What’s the Absolute Worst Ending in Phantom Liberty?

The “worst” ending in Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty is arguably the one where Songbird betrays V and willingly subjects herself to the Neural Matrix. This outcome is the most narratively bleak, representing a complete failure to save Songbird and resulting in V remaining in their compromised state. This ending is frequently considered the least desirable because it provides no resolution to V’s core problem and leaves Songbird in what many perceive as a fate worse than death.

Diving Deep into the Endings of Phantom Liberty

Phantom Liberty adds a layer of moral complexity to Cyberpunk 2077, introducing multiple endings, each with distinct implications for V, Johnny Silverhand, and the broader world. Deciding which ending is “worst” depends on individual priorities: emotional impact, gameplay consequences, or adherence to a character’s moral compass. However, the aforementioned ending consistently ranks lowest among players due to its devastating consequences. Let’s break down why.

Why is the Songbird Neural Matrix Ending Considered the “Worst”?

Several factors contribute to this perception:

• Songbird’s Fate: Songbird, throughout Phantom Liberty, displays a profound desire to escape her situation. She desperately seeks freedom from Myers and the FIA. Submitting her to the Neural Matrix completely negates her agency and condemns her to a digital prison, arguably a fate she actively sought to avoid. This directly contradicts V’s role as a fixer and someone who supposedly values freedom.
• V’s Unresolved Condition: This ending offers no cure for V’s Relic malfunction. One of the primary motivations for aligning with Songbird is the promise of a potential solution. To have that hope dashed, and remain with the constant threat of Johnny Silverhand taking over, is a significant blow. It returns V to the pre-Phantom Liberty status quo, but with the added weight of a failed mission.
• Moral Implications: Choosing to betray Songbird after promising her salvation is a morally questionable decision. Players who invested in her character and empathized with her plight often find this betrayal deeply unsettling. Even if Songbird is manipulative and flawed, V’s role in her final imprisonment feels particularly harsh.
• Lack of closure: The ending often feels abrupt and unsatisfying. There is a sense of failure and futility that permeates the narrative. Players may feel as though their efforts throughout the expansion were ultimately meaningless.
• Impact on Main Game Endings: This ending, unlike some of the others, can significantly impact the main game’s ending options, potentially locking out certain desirable outcomes depending on previous choices.

Comparing to Other Phantom Liberty Endings

While the Neural Matrix ending is often deemed the worst, it’s crucial to compare it to the other available options:

• Curing V (The Tower): This ending, achieved by handing Songbird over to Myers, offers a cure for V’s condition but results in them losing their cyberware and becoming a “normal” person. While some find this ending desirable, others see it as a bittersweet sacrifice, forfeiting V’s identity and capabilities.
• Killing Songbird: This ending, while emotionally charged, allows Songbird to die with dignity and on her own terms. While tragic, it respects her agency and provides a degree of closure. V also remains in their original condition, but without the added weight of betrayal.
• Helping Reed: This ending varies depending on choices made, but generally results in a confrontation with Songbird and potentially either her death or her capture. The morality hinges on your view of Reed and the FIA.

Compared to these, the Neural Matrix ending lacks any redeeming qualities. It offers no benefit to V and subjects Songbird to a fate many consider worse than death.

Understanding the Nuance

It’s important to acknowledge that “worst” is subjective. Some players might appreciate the complexity and moral ambiguity of the Neural Matrix ending. They might see it as a realistic depiction of the consequences of unchecked ambition and political maneuvering. However, from a narrative and character-driven perspective, it’s difficult to argue that it’s a good ending.

Ultimately, the choice is yours. Phantom Liberty excels at presenting players with difficult decisions, forcing them to confront their own values and priorities. Reflect on your character’s motivations, your relationship with Songbird, and your own moral compass when making your final choice. No matter the ending, understand the lasting impact it has on Night City and V’s future.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Does the “Worst” Ending Lock Me Out of Content?

Yes, some endings, including the Neural Matrix ending, can impact your access to certain side quests and main game endings. It’s crucial to understand the consequences before making a decision.

2. Can I Change My Ending Choice After Completing Phantom Liberty?

No. After completing Phantom Liberty, the game locks in your chosen ending. Reloading a previous save is the only way to experience different outcomes.

3. What’s the Best Way to Prepare for the Ending Choices?

Pay close attention to the dialogue and character interactions. Understand the motivations of Songbird, Reed, and Myers. Consider what V values most: survival, freedom, or loyalty.

4. Is it Possible to Get a “Good” Ending in Phantom Liberty?

The definition of a “good” ending is subjective. Some players may consider the cure for V a positive outcome, even if it comes at a cost. Others may prioritize Songbird’s freedom, regardless of the consequences. There is no objectively “good” ending.

5. How Does Johnny Silverhand Feel About the Different Endings?

Johnny Silverhand has strong opinions on each ending. He typically disapproves of choices that compromise V’s freedom or involve betrayal. His reactions can provide valuable insight into the moral implications of your decisions.

6. Does My Romance Choice Affect the Phantom Liberty Endings?

While your romance option from the main game doesn’t directly impact the endings themselves, the emotional resonance of certain choices might be amplified depending on your romantic relationship.

7. Are There Secret Endings in Phantom Liberty?

While there are no “secret” endings in the traditional sense, there are variations within the existing endings based on specific choices and actions taken throughout the expansion.

8. How Many Main Endings Are There in Phantom Liberty?

There are four main endings in Phantom Liberty, each with variations based on your specific choices.

9. What Happens to Night City After the Phantom Liberty Endings?

The endings have different effects on the political landscape of Night City and Dogtown. Some endings lead to increased FIA influence, while others result in a power vacuum.

10. Does Phantom Liberty Change the Main Game’s Story?

Yes, Phantom Liberty can significantly alter the available endings in the main game, particularly if you choose the “Tower” ending which cures V.

11. How Does The Expansion Affect My Relationship With Myers?

Your relationship with Myers is largely determined by the specific ending you choose. Depending on the ending, you may find yourself allied with her or at odds.

12. What Are the Consequences of Helping Reed Instead of Songbird?

Helping Reed typically aligns you with the FIA and against Songbird. This path often leads to Songbird’s capture or death, but it might offer a more “stable” outcome for Night City.

13. Is there an ending where both Songbird and V can get what they want?

Unfortunately, there is no ending where both Songbird and V achieve their desired outcomes completely. The narrative emphasizes the tragic nature of their situation and the difficult choices they must make.

14. What level should I be before starting Phantom Liberty?

It’s recommended to be at least level 30 before starting Phantom Liberty. This will ensure you have sufficient skills and resources to handle the challenges of Dogtown.

15. Is Phantom Liberty worth playing even if I don’t like the ending?

Absolutely! Phantom Liberty offers a compelling story, memorable characters, and exciting gameplay, even if you don’t find the ending satisfying. The journey is still worth experiencing.