The Easiest Legendary Fish to Catch in RDR2: A Comprehensive Guide

The world of Red Dead Redemption 2 is vast and filled with countless activities, but for many, the thrill of the hunt extends beyond land animals to the waters. Among the many fish that inhabit the lakes and rivers, legendary fish hold a special allure, presenting a unique challenge and reward. If you’re looking to get started on your legendary fishing journey in RDR2, you’re likely wondering: what is the easiest legendary fish to catch? The answer, without a doubt, is the Legendary Smallmouth Bass, located in Lake Owanjila. This guide will detail why the Smallmouth Bass is the most accessible legendary fish and provide tips on how to catch it effectively, while also covering frequently asked questions related to legendary fishing in Red Dead Redemption 2.

The Legendary Smallmouth Bass: Your Gateway to Legendary Fishing

Why is it the Easiest?

The Legendary Smallmouth Bass earns its title as the easiest for a few key reasons. First and foremost, its location in Lake Owanjila, just west of Strawberry, is incredibly convenient and accessible early in the game. Unlike other legendary fish that are found in more remote or challenging areas, Lake Owanjila is relatively peaceful, and reaching it doesn’t require navigating treacherous terrain or facing aggressive wildlife.

Secondly, the Special Lake Lure which is required to catch all legendary fish, is readily available from any bait and tackle shop, and is the only bait required for this fish. This consistency simplifies the process significantly. Finally, the fight with the Legendary Smallmouth Bass, while still requiring some skill, is less intense than what you will face from other legendary fish. It tends to tire quicker, making reeling it in a bit easier for those who are just beginning.

How to Catch the Legendary Smallmouth Bass

To catch this fish successfully, follow these steps:

1. Acquire the Special Lake Lure: Visit a bait shop to purchase the Special Lake Lure, which is the only lure that will attract any of the Legendary Fish in RDR2.
2. Travel to Lake Owanjila: Head west of Strawberry. The lake will be easily identifiable on your map.
3. Find a Suitable Fishing Spot: The banks of Lake Owanjila are mostly accessible. Cast your lure in a spot where you have clear access to the water and will not catch on rocks and other debris.
4. Cast and Wait: Cast the Special Lake Lure into the water. It may take a couple of tries to find the right place.
5. Reel and Resist: When the fish bites, pull back on the left analog stick to draw the fish in while reeling, but when the fish is resisting, click the right analog stick to momentarily stop the fish. This technique significantly increases the speed at which you reel in the fish.
6. Secure the Catch: Once the fish is reeled close enough to the shore, your character will automatically secure it. Store it on your horse.
7. Mail to Jeremy Gill: Once caught, take the Legendary Smallmouth Bass to the nearest Post Office and mail it to Jeremy Gill. This will get you on your way to completing the quest.

Frequently Asked Questions About Legendary Fishing in RDR2

Here are 15 frequently asked questions to deepen your understanding of legendary fishing in Red Dead Redemption 2:

1. What is the hardest legendary fish to catch in RDR2?
   The Legendary Bullhead Catfish is often cited as the most challenging. While not catchable in the base game, it is designed to be difficult, according to the game files.

2. Is there a trick to catching legendary fish in RDR2?
   Yes, during the reeling stage, pull back on the left analog stick to draw the fish in faster. When the fish resists, click the right analog stick to stop it temporarily. Combine these techniques with your regular fishing methods to improve your catch rate.

3. Where are the easiest places to catch regular fish in RDR2?
   Some of the best locations for easy fishing include Lagras, Lake Don Julio, Cattail Pond, the San Luis River, O’Creagh’s Run, Calumet Ravine, Flat Iron Lake, and Lake Owanjila.

4. What is the legendary fish in Flat Iron Lake?
   The Legendary Bluegill is found in Flat Iron Lake. It can be caught using the Special Lake Lure, particularly near the shores of Braithwaite Manor and the island south of Clemens Point.

5. What happens when you catch all 13 Legendary Fish?
   After mailing all 13 Legendary Fish to Jeremy Gill, he invites you for a final fishing trip, which concludes the “Fisher of Fish” side quest.

6. Where should I take Legendary Fish after catching them?
   After catching a Legendary Fish, store it on your horse and take it to the nearest post office to mail it to Jeremy Gill. Be careful when transporting the fish as it may be lost or ruined if damaged.

7. What fish sell for the most in RDR2?
   Northern Pike and Muskie sell for the highest price at $5.00 each.

8. Is fishing worth it in RDR2?
   Yes, fishing is beneficial for food and profit. It provides a steady supply of food and a means to earn money by selling your catches.

9. What is the best bait in RDR2?
   For larger fish, use crayfish in deep lakes and rivers or crickets for medium-sized river fish. For general lake fishing, worms are excellent for medium-sized catches. The Special Lake Lure is required for legendary fish.

10. How many legendary fish can Arthur catch in RDR2?
    Arthur can catch all 13 Legendary Fish to complete the ‘Fisher of Fish’ quest.

11. Can you actually catch the Legendary Catfish in RDR2?
    No, the Legendary Catfish model is in the game files, but it’s not accessible for gameplay. There is no means to catch it.

12. What is the easiest legendary animal in RDR2?
    The Legendary Moose is often considered the easiest legendary animal to hunt.

13. What attracts big fish in RDR2?
    Use crayfish, live crickets, and live worms to attract bigger fish like sturgeon, sockeye salmon, and largemouth bass. Lagras is the only town that sells live bait.

14. What is the best fish meat in RDR2?
    Succulent Fish meat comes from sockeye salmon and steelhead trout.

15. Where is the famous fisherman, Jeremy Gill, located?
    Jeremy Gill can be found on his dock on the north-east shoreline of Flat Iron Lake, south-east of Flatneck Station.

Conclusion

The Legendary Smallmouth Bass in Lake Owanjila is the perfect starting point for your legendary fishing journey in Red Dead Redemption 2. Its accessibility, combined with the relatively straightforward catching process, makes it the easiest legendary fish to land. Armed with this knowledge and the answers to the most common questions, you’re well on your way to becoming a master angler in the wild west. Happy fishing!