Which Weapon is Better From Elden Remembrance? A Deep Dive
The question of which weapon is best from Elden Remembrances is a common one among Tarnished, and for good reason. Remembrances are unique items obtained after defeating major bosses in Elden Ring, and they can be exchanged for powerful weapons, spells, or runes. This choice often shapes the direction of a player’s build and gameplay style. Unfortunately, there isn’t a single, definitive “best” weapon from all remembrances. Instead, the optimal choice depends entirely on your character build, preferred playstyle, and current needs within the game.
However, we can identify some standouts, and compare some frequently asked about choices. For example, from the Elden Remembrance, you get to choose between Marika’s Hammer or the Sacred Relic Sword. The Sacred Relic Sword is widely considered the superior choice for its massive AOE (area-of-effect) potential thanks to its unique skill, “Wave of Gold”. This can quickly dispatch hordes of enemies. On the other hand, Marika’s Hammer is a strength/faith scaling weapon with a powerful slam attack, best used for situations where you can reliably land heavy hits. In general, the Sacred Relic Sword provides more versatility and is more widely applicable, making it a better overall pick for most players.
It’s vital to consider the specific weapons offered from each Remembrance. For example, the Remembrance of the Rot Goddess provides either the Hand of Malenia or an incantation. The Hand of Malenia is a Dexterity scaling katana with a unique and powerful Ash of War, but is difficult to use. Many players would find it a better choice for high dexterity build, while the incantation may be more applicable to a faith or hybrid build.
Ultimately, the “best” remembrance weapon is highly subjective. The purpose of this article is to help you make the most informed decision when facing these crucial choices.
Understanding Remembrance Choices
Not All Remembrances are Created Equal
It’s important to understand that not all Remembrances are created equal. Some offer multiple powerful options, making it crucial to duplicate the Remembrance in a Walking Mausoleum to acquire both items. Others have choices that are less impactful, making rune consumption a viable option for those with sufficient weaponry already.
Consider Your Build
Before exchanging a Remembrance, take a good look at your current stats, play style, and build. If you’re a strength-focused player, a greatsword or hammer might be more beneficial. Alternatively, a dexterity-based character might want a katana or other quicker weapon. Faith and intelligence-based builds will lean toward incantations and sorceries, making those choices better than any melee alternative.
Don’t Be Afraid to Experiment
Elden Ring encourages experimentation. Don’t be afraid to try different weapons and spells to see what works best for you. Remember that you can always duplicate Remembrances and try multiple items.
Top Remembrance Weapons and Why They Stand Out
While the “best” depends on your preferences, some Remembrance weapons consistently rank among the top due to their overall power and usefulness:
- Blasphemous Blade (Remembrance of the Blasphemous): This greatsword is a powerful faith/strength scaling weapon with a very strong Ash of War that heals the user on hits. This makes it both damaging and defensive.
- Starscourge Greatsword (Remembrance of the Starscourge): A strength-scaling pair of greatswords that are great for stagger and deal decent damage. The unique Ash of War will pull enemies into you for easy stagger combos.
- Sacred Relic Sword (Elden Remembrance): As mentioned before, it has excellent AOE and strong faith scaling, making it an effective weapon for a wide variety of encounters.
- Mohgwyn’s Sacred Spear (Remembrance Of The Blood Lord): A powerful blood scaling great spear with an excellent Ash of War that can melt bosses and crowd control groups of enemies.
- Giant’s Red Braid (Remembrance Of The Fire Giant): A faith-scaling whip that is often overlooked but can make short work of many of Elden Ring’s bosses.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some common questions regarding Remembrances and their associated rewards:
1. What are Remembrances in Elden Ring?
Remembrances are special items dropped by major bosses in Elden Ring. They can be traded for unique weapons, spells, or runes.
2. How do I trade Remembrances?
You can trade Remembrances with Finger Reader Enia at the Roundtable Hold.
3. Can I get both items from a Remembrance?
Yes, by duplicating the Remembrance at a Walking Mausoleum, you can acquire both items.
4. How do I duplicate a Remembrance?
To duplicate a Remembrance, you must activate a Walking Mausoleum. These giant, turtle-like structures can be found throughout the Lands Between.
5. How many times can I duplicate a Remembrance?
You can duplicate one Remembrance per Walking Mausoleum. Choose your duplications carefully.
6. Should I consume Remembrances for Runes?
Generally, it’s better to trade Remembrances for unique weapons or spells because Runes can be obtained through other means.
7. What is the best Remembrance to duplicate?
The Remembrance of the Lichdragon is often considered the best to duplicate due to the two powerful incantations it offers.
8. Which Remembrance gives you the Hand of Malenia?
The Remembrance of the Rot Goddess provides the Hand of Malenia.
9. Which Remembrance provides the Blasphemous Blade?
The Remembrance of the Blasphemous gives you the Blasphemous Blade.
10. Is the Sacred Relic Sword good?
Yes, the Sacred Relic Sword is a very powerful weapon, known for its excellent AOE skill, “Wave of Gold.”
11. Is the Hand of Malenia a good weapon?
Yes, the Hand of Malenia is a strong dexterity-scaling katana, but it requires skilled use due to it’s relatively complicated Ash of War.
12. What is Marika’s Hammer and is it worth it?
Marika’s Hammer is a strength/faith scaling hammer that can be obtained from the Elden Remembrance. It is a strong hammer but is often considered less versatile than the Sacred Relic Sword.
13. Do Remembrances carry over into New Game Plus?
Yes, any unused Remembrances will carry over into New Game Plus.
14. What is the best straight sword from a remembrance?
The Elden Remembrance doesn’t offer any straight swords. However, among straight swords, the Sword of Night and Flame is frequently ranked at the top.
15. When should I use Remembrances?
You can use Remembrances when they benefit your character’s build, but it is typically better to wait for a Walking Mausoleum to duplicate them in order to get both rewards. You may consider using them for Runes if you find yourself needing to level up at any point.
Conclusion
Choosing the right weapon from a Remembrance in Elden Ring is a key decision that can significantly impact your gameplay experience. While there is no universally “best” choice, understanding your build, playstyle, and the specific advantages of each Remembrance offering will guide you to the most appropriate selection for your character. Remember, it’s a journey of experimentation, so don’t be afraid to explore the diverse range of weapons and spells that the Lands Between has to offer. By understanding these choices and making use of Walking Mausoleums, you can become an Elden Lord with the perfect arsenal!