What to do when Hamish dies?

When Hamish dies, the player, either as Arthur or John, has the option to mount Buell, his Dutch Warmblood horse, to fulfill his dying wish, thereby earning honor, or sell the horse at a stable or to the horse fence, which results in a loss of honor. This choice is significant as it reflects the player’s character and has implications for the game’s storyline, particularly in terms of honor and the bond with Buell.

Understanding Hamish’s Story and Buell’s Significance

Hamish’s Background and Relationship with Buell

Hamish Sinclair is a character in Red Dead Redemption 2 with whom the player can interact through a series of missions. His Dutch Warmblood horse, Buell, is notable for its rare Cremello Gold coat. The story of Hamish and Buell is one of loyalty and companionship, making the decision of what to do with Buell after Hamish’s death a poignant moment in the game.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What happens if you sell Buell? – Selling Buell at a stable or to the horse fence will result in the player losing honor.
2. Can you save Hamish in RDR2? – Unfortunately, it is not possible to save Hamish from his fate; his death is a predetermined event in the game’s storyline.
3. What to do with Hamish in RDR2? – The player should engage with Hamish’s story by completing his missions, which include a poignant fishing trip and a final hunt that ends in tragedy.
4. What happens if Buell dies? – Buell’s death serves as a foreshadowing of Arthur’s inevitable demise and signifies the loss of one of Arthur’s last positive relationships.
5. Can Arthur get laid in RDR2? – The game does not feature explicit content, but there are scenes involving Arthur’s past lovers, providing insight into his character.
6. Can you avoid Arthur’s TB? – The only way to avoid Arthur’s tuberculosis progression is by not progressing through the game, as there is no in-game cure for TB.
7. Can you do Hamish as John? – Yes, if the player doesn’t complete Hamish’s final mission as Arthur, they can interact with him as John in the epilogue, where Hamish shares stories of Arthur.
8. Is Arthur’s death avoidable? – No, Arthur’s death is a fixed part of the game’s narrative and cannot be altered by the player’s choices.
9. How do I lead Buell back to the veteran? – After Hamish’s death, the player can lead Buell back to the location where they first met Hamish by walking calmly and not running.
10. What is the best horse in RDR2? – The Arabian breed is considered the best horse in Red Dead Redemption 2 due to its exceptional stats in health, stamina, speed, and acceleration.
11. Can you give John Arthur’s horse? – Unfortunately, it is not possible to transfer Arthur’s horses, including Buell, to John after Arthur’s death.
12. What is the saddest ending in RDR2? – Arthur’s death is widely regarded as the saddest moment in the game, marking a poignant end to his story arc.
13. Should you get Buell as Arthur or John? – It is recommended to complete Hamish’s mission as John to keep Buell after Arthur’s death, ensuring the player can keep the horse without it being lost.
14. Can you finish Hamish missions as John? – Yes, John can complete Hamish’s missions in the epilogue, allowing for a unique interaction with Hamish after Arthur’s passing.
15. Can John meet Hamish in RDR2? – If the player doesn’t complete Hamish’s final mission as Arthur, John can meet Hamish and learn about Arthur’s interactions with him, including their hunting trips and Hamish’s appreciation for Arthur’s kindness.

Conclusion

The decision of what to do when Hamish dies is a critical moment in Red Dead Redemption 2, reflecting the player’s character and impacting the game’s storyline. Through Hamish’s story and the significance of Buell, the game explores themes of loyalty, companionship, and the inevitable nature of death and loss. By understanding the context and implications of Hamish’s death, players can appreciate the depth and complexity of Red Dead Redemption 2’s narrative.