The Consequences of Alice’s Death in Detroit: Become Human
Alice’s fate in Detroit: Become Human is intricately woven into the narrative, and her death has significant repercussions on the story, especially for Kara. If Alice dies, the ramifications are profound, impacting Kara’s emotional state, the available endings, and the overall thematic weight of the game. Her death represents a tragic loss, often cutting short the potential for a hopeful conclusion. The specific circumstances of her death heavily influence the storyline. For example, if Todd kills Alice before Kara can intervene, their entire storyline is abruptly terminated, resulting in a short, unsatisfying conclusion. In other scenarios, Alice’s death can occur later in the game, such as during the escape from the coastguard, leading to a somber and solitary path for Kara. The primary consequence is that Kara will no longer have the driving force that motivates her character throughout the game, significantly altering the dynamic and emotional core of the story. It typically results in a much bleaker ending for Kara, focusing on her survival in a world where she has lost her purpose, or simply ending the storyline entirely.
Specific Scenarios and Their Outcomes
Early Deaths: Todd’s Rampage
One of the most brutal ways Alice can die is early in the game during the “Stormy Night” chapter. If Kara fails to intervene when Todd’s rampage escalates, he will beat Alice and kill her. This scenario results in a “bad ending” where the Kara and Alice story concludes prematurely. There is no further opportunity for their storyline to develop, and the player is presented with a finale cutscene signifying the end of their journey.
Highway Tragedy
Later, during the escape sequence, if Kara and Alice die on the highway, their story also ends. In the event Connor gives up chasing Kara and Alice after being ordered by Hank and they are unable to navigate the highway, both characters perish. This results in a unique scene where Hank’s distress at their death is witnessed by Connor, adding a layer of emotional complexity to Connor’s development.
River Crossing
Another key point where Alice’s survival is at risk is during the river crossing scene. If you choose to either “hide” or “accelerate” while being attacked by the coastguard, Alice can be wounded. This injury can prove fatal, leading to Alice dying on the shore. This results in a heartbroken Kara needing to make the choice to continue living without her. The way Kara survives after this is another story entirely, as it usually ends with a lonely ending.
Other Fatal Encounters
Throughout their journey, Kara and Alice encounter numerous perils. Allowing Alice’s panic to overwhelm her when they find shelter results in the two being gunned down by authorities. Failing to follow the correct prompts when avoiding conflict with the police will almost certainly result in Alice getting fatally injured. These are key moments where a player’s decisions impact whether Alice survives.
Impact on Kara’s Storyline
Alice’s death deeply impacts Kara, often resulting in a significantly darker and emotionally desolate experience. It removes the core motivation of protecting Alice which drives her actions. Without Alice, Kara may become emotionally distant and focus solely on survival. The potential for a “happy ending,” such as crossing the Canadian border with Alice and finding freedom, is no longer attainable. It often leaves Kara’s ending feeling incomplete and unsatisfying as she becomes alone in the world.
Furthermore, the player is not able to achieve the desired “good ending” with Alice dead, the primary goal of which is to see Kara and Alice make it to the border and gain their freedom.
Alternative Outcomes
While many choices can lead to Alice’s death, the game also offers opportunities to save her and obtain a happy ending for Kara and Alice. The most important factor is ensuring Alice stays healthy by not picking any dialogue or prompts that could put her at risk. The way a player chooses to move through the game, and the decisions made affect the likelihood of survival immensely.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Is it possible to save Alice in Detroit: Become Human?
Yes, it is absolutely possible to save Alice. The “happiest River ending” sees both Kara and Alice survive the encounter with the coastguard. This requires either diving into the water or hiding behind Luther when attacked, and ensuring they reach shore unharmed.
2. What happens if Kara and Alice both die?
If both Kara and Alice die, their storyline typically ends prematurely. Depending on the point of their death, there may be a unique scene, but their journey ends, and the player will not be able to continue their story.
3. Can Kara survive without Alice?
Yes, Kara can survive without Alice, but it often leads to a more somber ending. This occurs usually after Alice dies in the River crossing scene. Kara can choose to carry on with her life alone after this loss.
4. What is the worst way for Alice to die?
The worst scenario is arguably when Todd kills Alice in the “Stormy Night” chapter. This is not only violent but also ends their story very early in the game, depriving the player of a chance for a fulfilling narrative.
5. Does Alice call Kara ‘mom’?
Yes, in many of their endings, especially if the player has formed a strong bond between them, Alice will call Kara “mom” or “I love you, Kara” This reinforces the powerful emotional connection between the two.
6. Can Alice die if Kara is distant towards her?
Yes, if Kara is distant with Alice throughout the game and particularly at Jericho, Alice (and Luther) may leave her. If Jericho is attacked, Kara may end up saving herself, thus leading to Alice’s death.
7. Can Alice die even if Kara is trying to protect her?
Yes, Alice’s survival is not only about Kara’s protective decisions but about the quick-time event choices that a player makes. If Kara does not correctly avoid dangers, it can lead to Alice’s death, even if Kara has been trying to protect her.
8. What choice should Kara make during the border scene to ensure Alice’s safety?
In the border scene, choosing “no sacrifice” when a peaceful protest is in progress, can allow Kara, Alice, and Luther to pass safely into Canada. This relies heavily on Markus’s choices throughout the game.
9. What happens if Alice gets wounded by the coastguard?
If Alice gets wounded by the coastguard, she will likely die when Kara reaches the shore, and Kara may have to continue without her.
10. What happens if Kara does not save Alice during an attack?
If Kara does not save Alice during an attack or fails to reassure her, Alice can get killed by the authorities. This is a direct consequence of Kara’s inaction or bad decisions.
11. Can Connor catch Kara?
Yes, Connor can catch Kara during chase scenes. Hitting all the quick-time event prompts successfully can cause Connor to grab Kara, which means more struggle prompts before she can get away.
12. What happens if Kara plays dead during the border crossing?
Choosing to play dead during the border crossing is a critical choice that allows both Kara and Alice to survive. Any other choice will almost certainly end their storyline.
13. Is there a way to prevent Alice from getting hurt at all?
Yes, the safest option during the coastguard scene to prevent Alice from getting hurt is to either dive into the water or hide behind Luther. Successfully completing the prompts after this allows them to survive the ordeal.
14. What is the “best ending” for Kara and Alice?
The best ending for Kara and Alice is when they make it safely across the border into Canada along with Luther. They would not have sacrificed themselves or anyone else, allowing them to find freedom.
15. Can Alice die and Kara still get a “good ending”?
No, if Alice dies, Kara cannot get her “good ending”. The “good ending” for Kara is almost always tied to her having a safe ending with Alice in tow.