XCOM Showdown: Which is Better, XCOM 1 or XCOM 2?
The question of whether XCOM: Enemy Unknown/Within (XCOM 1) or XCOM 2 reigns supreme is a hotly debated topic among strategy game enthusiasts. While both titles offer gripping tactical gameplay and deep strategic layers, XCOM 2 generally emerges as the superior experience, primarily due to its expanded variety, enhanced polish, and more ambitious scope. However, this doesn’t mean XCOM 1 is without its merits. In fact, for many, experiencing the first game’s narrative and mechanics is a crucial step in fully appreciating the advancements of the sequel. Ultimately, the “better” game depends on what you prioritize: a more traditional, manageable challenge, or a more dynamic, challenging, and varied one.
The Case for XCOM 2
XCOM 2 takes everything that made the first game great and dials it up to eleven. The most significant improvement is the sheer variety in enemies and playstyles. The introduction of new enemy types, like the terrifying Advent forces, coupled with enhanced class customization and abilities, leads to far more diverse tactical encounters. Players aren’t just relying on overwatch and carefully advancing anymore. The game pushes you to adapt, experiment, and embrace a range of strategies.
Furthermore, XCOM 2 benefits from a more robust and engaging narrative. The premise of a resistance movement fighting against an occupying alien force adds a compelling layer of desperation and heroism. The game also boasts superior polish, thanks to refinements to the game engine and user interface. While both games are built around the core turn-based tactical gameplay, the visual and technical enhancements in XCOM 2 make it a more fluid and enjoyable experience. Also, XCOM 2’s expansion, War of the Chosen, adds so much content that it is practically a different game making it a better deal than the base game and its expansion.
The strategic layer in XCOM 2 is also more intricate than its predecessor. Managing resources, building facilities, and conducting covert operations all add significant depth to the campaign. The game’s reliance on timed missions forces players to think on their feet and adds an element of urgency that is largely absent in the first game. While this can be frustrating to some, it ultimately contributes to the challenging and dynamic nature of XCOM 2.
The Case for XCOM 1 (Enemy Within)
Despite the advancements of XCOM 2, XCOM 1, especially with the Enemy Within expansion, remains a compelling experience. One of the core advantages it possesses over the sequel is that, when played with some discretion and focus on mission order, the difficulty is more manageable and largely controlled by the player’s strategic choices. Players can have a more gradual learning experience and feel less pressured. This allows players to truly explore strategies and squad load-outs in a more methodical manner.
Additionally, XCOM 1’s classic and well-established structure can be appealing for purists. Its focus is on defending against alien invasion, a concept many found to be more straightforward and more cohesive. Some players also appreciate the more deliberate, slower pace of combat in XCOM 1, allowing for more tactical planning.
It’s also essential to note that Enemy Within offers unique gameplay elements not found in XCOM 2. These aren’t necessarily better or worse than the features in the sequel, but provide a different flavor. For example, the MEC Troopers and gene modifications add interesting tactical options and strategic upgrades that create a distinctive experience not available in XCOM 2. Some purists may consider the more simplistic progression of soldiers in the original to be preferable over the deep class customization found in the sequel.
The Verdict: A Matter of Preference
Ultimately, while XCOM 2 is often considered the better game due to its more ambitious scope and enhanced mechanics, both titles are excellent in their own right. If you’re looking for a more diverse and challenging tactical experience with a deeper narrative, XCOM 2 is likely the better choice. But, if you prefer a more methodical and classic approach with a manageable difficulty curve XCOM: Enemy Within is well worth your time.
It is often recommended to start with XCOM 1 (Enemy Within) to appreciate the series progression and understand the story. This will also make the transition to XCOM 2 smoother, and allow you to more fully grasp the advancements and changes made in the sequel. Furthermore, playing XCOM 1 first can allow you to be more prepared and strategic when starting XCOM 2, allowing for a smoother and less frustrating experience.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Should I play XCOM or XCOM 2 first?
It’s recommended to play XCOM: Enemy Unknown/Within first, to understand the series’ storyline and appreciate the gameplay changes in XCOM 2.
Is XCOM 1 harder than XCOM 2?
Not necessarily. XCOM 1’s difficulty can be controlled by the player’s strategic progress, while XCOM 2 has a constantly increasing difficulty. XCOM 2 is often considered more challenging overall.
Is XCOM worth playing after XCOM 2?
Yes, absolutely. XCOM 1 (especially with Enemy Within) offers unique gameplay elements not present in XCOM 2. It is not a straight upgrade, and the first game still holds up.
What is the biggest difference between XCOM and XCOM 2?
XCOM 2 has a greater emphasis on narrative and increased enemy and gameplay variety compared to XCOM 1. It also introduces a more dynamic strategic layer.
Is XCOM 1 worth playing before 2?
Yes, it is recommended to play XCOM 1 first to understand the series’ foundations and fully appreciate the advancements made in XCOM 2.
Is XCOM or XCOM 2 easier?
XCOM 2 is considered easier on Veteran and Commander difficulty but more challenging on Legendary difficulty. XCOM 1’s difficulty can be more controlled by the player.
Is XCOM 2 worth playing in 2024?
Yes! XCOM 2 is a great management and tactical combat game that still provides an immersive experience in 2024. It is a must-play for fans of turn-based games.
Which XCOM should I buy?
Starting with either Vanilla XCOM 2 (without Alien Hunters DLC), War of the Chosen (WOTC), or XCOM Enemy Unknown + Enemy Within DLC is recommended, depending on the desired experience.
Will we get an XCOM 3?
Firaxis has confirmed that XCOM 3 is still happening but they are currently focusing on other projects, such as Marvel’s Midnight Suns.
Is XCOM 2 addictive?
Yes, it is considered a highly addictive game, thanks to its blend of tactical combat and resource management.
Who is the strongest character in XCOM 2?
The Reaper is generally recognized as the strongest and best class in XCOM 2, with the Grenadier class as a close second.
Is XCOM 2 never-ending?
Yes, technically. The game will continue to spawn side missions until the player decides to engage in the final mission.
How hard is XCOM 2 for beginners?
XCOM 2 can be difficult for beginners due to its numerous mechanics and options. However, it is possible to overcome the learning curve with patience and strategy.
What is the best order to build in XCOM 2?
A balanced build order is: Advanced Warfare Center, Guerrilla Training School, Power Relay, Resistance Comms, Proving Grounds, and Psi Lab.
Should I play XCOM Enemy Within before 2?
Yes, it’s highly recommended. Experiencing the first game and its expansion will provide context for the sequel, while also giving you a great and distinct experience in its own right.