Navigating Friendships and Betrayals: Who Can You Trust in Hogwarts Legacy?

Hogwarts Legacy offers a rich tapestry of characters, alliances, and moral dilemmas. While the game allows for significant player agency in shaping your character’s journey, the question of trust remains central. The reality is that trust is situational and depends heavily on your character’s moral compass and the choices you make. There is no single character in Hogwarts Legacy that can be blindly trusted, and conversely, no character that is inherently untrustworthy. What you need to consider is their motivations, their actions, and how those align with your own values within the game. While Natty is presented as a generally trustworthy and helpful companion, her unwavering dedication to justice might clash with a player who is more lenient or pragmatic. Sebastian Sallow, on the other hand, is a complex character whose pursuit of darker knowledge can lead to dangerous consequences, even though he is fiercely loyal to those he cares about. Ultimately, deciding who to trust in Hogwarts Legacy hinges on how closely their principles align with your own gameplay style.

Trust and Consequences in Hogwarts Legacy

Hogwarts Legacy presents a nuanced view of morality. While you can’t become an all-out evil villain, your choices do have consequences, primarily affecting your relationships with other characters. The game masterfully weaves these moral dilemmas into the narrative, forcing you to consider the implications of your actions.

• Natty Onai: A Gryffindor student with a strong sense of justice. She is a reliable ally, especially if you value fairness and protecting others. However, her rigid morality might lead to conflict if you’re willing to bend the rules.

• Sebastian Sallow: A Slytherin student fascinated by the Dark Arts. He is a loyal friend but driven by a desire to protect his sister, which can lead him down a dangerous path. Trusting him means accepting the risks associated with his darker pursuits.

• Ominis Gaunt: A descendant of Salazar Slytherin, Ominis is conflicted by his family’s dark history. Although wary of the Dark Arts, he’s fiercely loyal to Sebastian, creating a complex dynamic that requires careful navigation.

• Professor Fig: A dedicated professor invested in your well-being and the mysteries surrounding ancient magic. He acts as a mentor, but withholding information or making choices he disapproves of can affect your relationship.

Therefore, when considering who to trust, focus on:

• Shared Values: Do their goals and principles align with yours?
• Actions and Consequences: Have their actions demonstrated reliability, or have they been reckless and self-serving?
• Personal Morality: Are you comfortable with the compromises they might make?

Navigating the Hogsmeade Trip

The decision of whether to go to Hogsmeade with Natty or Sebastian is a crucial point where you begin to form deeper bonds. While the article explicitly states that it “doesn’t really make too much of a difference,” consider it an opportunity to solidify a relationship that aligns with your intended gameplay.

• Choosing Natty: Reinforces a commitment to justice and doing what’s right.
• Choosing Sebastian: Signals a willingness to explore morally ambiguous paths.

This choice, while not dramatically altering the storyline, helps establish the tone of your character’s relationships and future interactions.

The Sebastian Dilemma: To Turn Him In or Not?

The most significant moral choice in Hogwarts Legacy revolves around Sebastian Sallow’s actions, specifically the killing of his uncle. This decision has far-reaching consequences:

• Turning Sebastian In: He will be expelled and unavailable for future quests, including the opportunity to learn the Unforgivable Curses, unless you begin a new game. Ominis Gaunt will take his place in the quest line.

• Not Turning Sebastian In: He remains at Hogwarts, continuing to teach you the Unforgivable Curses if you haven’t already learned them. This choice acknowledges his crime but prioritizes the player’s access to powerful spells and the continuation of his questline.

The decision to turn Sebastian in or not should be weighed based on:

• Your Character’s Moral Code: Would your character condone murder, even if committed in self-defense or out of desperation?
• Gameplay Considerations: Do you prioritize learning the Unforgivable Curses, even if it means condoning Sebastian’s actions?
• Long-Term Consequences: Are you willing to sacrifice Sebastian’s presence in the end-game content for the sake of your moral convictions?

Morality and Endings

Hogwarts Legacy features both “good” and “bad” endings, along with a universal final scene. This means your choices impact the narrative’s outcome, but not in a game-breaking way. While you can’t become a fully-fledged villain, your decisions regarding ancient magic and your relationships with characters contribute to the overall conclusion.

• Good Ending: Keeping the ancient magic contained and secret.
• “Bad” Ending: Suggesting different ways of dealing with the ancient magic.

Even choosing darker spells won’t automatically make you evil. The real measure lies in how you use those spells and the justifications you offer for your actions. This offers an interesting perspective on the Games Learning Society and how games can explore moral dilemmas.

FAQs: Trust and Choices in Hogwarts Legacy

Is Natty a trustworthy friend?

Natty is generally portrayed as a trustworthy and loyal friend. However, her strong sense of justice might conflict with players who are willing to bend the rules or make morally questionable decisions.

Can I trust Sebastian Sallow?

Sebastian is a more complex case. While loyal to his friends, his obsession with Dark Arts and protecting his sister leads him down dangerous paths. Trusting him means accepting the risks associated with his choices.

What happens if I betray Sebastian?

Turning Sebastian in results in his expulsion from Hogwarts, removing him from future quests and the epilogue. Ominis Gaunt will take his place in the “In the Shadow of Friendship” quest line.

Can I learn Avada Kedavra after turning Sebastian in?

No. Turning Sebastian in prevents you from learning Avada Kedavra in that playthrough. You would need to start a new game to learn it.

Does it matter whom I choose to go to Hogsmeade with?

While the article suggests it doesn’t make a huge difference, choosing Natty or Sebastian reflects your character’s alignment and can influence your relationship with them.

Can I prevent Sebastian from killing his uncle?

No, the showdown between Sebastian and his uncle is a fixed plot point. You cannot change this event.

Is there a way to avoid making difficult choices?

No. Hogwarts Legacy is designed to present players with moral dilemmas and challenging choices that shape their character’s journey.

What determines the ending I get in Hogwarts Legacy?

The ending you receive is primarily determined by your choices during the final Keeper trial and your handling of the ancient magic.

Can I be expelled from Hogwarts?

No, you cannot be expelled from Hogwarts, but turning in Sebastian will result in his expulsion.

Does my Hogwarts house affect whom I can trust?

While your house doesn’t inherently dictate whom you can trust, it can influence your initial interactions and relationships with other students. Choosing Slytherin, for example, grants more opportunities to interact with Sebastian Sallow and Ominis Gaunt.

What is the “bad” ending in Hogwarts Legacy?

The “bad” ending involves making choices that lead to the potential release or misuse of the ancient magic. It’s not a definitive “evil” ending but rather a morally ambiguous one.

Can I be truly evil in Hogwarts Legacy?

No, you cannot canonically be evil in Hogwarts Legacy. While you can make morally questionable choices, you will not become a Voldemort-like figure.

Should I learn the Unforgivable Curses?

Learning the Unforgivable Curses is a personal choice. They grant powerful abilities but may also impact your relationships with other characters.

How does lying to Professor Weasley affect the game?

Lying to Professor Weasley is a role-playing choice with no significant impact on the game’s outcome.

Where can I learn more about games and their educational impact?

You can explore the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org to discover how video games can be powerful tools for learning and engagement.