The Tragic Choice: What Happens When You Sacrifice Luther in Detroit: Become Human?

In the emotionally charged narrative of Detroit: Become Human, players are frequently forced to make difficult decisions that have profound consequences for the characters they control. One of the most heart-wrenching choices comes at the border crossing, where Kara, Alice, and Luther face a desperate bid for freedom. If you choose to sacrifice Luther at the border, a specific series of events unfolds. Luther’s sacrifice at this point in the game leads to his death, but importantly, it allows Kara and Alice to proceed, achieving their goal of crossing the border.

Following the player’s decision to sacrifice Luther, he will exclaim “Goddamn androids. You okay, little girl?” This phrase highlights Luther’s gruff yet deeply caring nature, particularly towards Alice. He prioritizes her safety above his own, a defining trait throughout the game. This sacrifice also results in a specific dialogue from the border patrol officer. He does not scan the remaining two after each sacrifice. Instead he will focus on the immediate need to assess the situation and then give instructions to those present.

It’s vital to understand the context of this sacrifice. During the border crossing scene, the guards are alerted to the presence of androids and the increasingly violent protests happening in Detroit by either watching the news, or having it directly communicated to them. Kara is given the choice to offer up either Luther or Jerry (if present) as a “sacrifice” to buy their passage. The alternative is to choose “No Sacrifice,” which, if the protests are violent, inevitably leads to the arrest and death of the entire group.

While sacrificing Luther ensures Kara and Alice’s survival at this point, it is a permanent loss. Luther, who has become a steadfast protector and father figure to Alice, is gone, leaving a hole in the makeshift family. This decision is a heavy emotional burden for Kara, and the game does not shy away from depicting the impact of this kind of choice.

This sacrifice option also provides a unique dialogue exchange and shows one of many potential paths through the complex game. This shows that a positive outcome, such as successfully crossing the border, can come at a high personal cost.

FAQs: Delving Deeper Into Luther’s Sacrifice and Detroit: Become Human

What are the different ways Luther can die in Detroit: Become Human?

Luther can die in several different ways, reflecting the game’s branching narratives. Apart from the border sacrifice, he can also die if you choose the boat and fail the quick-time events, in the Zlatko chapter, or if you are unable to keep him safe throughout the game. However, the border sacrifice is a very specific death, as it is the direct consequence of a player choice. In the Zlatko chapter, Luther can die if you fail the QTEs during the escape and/or if Kara is caught by the hunter. If Kara chooses the Boat crossing, Luther dies no matter what, but if you take a “plunge”, he gets final words rather than dying immediately.

Can Kara and Alice survive without sacrificing Luther?

Yes, Kara and Alice can survive without sacrificing Luther. One of the primary ways is by opting to “plunge” into the water on the boat. This option leads to Kara and Alice surviving the crossing, although Luther will always die, but he will have some final words. Another way to ensure all three make it across the border is to have Markus lead a peaceful protest, allowing the border patrol officer to be more compassionate and allow them to pass.

What happens if you choose no sacrifice at the border?

Choosing the “No Sacrifice” option can have drastically different outcomes depending on Markus’ storyline. If Markus leads a violent protest, the border patrol will view androids as a threat. Choosing “No Sacrifice” will result in the guards being ordered to intervene and arrest and kill the entire group. If Markus leads a peaceful protest, they will be treated with compassion and will be allowed to enter Canada.

Is it possible to save everyone in Detroit: Become Human?

Yes, it is possible to save every main character in the game, including Kara, Alice, Luther, Markus, Connor, and Hank. This outcome is often regarded as the best ending, and it requires careful planning, strategic choices, and successful completion of quick-time events throughout the game.

What is considered the worst ending in Detroit: Become Human?

The worst overall ending is generally considered to be when Markus chooses violent protest options and dies, Connor fails to become a deviant and is deactivated and Kara, Alice and Luther fail to escape and are killed at the border. The player must choose the “determined” dialogue choices during his Stratford Tower speech, lead a violent protest in Capitol Park and kill two officers. He chooses to attack the police during the Freedom March.

What is the significance of rA9 in Detroit: Become Human?

rA9 is a mysterious concept within the game, speculated to be a myth or a symbol of hope for the androids. It’s considered to be the first deviant android, and is talked about as the android that will eventually “wake” the rest of them. Some fan theories believe the player may be rA9, or it could be a collection of the main androids, as the game does have hidden morse code messages throughout. It is also thought that the model seen in the main menu, Chloe, is rA9.

What is RA9?

RA9 in a baseball context stands for Runs Allowed per Nine Innings pitched. It’s similar to ERA but without the “E,” focusing solely on the runs allowed, not earned runs.

What happens if Kara dies early in the game?

If Kara dies early in the game, such as failing the QTE during the fight with Todd, the game ends at that point and you will switch to a cutscene and the game continues only with Connor and Markus. Kara is not revived, and you will not be able to continue her storyline at that point.

What should Kara choose when playing dead during the fight?

Kara must select the “Play Dead” and “Don’t move” options during the fight with Todd and his associates. Choosing any other options will lead to both Alice and Kara’s deaths, making it impossible to achieve the ‘Good Ending’ for the Kara storyline.

How do you make the border crossing without any sacrifices?

A sacrifice-free border crossing is achievable if Markus leads a peaceful protest. This shows the border patrol officer that not all androids are dangerous, and he will have a more compassionate response, allowing Kara, Alice, and Luther to enter Canada.

Is there any romantic relationship between Kara and Luther?

While there is a deep bond and caring between Kara and Luther, their relationship is not portrayed as romantic. It is more of a familial bond, with Luther acting as a protector and father figure to Alice and a supportive friend to Kara. However, some fans theorize that they can get together after the game ends.

Why is Luther protective of Alice?

Luther’s protectiveness towards Alice stems from his compassionate nature and his desire to find a sense of purpose after losing his own family. He sees himself as a protector, and he wants to ensure Alice has a safe and loving environment.

What is the secret ending in Detroit: Become Human?

The secret ending is achieved by making specific choices: Markus allows himself to be shot by the police, and Connor fails to find Jericho and is deactivated. This will unlock the Kamski ending.

Can Connor become friends with Hank?

Yes, it’s possible for Connor and Hank to become good friends. This requires the player to make choices that foster their bond, leading to the two surviving the entire ordeal and embracing in the epilogue. Failing to achieve this may result in Hank’s death and a poorer outcome.

What happens if you choose to kiss North?

If the player builds a strong relationship with North, during the attack, you can choose to kiss North instead of sacrificing yourself or singing. This action will halt the attack and initiate a long cutscene that depicts the aftermath of everything that has happened, with the president addressing the events in Detroit.

Is Alice a psychopath?

Although there are fan theories surrounding this, Alice is not explicitly portrayed as a psychopath. She is a child character with a complicated backstory and her actions and traits are primarily born from trauma and circumstance.

In conclusion, the decision to sacrifice Luther is a significant turning point in Kara’s story, illustrating the heavy choices players must make in Detroit: Become Human. It showcases the emotional depth of the game and the profound impact even seemingly small choices can have on the lives of its characters. While it allows Kara and Alice to escape, it serves as a poignant reminder of the sacrifices made in the fight for freedom and the complex moral landscape that Detroit: Become Human expertly navigates.