The Grim Fate: What Happens if Todd Kills Alice in Detroit: Become Human?
The stakes in Detroit: Become Human are incredibly high, and the consequences of player choices are often brutal. One of the most heart-wrenching scenarios involves the young android, Alice, and her abusive guardian, Todd. If Todd kills Alice, the game presents a swift and devastating ending for their storyline. This outcome usually unfolds during the “Stormy Night” chapter. When Kara fails to intervene, or if she fails to successfully protect Alice, the scene fades to black with the sound of Alice’s screams, marking a definitive and tragic end for both Alice and, potentially, Kara. This event triggers a “bad ending” cutscene that solidifies the finality of their fate. Their narrative arc is abruptly concluded, emphasizing the importance of making protective choices for Alice during this critical juncture.
The Weight of Player Choices: A Story Cut Short
The death of Alice at the hands of Todd serves as a harsh lesson on the weight of choices in Detroit: Become Human. It exemplifies how crucial it is to react quickly and decisively. The game doesn’t shy away from depicting the consequences of inaction or poor decisions. Should the player fail to calm Alice down when her stress levels are high, and then not intervene when Todd attacks, the result is fatal. This scenario highlights that sometimes reasoning with Todd is a futile effort and that direct intervention is necessary to save Alice. This ending also underscores how easily the delicate bond between Kara and Alice can be shattered by violence.
The Triggers for Alice’s Death
Several factors can lead to this tragic outcome. Failing to reassure Alice when she’s scared or choosing not to stay with her can elevate her panic. If her fear reaches a critical point, Todd’s violent nature is unleashed, and if Kara doesn’t act to protect her, Alice will get gunned down by Todd. The game leaves no room for indecisiveness. The player must quickly recognize the threat Todd poses and choose a path that prioritizes Alice’s safety, usually by actively confronting Todd or fleeing with her.
The Absence of Redemption
Unlike some other characters in the game, where there are multiple opportunities to redeem past mistakes, the death of Alice is final. This outcome sharply contrasts with the potential “good ending” where Kara, Alice, and Luther (sometimes) escape to freedom in Canada. It’s a powerful reminder that not all characters are guaranteed safety, and the player’s role is not merely as an observer but as a crucial participant in their fates.
The Significance of the “Stormy Night” Chapter
The “Stormy Night” chapter is a crucial turning point in the game. It’s here that the players fully understand the abusive dynamic between Todd and Alice, and it forces them to make immediate decisions. Choosing to reason with Todd, as the text highlights, gets you absolutely nowhere. The best outcome is to ignore him and go straight upstairs. The actions taken during this chapter will greatly influence whether Alice survives to the end.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some frequently asked questions related to the fate of Alice in Detroit: Become Human:
-
What exactly happens if Kara doesn’t save Alice during the “Stormy Night” chapter?
If Kara fails to protect Alice, she is killed by Todd. This happens when she doesn’t intervene while Todd is attacking, or fails to reassure her when she is panicked leading to Todd shooting her. The scene fades to black accompanied by Alice’s scream, and their storyline ends abruptly. -
Is it possible to prevent Alice from being harmed by Todd?
Yes, it’s absolutely possible. By reacting quickly, going to her immediately, ignoring Todd, and opting to protect her directly, players can prevent Todd from killing her. There is also the option to grab the gun in Todd’s room if you’ve discovered it previously and use it to defend Alice. -
What are the consequences if Kara tries to reason with Todd instead of protecting Alice?
Reasoning with Todd is generally unproductive. The game clearly states that it “gets you absolutely nowhere.” It wastes valuable time, leaving Alice vulnerable and increasing the likelihood of her death. Therefore, direct action is essential in the situation. -
Can Todd be seen again in the game if he is not killed in “Stormy Night?”
Yes, if Todd is not killed, he appears again in the “Battle for Detroit” chapter if Kara, Alice, and (optionally) Luther make it to the bus depot. He tries to claim that Kara stole Alice and calls for security. -
What happens if Kara and Alice die on the highway?
If Kara and Alice fail to cross the highway and die, and Connor fails to catch them (due to Hank’s orders), the emotionally distraught scene with Hank will play as normal but will include Connor’s presence. -
Is there a possibility for Kara to survive if Alice is killed?
Yes, Kara can survive even if Alice is killed, but it generally means that their shared narrative ends in tragedy. The rest of the game would unfold with Kara dealing with the consequences of her failure to save Alice. -
What happens if Kara doesn’t find an escape and is relying on Markus for help?
If Kara and Alice don’t escape on their own and Markus saves the camp, they will avoid being sent to the recycling center. It’s another way for Kara and Alice to survive if you don’t have a clear escape route. -
What is the best ending for Kara?
Kara’s best ending is to escape over the border into Canada without sacrificing herself or anyone else, which usually includes Alice and Luther. They are free and able to start a new life together. -
How can you achieve the “happiest” ending for Kara and Alice near the river?
To achieve the best River ending, either dive into the water or hide behind Luther when the coastguard attacks. Both Kara and Alice should come out unharmed, and if you move swiftly, you can reach the shore. -
How do you make Kara shoot Todd?
After Kara becomes a deviant, she needs to run upstairs and grab the gun from Todd’s room, if she discovered it in the chapter “A New Home”. When she follows Todd to Alice’s room, the gun will be drawn automatically, and then there’ll be a QTE sequence where Kara will defend herself, ending with her shooting Todd. -
What happens if Kara abandons Alice?
If Kara abandons Alice, and Markus doesn’t rescue her, she will die in the recycling machine. If they both fail to escape, they will be either shot by soldiers or die in the same machine. -
Does Alice refer to Kara as “Mom”?
Yes, in many of their endings, Alice refers to Kara with words like “I love you, Kara” or “I love you, Mom,” indicating a strong, maternal bond. -
What happens if Kara gets reset?
If Kara is reset, she makes her way to Luther and can regain her memories by interacting with the environment. She is driven to find Alice after this. -
Is it necessary for Kara to play dead to survive?
Yes, in certain scenarios. Choosing any options other than “PLAY DEAD” and “DON’T MOVE” will result in both Kara and Alice getting killed, and will prevent the “Good Ending” from being achieved. -
What are the implications if Kara chooses to sacrifice herself?
If Kara chooses to sacrifice herself, the guard will comfort Alice. Alternatively, if Kara chooses “No Sacrifice” during a peaceful protest led by Markus, the guard will likely allow them to enter Canada, despite knowing they’re androids, showing compassion.
The possibility of Todd killing Alice in Detroit: Become Human is a stark reminder of the high stakes involved in this interactive narrative. It showcases the weight of choices, the fragility of life, and the importance of decisive action. The tragic ending serves to underscore the responsibility players have over the fates of these characters and the impact of each decision along the way.