Table of Contents

The Dynamite Dilemma: Lenny, Explosions, and Your Red Dead Redemption 2 Choices

The question isn’t just “What happens if you send Lenny or shoot the dynamite?” it’s about the ripples of choice in Red Dead Redemption 2. Sending Lenny means he attempts to disarm the dynamite, resulting in a comical but ultimately unsuccessful scenario, likely ending in an explosion and alerted enemies. Shooting the dynamite, on the other hand, provides a more immediate, violent, and typically more effective solution, instantly alerting enemies and triggering a firefight. The choice hinges on your preferred playstyle: stealthy chaos versus direct confrontation.

Unpacking the Explosive Options

In Red Dead Redemption 2, particularly during missions involving explosives, you’re often presented with tactical choices. When faced with the option to send Lenny or shoot the dynamite, understanding the consequences is crucial for a successful outcome and a desired play style. Both options have distinct outcomes:

Sending Lenny: This is often the riskier, albeit potentially more amusing, path. Lenny, bless his heart, isn’t exactly an expert bomb disposal technician. Sending him to defuse the dynamite usually results in a failed attempt. The dynamite will explode, alerting the enemy. This can lead to a less controlled situation, but can also create useful chaos. This approach can be fun for players looking for a more unpredictable outcome.
Shooting the Dynamite: A much more direct approach. Shooting the dynamite guarantees an immediate explosion. The blast can kill or disable enemies near the dynamite, giving you an initial advantage in a firefight. However, it also immediately alerts all enemies in the vicinity to your presence. This is ideal for players who prefer direct combat.

The ultimate choice depends on the specific context of the mission, your preferred playstyle (stealth vs. action), and your desired outcome (controlled engagement vs. chaotic firefight).

The Ramifications of Your Explosive Decision

Beyond the immediate consequences, your choice between sending Lenny or shooting the dynamite can have other ripple effects:

Honor: While neither option drastically impacts your honor, your actions within the ensuing conflict certainly can. Engaging in indiscriminate killing of innocents or surrendering to the authorities will negatively impact your honor, regardless of how the conflict started.
Resources: Shooting the dynamite might save you ammunition in the short term, but the resulting firefight could require you to expend more resources in the long run. Conversely, a failed attempt by Lenny might alert fewer enemies initially, potentially leading to a more resource-efficient encounter.
Replayability: Exploring both options provides unique experiences and dialogue. Red Dead Redemption 2 excels at rewarding players who experiment and replay missions with different choices.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Does sending Lenny ever actually work?

In most scenarios, no. Lenny’s attempt to defuse dynamite is typically a humorous, albeit unsuccessful, endeavor. It’s designed to create chaos, not resolve the situation peacefully. There might be an extremely rare case where the game glitches in your favor, but don’t count on it.

2. Is there a “best” choice between sending Lenny and shooting the dynamite?

It depends entirely on the situation and your playstyle. If you prefer stealth and want to try a risky maneuver, sending Lenny might be entertaining. If you prefer direct action and want to start with a bang, shooting the dynamite is the better option.

3. How does shooting the dynamite affect enemy AI?

Shooting the dynamite immediately puts the enemy AI on high alert. They’ll actively seek you out, take cover, and coordinate their attacks. Be prepared for a more intense and aggressive response.

4. Can the dynamite explosion be used strategically?

Absolutely! Position yourself strategically before shooting the dynamite to maximize the blast radius and eliminate as many enemies as possible. Consider the environment and use the terrain to your advantage.

5. Does the type of dynamite matter?

In scenarios where you can send Lenny or shoot dynamite, the specific type of dynamite typically doesn’t matter. The outcome of Lenny’s attempt is predetermined, and shooting any type of dynamite will result in an explosion. However, the damage dealt by the dynamite will depend on its grade.

6. Can I send another character other than Lenny?

In most instances with this particular choice it will specifically be Lenny.

7. Does the time of day affect the outcome?

The time of day generally doesn’t significantly impact the immediate outcome of sending Lenny or shooting the dynamite. However, it can affect the visibility and enemy patrol patterns during the ensuing firefight.

8. How does this choice affect my mission completion percentage?

Choosing either option will still lead to mission completion, provided you survive the subsequent encounter. However, some missions have optional objectives that might be easier to achieve with one approach over the other.

9. Can I use Dead Eye to shoot the dynamite more accurately?

Yes! Using Dead Eye can significantly improve your accuracy when shooting the dynamite, allowing you to target specific points on the dynamite or detonate it from a greater distance.

10. Are there any achievements or trophies related to this choice?

There are no specific achievements or trophies directly tied to choosing between sending Lenny and shooting the dynamite. However, the broader consequences of your actions during the mission might contribute to progress towards other achievements.

11. What happens if I try to stealth past the dynamite instead of interacting with it?

In some cases, you might be able to attempt a stealthy approach to bypass the dynamite altogether. However, this usually requires careful planning, skillful execution, and a high degree of stealth proficiency. You may also miss out on other valuable gameplay opportunities.

12. How does my character’s stats influence the outcome?

Your character’s stats don’t directly influence the immediate outcome of sending Lenny or shooting the dynamite. However, stats like Health, Stamina, and Dead Eye proficiency will affect your ability to survive the ensuing firefight.

13. What if I shoot Lenny after I tell him to disarm the dynamite?

While the game won’t directly punish you with a drastic honor loss, shooting Lenny, especially after sending him to disarm the dynamite, is a morally reprehensible act and will likely result in a decrease in your honor.

14. Where can I learn more about the mechanics of Red Dead Redemption 2’s choices and consequences?

Explore online forums, wikis, and gameplay videos dedicated to Red Dead Redemption 2. The community is a great resource for sharing tips, strategies, and insights into the game’s complex systems. You can also find relevant information on the Games Learning Society website: GamesLearningSociety.org. The Games Learning Society is a research community that often publishes studies about how video games are built and played.

15. Does playing online (Red Dead Online) change the dynamics of this choice?

In Red Dead Online, the option to send Lenny is not usually available in the same scripted manner as in the single-player campaign. You will probably just be able to shoot the dynamite, or work with other players to find an alternate stealthy approach around the dynamite.

The Final Verdict: Experimentation is Key

Ultimately, the choice between sending Lenny or shooting the dynamite is a microcosm of the larger experience that Red Dead Redemption 2 offers: a world brimming with choices, consequences, and opportunities for experimentation. Don’t be afraid to try both options and see what unfolds. The game is designed to be replayed and explored, so embrace the chaos and enjoy the ride!