The Jarring Truth: What Happens if You Kill Iron Fist Alexander in Elden Ring?

Killing Iron Fist Alexander, the lovable warrior jar in Elden Ring, is a decision with significant consequences. Simply put, murdering Alexander means you will be locked out of his questline, preventing you from obtaining the Shard of Alexander talisman, a highly sought-after item that greatly boosts attack power of skills. Furthermore, you’ll miss out on experiencing the heartwarming conclusion to his story, which is a rewarding element for many players.

The Grim Reality of a Jarrdian’s Demise

Beyond the immediate loss of the talisman, killing Alexander prematurely removes a valuable summon for the Radahn boss fight, where he can be a surprisingly effective ally. While he might die during the battle, his presence helps distract Radahn and allows you to deal more damage. You’ll also miss out on his subsequent appearances and dialogue, each offering unique insights into his character and the world of The Lands Between. In essence, extinguishing Alexander’s flame prematurely closes a narrative thread and a powerful gameplay advantage.

Related FAQs: Delving Deeper into the Alexander Conundrum

Here are 15 frequently asked questions to further illuminate the consequences of killing, interacting with, or even missing Iron Fist Alexander in Elden Ring:

H3 FAQ 1: I Accidentally Killed Alexander! Is There Any Way to Revive Him?

Unfortunately, no. Unlike some NPCs, Celestial Dew will not revive Alexander if you kill him. Once he’s gone, he’s gone for that playthrough. This is a significant departure from the mechanics surrounding certain other NPC interactions, further emphasizing the weight of your choice.

H3 FAQ 2: If I Attack Alexander by Mistake, Can I Still Complete His Questline?

Yes, there’s hope! If you accidentally aggro Alexander, you can use Celestial Dew at the Church of Vows to reset his hostility. This will allow you to resume his questline as if nothing happened. Just be quick about it before you accidentally finish him off!

H3 FAQ 3: I Missed Alexander in Limgrave. Does That Ruin His Questline?

Not necessarily. Even if you miss Alexander in his initial locations in Limgrave, he will still appear at Redmane Castle for the Radahn Festival. You can find him in the courtyard before the fight and summon him for the battle. However, missing these initial encounters might affect certain dialogue options later on.

H3 FAQ 4: Does Alexander’s Questline Affect Any Other Quests?

No, Alexander’s questline is largely independent of other major questlines in Elden Ring. While the world is interconnected, his journey primarily focuses on his personal growth and pursuit of warriorhood. This allows you to focus on his quest without worrying about inadvertently altering other narratives.

H3 FAQ 5: What are the Benefits of Completing Alexander’s Questline?

The primary reward for completing Alexander’s questline is the Shard of Alexander talisman, which significantly boosts the attack power of skills. This is incredibly valuable for builds that rely heavily on weapon arts and other special abilities. You also gain unique dialogue and insights into his character.

H3 FAQ 6: Where Does Alexander Go After the Radahn Fight?

After the Radahn fight, you can find Alexander in Liurnia of the Lakes, stuck in a hole near the Artist’s Shack. You’ll need to help him out by hitting him from behind with an oiled pot. This is a crucial step in progressing his questline.

H3 FAQ 7: Is Alexander a Difficult NPC to Find?

Alexander’s locations can be somewhat obscure, but he generally stays in the same areas until triggered to move by certain events or player actions. Consulting a guide or walkthrough can be helpful if you’re having trouble locating him.

H3 FAQ 8: Can Alexander Die Permanently During the Radahn Fight?

While Alexander can “die” during the Radahn fight, it’s not a permanent death in the sense that it will end his questline. You can continue to summon him for the fight multiple times, and he will reappear at his next designated location afterward. However, killing him outside of this boss fight will prevent you from obtaining the talisman.

H3 FAQ 9: What’s the Best Way to Help Alexander Out of the Hole in Liurnia?

The easiest way to free Alexander from the hole in Liurnia is to craft an Oiled Pot, throw it at his rear end, and then hit him with a weapon. The oiled pot makes him slippery enough to climb out, and he will be grateful for the assistance.

H3 FAQ 10: Where Does Alexander Go After Liurnia?

After being freed from the hole in Liurnia, Alexander moves to Mt. Gelmir, near the Fort Laiedd site of grace. You’ll find him bathing in lava, toughening himself up for future battles.

H3 FAQ 11: What are the Morality Implications of Killing Alexander?

In the world of Elden Ring, morality is a complex and subjective concept. While Alexander is a friendly and helpful character, some players may choose to kill him for his talisman or simply out of curiosity. Ultimately, the decision is up to the individual player and their interpretation of the game’s narrative. The Games Learning Society often explores these ethical considerations in games, examining how choices impact the player’s experience and understanding of the game world.

H3 FAQ 12: Is There Any Lore Behind Alexander’s Jar-Like Existence?

While the exact origins of Alexander and other living jars are never explicitly stated, the lore hints at connections to ancient alchemists and the Crucible. They seem to be artificial beings created for specific purposes, often related to warfare or crafting. This adds a layer of mystery and intrigue to their existence.

H3 FAQ 13: How Does Alexander’s Questline End?

Alexander’s questline culminates in a final duel in Crumbling Farum Azula. He seeks to prove his strength and fulfill his warrior’s journey by battling you. After defeating him, you receive the Shard of Alexander and a piece of his jar, signifying his ultimate sacrifice.

H3 FAQ 14: Is the Shard of Alexander Talisman Worth Completing the Questline For?

For many players, the Shard of Alexander is one of the best talismans in the game. The significant boost to skill attack power makes it invaluable for builds that rely on weapon arts and other special abilities. If you’re focused on maximizing your damage output, completing Alexander’s questline is highly recommended.

H3 FAQ 15: Can I Get Alexander’s Innards Without Killing Him Early?

Yes! Alexander’s questline ends with a duel to the death between the player and him. You will acquire Alexander’s Innards in the final battle and be able to progress further in the game.

The Final Verdict: To Slay or Not to Slay?

Ultimately, the decision to kill or spare Iron Fist Alexander rests with you. However, considering the valuable rewards, the compelling narrative, and the heartwarming nature of the character, it’s generally advisable to complete his questline. For those interested in exploring the educational aspects of gaming, visit the GamesLearningSociety.org for research and resources on game-based learning. Choose wisely, Tarnished, for your actions have consequences in the unforgiving world of Elden Ring.