Table of Contents

Hogwarts Legacy: Choosing Between Ominis and Sebastian – Consequences and Outcomes

The world of Hogwarts Legacy presents players with numerous choices, many of which seem weighty and impactful. One of the most significant moral quandaries revolves around the character Sebastian Sallow and his descent into dark magic. Throughout his questline, you’ll be forced to make decisions that align you more closely with either Sebastian or his conflicted friend, Ominis Gaunt. While the core storyline remains largely consistent regardless of your choices, the consequences – both immediate and long-term – are nuanced and affect the character’s interactions and gameplay experience.

Ultimately, siding with Ominis typically means prioritizing the rules of Hogwarts and the potential dangers of Sebastian’s actions. This might involve expressing disapproval of his dark magic usage and ultimately, potentially turning him in for his crimes. Siding with Sebastian, on the other hand, means being more lenient towards his methods, understanding his motivations (saving his sister Anne), and potentially learning the Unforgivable Curses alongside him. The crucial point is that both options allow you to complete the quests and leave the catacomb, and Sebastian will always take the relic.

Navigating the Shadow of the Undercroft

The narrative unfolds around Sebastian’s determination to cure his sister, Anne. This leads him down a dangerous path involving dark magic and the Unforgivable Curses. Your choices during his questline will determine how deeply involved you become in his practices and how you react to his increasingly reckless behavior.

Impact on Character Relationships: Your decisions will significantly impact your relationship with both Sebastian and Ominis. Supporting Sebastian’s actions might strain your friendship with Ominis, who is deeply concerned about the dangers of dark magic. Conversely, condemning Sebastian’s methods might lead to friction between the two of you, while solidifying your bond with Ominis.
Learning the Unforgivable Curses: One of the most significant gameplay consequences of siding with Sebastian is the opportunity to learn the Unforgivable Curses: Avada Kedavra, Crucio, and Imperio. These powerful spells can drastically change your combat style. If you disapprove of his actions and/or turn Sebastian in, you will miss the opportunity to learn the Unforgivable Curses during his questline. This makes many people side with Sebastian despite his reckless actions.
Turning Sebastian In: The most drastic consequence is the decision to turn Sebastian in after the tragic event involving his uncle. This action results in his expulsion from Hogwarts and removes him from future quests and the epilogue. It’s a weighty decision that reflects a firm commitment to upholding the law and the dangers of unchecked dark magic. This does not affect the main storyline beyond Sebastian no longer being available.

Consequences of Your Choices

The consequences of siding with either character are multi-faceted:

Siding with Ominis

Moral High Ground: You maintain a strong moral compass within the game’s narrative.
Approval from other characters: You will receive approval from characters who disapprove of the use of dark magic.
Loss of Opportunity: You will likely miss the opportunity to learn the Unforgivable Curses from Sebastian, limiting your spell arsenal.
Sebastian’s Expulsion: Choosing this path potentially leads to Sebastian’s expulsion from Hogwarts.
Change in Interactions: After turning Sebastian in, interacting with Ominis will have a more somber tone.

Siding with Sebastian

Acquiring Unforgivable Curses: Gain access to the Unforgivable Curses, providing powerful combat options.
Moral Ambiguity: Navigating a more morally ambiguous path, which can be a compelling role-playing experience.
Potential Disapproval: Face disapproval from characters who oppose dark magic.
Continued Interaction: Sebastian remains available for future quests (if you don’t turn him in), allowing you to continue exploring his storyline.

No True “Good” or “Evil” Path

It’s important to understand that Hogwarts Legacy doesn’t present a clear-cut “good” or “evil” path. The choices surrounding Sebastian are more about moral ambiguity and personal values. The game allows you to explore the complexities of dark magic and its potential consequences without forcing you into a purely villainous role.

The decision of whether or not to side with Ominis or Sebastian is a matter of personal preference. Consider your own character’s values and goals when making these choices. Remember, the most important thing is to enjoy the game and create a story that is meaningful to you.

Learning through video games is a growing field, and more information can be found at the GamesLearningSociety.org website.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Here are some frequently asked questions about the consequences of siding with Ominis or Sebastian in Hogwarts Legacy:

1. Does it matter if you side with Ominis or Sebastian in the long run?

No, the core storyline remains largely unchanged regardless of your choices. The primary differences lie in character relationships, access to the Unforgivable Curses, and Sebastian’s availability in later quests. The overarching plot of Hogwarts Legacy is not affected by your decision.

2. Is it better to turn Sebastian in or not?

This depends on your personal preferences. Turning Sebastian in aligns with a more lawful and morally upright path, but it leads to his expulsion and the loss of his questline. Not turning him in allows you to continue learning from him and potentially learn the Unforgivable Curses.

3. Are there consequences for turning Sebastian in?

Yes. Turning in Sebastian will result in his being expelled from Hogwarts. As a result, he won’t be available in quests at the end of the game and won’t be in the epilogue.

4. Should I side with Sebastian Sallow to learn Avada Kedavra?

If learning Avada Kedavra and the other Unforgivable Curses is a priority, siding with Sebastian is the only way to acquire them during his questline. Other than some disapproving dialogue from other characters, there are no long-term downsides to this action.

5. Can you stop Sebastian from killing his uncle?

No, the confrontation between Sebastian and his uncle is a fixed event in the storyline. The only decision you have is whether to turn Sebastian in afterwards.

6. Can you get the killing curse if you turn Sebastian in?

No. If you turn Sebastian in, he will be taken away by the Ministry authorities, and you won’t be able to learn Avada Kedavra from him. To learn Avada Kedavra later, you need the Dark Arts Pack DLC, after which the spell will become available in the Dark Arts Battle Arena.

7. Can you mess up Sebastian’s questline?

Very little. The main plot points of Sebastian’s questline are fixed, but your choices influence your relationship with him and whether you learn the Unforgivable Curses. You cannot alter anything in Natty or Poppy’s main friendship quests, and you can alter, very, very little about Sebastian’s.

8. Can I learn Avada Kedavra without Sebastian?

Yes, but only with the Dark Arts Pack DLC. For players who did not take the Slytherin House or chose to turn in Sebastian without learning the curse, they can access Avada Kedavra in the Dark Arts Battle Arena.

9. Can you tell Ominis about Sebastian’s actions?

Yes. Preferably, it’s better to tell Ominis since he’s actually standing in the room and will make his presence known once Sebastian finishes talking.

10. Is Sebastian Sallow evil?

Sebastian is not inherently evil, but he becomes increasingly reckless and morally ambiguous in his pursuit of a cure for his sister. He crosses lines and uses dark magic, but his motivations stem from a desire to help his family, rather than malicious intent.

11. What happens if you say “no one should know that curse” to Sebastian?

You may still learn the spell later if you do not turn Sebastian in. You don’t get your second chance until after the main quest is finished.

12. Do you ever cure Sebastian’s sister?

Unfortunately, you cannot cure Anne. However, you can influence Sebastian’s fate by choosing whether to turn him in or not, potentially saving him from Azkaban.

13. What happens if I take the relic with Sebastian?

Regardless of which dialogue option the player chooses, it won’t affect the outcome of the situation, because Sebastian will always end up taking the relic.

14. What happens to Ominis Gaunt?

Historically, the last living Gaunts by the summer of 1925 were Marvolo and his children Morfin and Merope. It follows that Ominis had already passed away by that date.

15. Should we tell Ominis in Hogwarts Legacy?

Yes, preferably, it’s better to tell Ominis since he’s actually standing in the room and will make his presence known once Sebastian finishes talking.

In conclusion, the choice between siding with Ominis or Sebastian in Hogwarts Legacy is a complex one with no right or wrong answer. It depends on your personal values, your character’s goals, and the type of experience you want to have. By carefully considering the consequences of your choices, you can create a unique and meaningful story within the world of Hogwarts Legacy.

What happens if you side with ominis or sebastian?