, blurring the lines between right and wrong.
FAQs: Unpacking the Endings of GTA IV
1. Is there a “good” ending in GTA IV?
No, neither the “Deal” nor the “Revenge” ending can be considered a “good” ending. Both result in significant loss and underscore the tragic nature of Niko Bellic’s story. The game explores themes of violence, betrayal, and the elusive nature of the American Dream, and both endings reflect these themes.
2. Which ending gives you more money?
The financial reward is the same, $250,000, regardless of whether you choose the “Deal” or “Revenge” ending. However, in the “Deal” ending, you receive the money before the final mission, whereas in the “Revenge” ending, you receive it after the final mission.
3. Does your relationship with Kate change depending on the ending?
Yes. If you choose the “Deal” ending and Roman dies, Kate becomes distant and disapproving of Niko’s decision to prioritize money over revenge. In the “Revenge” ending, Kate is killed, so there’s no further interaction with her.
4. Can you save both Roman and Kate?
Unfortunately, no. The game mechanics force you to choose between prioritizing money (leading to Roman’s death) or pursuing revenge (leading to Kate’s death).
5. What happens to Mallorie in each ending?
In both endings, Mallorie is pregnant with Roman’s child. In the “Deal” ending, she’s left widowed but with the prospect of a new life. In the “Revenge” ending, she still has Roman by her side, offering a more hopeful future.
6. What are the names of the final missions in each ending?
The final mission in the “Deal” ending is “A Revenger’s Tragedy,” while the final mission in the “Revenge” ending is “Out of Commission.”
7. How does the choice affect Niko’s character arc?
The choice profoundly impacts Niko’s character arc. The “Deal” ending can be seen as a betrayal of his principles, while the “Revenge” ending highlights his struggle to escape the cycle of violence. Both outcomes leave him emotionally scarred and questioning his choices.
8. Does the “Revenge” ending make Niko a more sympathetic character?
Many players find Niko more sympathetic in the “Revenge” ending, as he ultimately prioritizes justice and loyalty over financial gain, even at a great personal cost.
9. Is it worth replaying GTA IV to experience both endings?
Absolutely. Experiencing both endings provides a deeper understanding of the game’s themes and the complexities of Niko’s character. It allows players to grapple with the moral dilemmas presented by the story and form their own interpretations.
10. What makes GTA IV’s endings so impactful?
The endings are impactful because they force players to confront the consequences of their actions. The game doesn’t offer a fairytale ending; instead, it presents a realistic portrayal of loss, regret, and the lasting impact of violence. This aligns with research from the Games Learning Society highlighting the power of games to explore complex social and ethical issues.
11. How does GTA IV’s ending compare to other GTA games?
GTA IV’s ending is arguably more emotionally resonant and morally ambiguous than the endings of other GTA games. It focuses on personal loss and the complexities of human relationships, rather than solely on achieving wealth or power.
12. Can you continue playing after the final mission?
Yes, after completing either ending, you can continue to explore Liberty City and complete any remaining side missions or activities. However, the main storyline is concluded.
13. Are there any Easter eggs or secrets related to the endings?
While there aren’t any specific Easter eggs tied directly to the endings, exploring Liberty City after completing the game can reveal new dialogue or interactions that reflect the chosen ending and its impact on the characters.
14. What’s the general consensus among players about which ending is better?
There’s no definitive consensus. Some players prefer the “Revenge” ending for its perceived narrative coherence and the opportunity to see Roman survive. Others find the “Deal” ending more tragic and thought-provoking, highlighting the corrupting influence of money and the futility of Niko’s pursuit of the American Dream.
15. How can games like GTA IV be used for educational purposes?
Games like GTA IV can be used to explore themes of morality, ethics, and social commentary. They can also be used to analyze narrative structures, character development, and the impact of player choice. GamesLearningSociety.org promotes the research and educational use of video games.
In conclusion, the endings of GTA IV are a testament to the game’s complex narrative and its ability to provoke thought and emotion in its players. Whether you choose the path of “Deal” or “Revenge,” you’re guaranteed a memorable and impactful experience.