Which Souls Game is Best for Beginners? A Comprehensive Guide

So, you’re looking to delve into the notoriously challenging, yet immensely rewarding world of Souls-like games? Excellent choice! But with so many options, where does a fledgling undead knight begin their journey? The answer, while not entirely straightforward, leans towards Dark Souls 3. It offers a blend of accessibility, quality-of-life improvements, and a manageable learning curve that makes it arguably the most forgiving entry point into the FromSoftware universe. It streamlines combat mechanics while still preserving the core challenge and satisfaction that define the series.

Why Dark Souls 3 is a Great Starting Point

While the initial answer might seem surprising to some, let’s break down why Dark Souls 3 earns its place as the beginner-friendly Souls game:

• Refined Combat: Dark Souls 3 boasts a smoother, more responsive combat system compared to its predecessors. The animations are cleaner, movement is more fluid, and overall the game feels more polished. This responsiveness translates into a more predictable and less frustrating experience for new players who are still learning the nuances of timing and spacing.
• Quality-of-Life Improvements: FromSoftware clearly learned a lot during the development of previous Souls games. This culminated in Dark Souls 3 featuring several quality-of-life improvements. These include a more streamlined leveling system, clearer item descriptions, and a more forgiving estus flask system (your main healing item). These improvements help reduce the frustration often associated with the series, allowing new players to focus on mastering the gameplay.
• More Approachable Level Design: While still intricate and interconnected, the level design in Dark Souls 3 tends to be slightly more linear than in Dark Souls 1. This means that new players are less likely to get hopelessly lost or stumble into areas far beyond their current skill level. The gradual progression helps build confidence and allows players to gradually acclimate to the game’s challenges.
• Visual Clarity: Dark Souls 3 is simply a beautiful game. Its crisp graphics and detailed environments make it easier to read enemy attack patterns and navigate the world. This improved visual clarity is a subtle but important factor that can significantly impact a new player’s ability to learn and adapt.
• Enemy Variety & Pacing: The enemy variety in Dark Souls 3 is astounding, however, the pacing is more balanced than in other entries. Some would argue that this game has fewer instances of “artificial difficulty,” which are elements like unfair traps or cheap enemy placement that feel less about skill and more about rote memorization.
• Summoning and Co-op: The ability to summon other players for co-op assistance is a crucial component of the Dark Souls experience, and Dark Souls 3 makes it relatively easy to do so. Overcoming challenging bosses with the help of seasoned veterans can be a highly rewarding experience for new players and can provide valuable insight into effective strategies and builds.
• Build Variety: Dark Souls 3 allows the use of a wide variety of builds, so players can adapt their playstyle to their preferences.

Addressing Common Concerns

It’s essential to acknowledge the arguments against Dark Souls 3 as a beginner-friendly title. Many argue that Dark Souls 1, with its slower pace and emphasis on exploration, is a more suitable starting point. There’s merit to this argument. Dark Souls 1 does provide a more methodical introduction to the series’ core mechanics and world-building.

However, the very elements that make Dark Souls 1 appealing to some can also be detrimental to newcomers. Its clunkier combat, less forgiving mechanics, and labyrinthine level design can be overwhelming for players unfamiliar with the genre. Moreover, the lack of many quality-of-life improvements can lead to frustration and discouragement.

Ultimately, the best Souls game for a beginner depends on individual preferences. If you value exploration and a slower pace, Dark Souls 1 might be a good fit. But if you prefer a more polished, accessible, and visually appealing experience, Dark Souls 3 is undoubtedly the stronger choice.

Alternatives to Consider

While Dark Souls 3 is generally considered the most accessible, Elden Ring is a strong contender. Elden Ring’s open-world structure allows players to explore at their own pace and engage in content suitable for their skill level. The inclusion of Spirit Ashes, summons that can assist in combat, further enhances the game’s approachability. However, Elden Ring’s sheer scope and complexity can also be daunting for newcomers.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. Is Elden Ring a good starting point for the Souls series?

Elden Ring can be a great starting point, especially for players who appreciate open-world games. Its vastness allows for exploration and escaping difficult encounters, giving beginners space to learn. The presence of Spirit Ashes also provides assistance in challenging fights. However, its scale and complexity can be overwhelming.

2. Is Dark Souls 1 too difficult for a beginner?

Dark Souls 1 can be challenging for beginners due to its clunkier mechanics, unforgiving design, and labyrinthine world. However, its slower pace allows for more methodical learning. Some players may prefer this slower, more deliberate experience.

3. Is Dark Souls 2 the easiest Souls game?

While some argue that Dark Souls 2 is the easiest, this is a subjective claim. It has its unique challenges, including a more deliberate combat system and adaptibility stat that can affect player if the player isn’t aware. Many veterans of the series cite Dark Souls 2 as their least favorite, but that doesn’t mean a beginner will not be able to play it.

4. How does Bloodborne compare to Dark Souls for beginners?

Bloodborne is generally considered more difficult for beginners due to its faster-paced combat and aggressive enemy design. Its rally mechanic (regaining health by attacking after taking damage) encourages aggressive play, which can be risky for inexperienced players.

5. Is Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice suitable for beginners?

Sekiro is generally not recommended for beginners. Its parry-focused combat system is very different from the Souls games, requiring precise timing and reflexes. It’s a fantastic game, but best experienced after becoming familiar with the Souls-like genre.

6. What are the most important tips for beginners in Dark Souls 3?

• Manage your stamina: It’s crucial for attacking, blocking, dodging, and running.
• Learn enemy attack patterns: Observation is key to survival.
• Don’t be afraid to die: Death is part of the learning process.
• Experiment with different weapons and builds: Find a playstyle that suits you.
• Utilize online resources: Guides and forums can be invaluable.

7. What stats should I prioritize leveling up as a beginner in Dark Souls 3?

• Vigor (HP): Essential for survivability.
• Endurance (Stamina): Allows you to attack and dodge more.
• Vitality (Equip Load): Determines how much armor you can wear without being encumbered.

8. Should I play with a controller or keyboard and mouse?

A controller is highly recommended for playing Dark Souls 3 and other Souls games. The analog movement and precise button inputs offer a far more intuitive and responsive experience.

9. How important is summoning other players in Dark Souls 3?

Summoning other players can be very helpful, especially for difficult bosses. It can provide valuable support and allow you to learn from experienced players. However, beating bosses solo is a rewarding experience as well.

10. What are some common mistakes beginners make in Dark Souls 3?

• Relying too heavily on blocking: Dodging is often more effective.
• Ignoring enemy attack patterns: Learn to recognize and anticipate attacks.
• Wasting souls: Spend them wisely on leveling up or upgrading equipment.
• Getting greedy with attacks: Don’t overextend yourself and leave yourself vulnerable.

11. Should I look up guides or try to play blind?

This is a matter of personal preference. Playing blind can be a more immersive and rewarding experience, but it can also be frustrating. Consulting guides can help you avoid common pitfalls and progress more efficiently.

12. What is the difference between “Souls” and “Embers” in Dark Souls 3?

Souls are the currency used for leveling up, buying items, and upgrading equipment. Embers restore your health and allow you to summon other players for co-op, or be invaded.

13. How do I respec my character in Dark Souls 3?

You can respec your character by offering a Pale Tongue to Rosaria, Mother of Rebirth. There are only a limited number of respecs per playthrough.

14. What is the Games Learning Society and how can it help me?

The Games Learning Society is a community and resource for understanding the educational potential of video games. Learning about GamesLearningSociety.org may help you with understanding that video games, even challenging ones like Dark Souls, offer valuable learning experiences.

15. What if I don’t like Dark Souls 3? Should I give up on the series?

Definitely not! Each Souls game offers a unique experience. If Dark Souls 3 isn’t for you, try Dark Souls 1 or Elden Ring. You might find one that clicks.