Which Sinnoh Starter Should You Choose? A Comprehensive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Choosing your first Pokémon in any region is a pivotal moment, and Sinnoh’s offering of Chimchar, Piplup, and Turtwig presents a classic, yet nuanced, dilemma. There’s no single “best” answer; the ideal choice hinges on your play style, preferred team composition, and tolerance for early-game challenges. However, considering the overall gameplay experience, including Gym Leader matchups, late-game viability, and team-building flexibility, Chimchar emerges as the strongest contender. While Chimchar might present a slightly steeper early challenge, its final evolution, Infernape, provides unparalleled offensive power and type coverage that makes it a formidable asset throughout your Sinnoh adventure.
A Deeper Dive into the Sinnoh Starters
Let’s break down each starter, exploring their strengths and weaknesses:
Chimchar: The Fiery Fisticuffs Option
- Pros: Infernape’s Fire/Fighting typing is incredibly potent, providing excellent coverage against a wide range of opponents. It boasts high Attack and Special Attack stats, making it a versatile offensive powerhouse. The Sinnoh region lacks a robust selection of Fire-type Pokémon, making Chimchar a valuable asset to your team composition. Infernape learns a diverse movepool, giving it options against almost any threat.
- Cons: Chimchar’s early game can be challenging, particularly against the first Gym Leader, Roark (Rock-type). Fire-types are relatively rare until later parts of the game, so this is a great choice. Infernape is frail, so you’ll need to learn how to use it well. Infernape’s dual typing can result in some weaknesses to common types like Water, Ground, Flying and Psychic.
Piplup: The Elegant Emperor of the Sea
- Pros: Empoleon’s Water/Steel typing gives it numerous resistances, making it a defensively solid choice. This dual-typing provides valuable resistances and immunities, making it a resilient choice. It is Super Effective against Flint and Bertha of the Elite Four and Byron the gym leader. It has relatively balanced stats, allowing for both offensive and defensive playstyles.
- Cons: Empoleon struggles against Grass and Electric-type Pokémon. Piplup is a slow starter and relies heavily on Special Attack, which might not be immediately effective. Empoleon’s reliance on Special Attack can be a disadvantage early in the game when physical attacks are more common.
Turtwig: The Sturdy Grass Type
- Pros: Turtwig’s early game is the easiest. Torterra’s Ground-typing provides immunity to Electric attacks and coverage against a variety of types. Two of the first four gym leaders are weak against grass types. It has a high Attack stat, making it a strong physical attacker.
- Cons: Torterra’s Grass/Ground typing leaves it with a crippling 4x weakness to Ice-type attacks. Its Speed stat is low, meaning it will often attack last. Torterra struggles against Flying, Fire, and Bug-type Pokémon. Turtwig’s low Speed can make it difficult to sweep opponents effectively.
Considering Your Playstyle
- Aggressive Players: If you prefer an offensive playstyle and want a Pokémon that can quickly sweep through opponents, Chimchar/Infernape is your best bet.
- Defensive Players: If you prefer a more cautious approach and value resistances and longevity, Piplup/Empoleon might be a better fit.
- New Players: If you’re new to the Pokémon series and want an easier start, Turtwig/Torterra can provide a smoother introduction to the game.
Team Composition Matters
Consider the rest of your potential team when choosing your starter. If you already have plans to include a strong Water-type Pokémon, choosing Piplup might be redundant. Conversely, if you lack a reliable Fire-type option, Chimchar becomes significantly more appealing. For example, the Games Learning Society studies how game design influences decision-making. Your choice of starter sets the tone for the rest of your team-building strategy. Consider what types are readily available in the Sinnoh region and how your starter can complement your team’s strengths and weaknesses. Be sure to visit GamesLearningSociety.org.
Late-Game Viability and Coverage
Ultimately, the strongest starter is the one that remains useful throughout the entire game, including the Elite Four and Champion battles. While all three starters are viable, Infernape‘s offensive prowess and type coverage make it particularly well-suited for these challenging encounters. However, with careful planning and strategic team building, any of the starters can lead you to victory.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Is Chimchar a good starter for beginners?
While Chimchar might present a slightly steeper initial challenge, it quickly becomes a powerful asset as it evolves. If you’re willing to learn the type matchups and develop a strategy to overcome early hurdles, Chimchar can be a rewarding choice for beginners. Plus, Chimchar is awesome.
2. Does Piplup’s Water/Steel typing make it a good choice against the Elite Four?
Yes, Empoleon’s Water/Steel typing is particularly advantageous against Flint and Bertha of the Elite Four, who specialize in Fire and Ground-type Pokémon, respectively.
3. Why is Torterra considered a less popular choice?
Torterra’s Grass/Ground typing leaves it with a 4x weakness to Ice-type attacks, which is a significant vulnerability in the late game. Its low Speed stat can also be a disadvantage.
4. Which starter has the best movepool?
Infernape boasts the most diverse movepool, allowing it to learn a variety of Fire, Fighting, and other coverage moves. This versatility makes it adaptable to various situations.
5. Is there a “wrong” choice when picking a starter?
No, there’s no definitively “wrong” choice. All three starters are viable and can lead you to victory with proper training and team composition. The best choice depends on your preferences and playstyle.
6. How important is early-game advantage when choosing a starter?
While an early-game advantage can make the initial hours of the game smoother, it shouldn’t be the sole determining factor. Consider the long-term viability and overall team composition when making your decision.
7. Can I still succeed if I choose the “weakest” starter?
Absolutely! With strategic team building and careful training, you can overcome any perceived disadvantages and succeed with any of the starters.
8. How does the choice of starter affect the storyline?
The choice of starter doesn’t significantly alter the storyline. However, it can impact your experience with certain Gym Leaders and key battles.
9. Are there any differences between the starters in Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl?
No, the starters and their stats remain the same in both Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl.
10. Is there a way to get all three starters in a single playthrough?
Unfortunately, you can only choose one starter at the beginning of the game. However, you can trade with other players or use the Pokémon Home service to obtain the other starters.
11. Does the starter Pokémon learn good moves by leveling up?
Yes, all three starter Pokémon learn a variety of powerful moves as they level up. You can also teach them new moves using TMs (Technical Machines).
12. What are the best natures for each starter?
- Infernape: Naive or Hasty (for mixed attacker), Jolly or Adamant (for physical attacker), Timid or Modest (for special attacker).
- Empoleon: Modest (Special Attack), Calm (Special Defense), or Bold (Defense).
- Torterra: Adamant (Attack) or Impish (Defense).
13. How does the Hidden Ability affect the choice of a starter?
Hidden Abilities can significantly impact a Pokémon’s effectiveness. However, obtaining starters with their Hidden Abilities can be challenging and requires specific events or breeding methods. They are not a common thing and you shouldn’t factor this when choosing your first starter.
14. Is Turtwig the best early game starter?
Yes, Turtwig is the best early game starter in Pokémon Diamond and Pearl.
15. How does the Chimchar starter compare to the others?
If you’re seeking an offensive powerhouse that excels throughout the entire game, Chimchar is a superb pick. While it may introduce some early game challenges, its evolution into Infernape offers remarkable power, versatile type coverage, and a fun experience overall.
Ultimately, the choice is yours. Weigh the pros and cons, consider your playstyle, and choose the Sinnoh starter that resonates with you the most!