What happens if you don’t choose Ashley or Josh?

If you don’t make a choice, the saw will kill Josh, and the resulting dialogue will be as if you chose to save Ashley, instead of saving Josh and noticing that the trap didn’t work as intended. This outcome is a pivotal moment in the game Until Dawn, showcasing the Butterfly Effect where player choices significantly impact the storyline and character fates.

Understanding the Consequences

The decision not to choose between Ashley and Josh leads to a specific sequence of events, emphasizing the game’s dynamic storytelling. The saw trap is designed to target Josh, regardless of the player’s choice, due to the nature of the trap being an elaborate prank by Josh himself. This prank gone wrong sets the stage for the consequences of not choosing, which are felt throughout the game as Ashley and Josh interact with other characters, influenced by the player’s actions or lack thereof.

Exploring Related Questions

To delve deeper into the world of Until Dawn and understand the complexities of player choice, let’s examine some frequently asked questions related to the game’s storyline and mechanics.

FAQs

1. What happens if you choose not to shoot Chris or Ashley in Until Dawn?: Regardless of who you decide to shoot (or not shoot), the result will end up the same in the next chapter, demonstrating the Butterfly Effect where some choices may not alter the immediate outcome but influence later events.
2. Can you not save Josh in Until Dawn?: You can take actions to potentially save Josh by picking up all the clues during the game, but the saw trap outcome is fixed, highlighting the importance of understanding which choices are crucial to character survival.
3. What happens if you pick Ashley instead of Josh in Until Dawn?: Josh dies either way, as the trap is designed to target him, but your choice affects the dialogue and Ashley’s actions later in the game, showing how player decisions influence character relationships and story progression.
4. Is it better to save Josh or Ashley in Until Dawn?: The choice between Josh and Ashley has significant implications on the story, especially in how Ashley reacts to Chris later on, but Josh’s fate is sealed in the saw trap scenario.
5. Who is the hardest to save in Until Dawn?: Matt is known as the most difficult character to keep alive, requiring careful decision-making, particularly in Chapter Five, where disagreeing with Emily about going to the fire tower is crucial.
6. Is there a way to save Josh and Ashley?: In the specific scene where Josh is in the saw trap, you cannot save both, but through further gameplay, there are opportunities for both characters to survive, depending on your choices.
7. Who is the easiest to save in Until Dawn?: Ashley is considered one of the easiest characters to save, with fewer critical choices affecting her survival compared to other characters like Matt.
8. What happens if you point the gun at Ashley but don’t shoot?: If Chris does not shoot Ashley and makes it to the lodge, Ashley will open the door for him, saving his life, illustrating the impact of sparing a character on future events.
9. Can you save Mike’s fingers?: The choice to save Mike’s fingers affects his ability to use the machete in later chapters, showing how even seemingly minor decisions can have gameplay implications.
10. Should Mike shoot Emily?: The decision to shoot Emily dead or spare her life unlocks different trophies and influences the story, particularly in how Ashley and Sam discover the truth about the wendigo bite.
11. Can Chris save both Ashley and Josh?: Unfortunately, Chris cannot save both; the storyline is designed so that Josh will be killed by the saw trap, regardless of Chris’s choice.
12. What did Ashley do to Josh?: According to backstory elements, Ashley and Josh had a verbal altercation, but this does not directly impact the saw trap outcome, which is a fixed event in the game.
13. What happens if Ashley takes the scissors?: If Ashley takes the scissors, she can use them against the Psycho, but this will result in her getting a black eye, showing how defensive actions can lead to negative consequences.
14. What happens if you sacrifice Ashley?: Sacrificing Ashley leads to specific consequences, including losing a potential ally and affecting the dynamics between characters, especially in how they react to Chris.
15. Can you prevent Josh from becoming a Wendigo?: Josh becomes a Wendigo by eating the Flamethrower guy’s head, an event that can be prevented by avoiding this action, thereby saving Josh from this fate, although this does not prevent his initial death in the saw trap.

Conclusion

The world of Until Dawn is filled with complex choices and consequences, making it a deeply engaging and replayable game. Understanding the implications of not choosing between Ashley and Josh, as well as exploring other FAQs, provides insight into the game’s Butterfly Effect system and the importance of player decision-making in shaping the story and its outcomes. Whether you’re a seasoned gamer or new to the Until Dawn universe, the game’s dynamic storytelling and characters offer a unique experience that challenges players to consider the impact of their choices on the game’s world and its inhabitants.