Which Ending is Better Witcher 3 Hearts of Stone?
The best ending for Witcher 3 Hearts of Stone is largely a matter of personal preference, with two distinct endings available: one where Geralt outsmarts the Man of Glass and saves Olgierd, and another where O’Dimm takes Olgierd’s soul. Ultimately, the choice between these endings depends on the player’s moral compass and their interpretation of the game’s storyline, with both endings being well-written and brilliantly executed.
Understanding the Endings
To make an informed decision, it’s essential to understand the implications of each ending. The good ending, where Geralt saves Olgierd, involves completing a timed challenge that requires solving a riddle set by O’Dimm. On the other hand, the bad ending, where Olgierd dies, can be achieved by opting not to save him or failing to meet with Shani and Shakeslock.
Frequently Asked Questions
General Questions
- What is the best overall ending in Witcher 3?: The best overall ending in Witcher 3 is widely regarded as Ciri taking up the path of a Witcher.
- Should I finish Hearts of Stone first?: The recommended order is to complete Witcher 3: Wild Hunt, Hearts of Stone, and Blood and Wine in that order.
- Does Heart of Stone affect the main story?: Heart of Stone is a standalone expansion that can be played without affecting the main story.
Ending-Specific Questions
- Is it better to save Olgierd?: Saving Olgierd is generally considered the morally good ending, but both endings have their consequences.
- What is the bad ending of Hearts of Stone?: The bad ending occurs when Olgierd dies, either by choice or by failing to meet with Shani and Shakeslock.
- Should I help Olgierd or O’Dimm?: Helping Olgierd yields a useful steel sword, while helping O’Dimm provides slightly useful items.
Gameplay and Storyline Questions
- When should I complete Hearts of Stone?: It’s recommended to start Hearts of Stone shortly before finding Ciri or after the battle of Kaer Morhen.
- Can I change my ending in Witcher 3?: To change the ending, you must start over with a save file after the Kaer Morhen fight.
- Who is Geralt’s canon lover?: Yennefer of Vengerberg is decisively Geralt’s true love in the series.
Character-Specific Questions
- Should you side with Gaunter or Olgierd?: Interfering with Gaunter O’Dimm and saving Olgierd is generally considered the good ending.
- Why is Olgierd so hard to defeat?: Olgierd’s ability to take on a non-corporeal form makes him difficult to strike, but using an upgraded Yrden trap can help.
- Is Olgierd’s sword good?: Iris/Olgierd’s Sword is a powerful weapon with a unique effect that builds up a charge for a massively powerful strike.
Miscellaneous Questions
- How many hours is Hearts of Stone?: The expansion is approximately 10 hours long when focusing on main objectives, and 18 hours for 100% completion.
- Can I romance anyone in Heart of Stone?: Geralt can romance Shani during the expansion’s storyline.
- Does killing Radovid change anything?: Killing Radovid affects the storyline, as Djikstra rises to power and claims the north, ruling with an iron fist.