Who Has Abigail Slept With in Red Dead Redemption 2? A Deep Dive into Abigail’s Past
Abigail Marston’s past is a complex and often debated topic among Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2) fans. Directly answering the question: Abigail Marston slept with multiple members of the Van der Linde gang before settling down with John Marston. Specifically, the game implies, and several characters explicitly state, that she had intimate relationships with Javier Escuella and Arthur Morgan, in addition to John. While the extent and nature of these relationships remain somewhat ambiguous, it’s clear that Abigail’s history is interwoven with the lives of many gang members.
Abigail’s Relationships within the Van der Linde Gang
Abigail joined the Van der Linde gang at a young age, likely as a runaway or an orphan. The gang, for her, became a surrogate family, although a highly dysfunctional one. Life within the gang was chaotic, dangerous, and morally ambiguous. Her involvement with multiple members underscores the close, sometimes blurred, lines that existed within that community.
Abigail and John Marston
Abigail’s relationship with John Marston is the core of her story in both Red Dead Redemption games. Despite the complexities and uncertainties of their past, they form a lasting bond and raise their son, Jack. John and Abigail’s relationship is characterized by both deep affection and persistent conflict, largely stemming from John’s inability to leave his outlaw past behind and Abigail’s desire for a normal, stable life. John’s dedication to her and Jack is a constant throughout the narrative, driving his actions and ultimately leading to his sacrifice.
Abigail and Arthur Morgan
The nature of Abigail’s relationship with Arthur Morgan is a point of much discussion. While never explicitly shown on screen, hints and dialogue strongly suggest a past romantic or sexual entanglement. Arthur, in his journal, reflects on Abigail and her past, demonstrating an awareness and a possible regret or understanding of their history. Characters like Hosea Matthews also allude to a past connection between them. Arthur’s interactions with Jack, often paternal, further complicate the picture. Though unspoken, there’s a palpable sense of shared history and underlying affection between Arthur and Abigail.
Abigail and Javier Escuella
Javier Escuella’s involvement with Abigail is more directly implied. Several conversations and character interactions suggest a romantic or sexual relationship existed between them before the events of the game. Dialogue from other gang members and subtle cues in their interactions hint at this past connection. While Javier’s role in Abigail’s life isn’t as central as John’s or Arthur’s, it’s a significant aspect of her history and underscores the interconnectedness of the gang’s members.
FAQs About Abigail Marston’s Past
Here are some of the most frequently asked questions about Abigail Marston’s past and her relationships within the Red Dead Redemption universe:
1. Is it explicitly stated that Abigail slept with Arthur?
No, it is not explicitly stated. However, strong implications and subtle cues within the game suggest a past romantic or sexual relationship. These are largely conveyed through dialogue and character interactions.
2. Why is Abigail’s past important to the story?
Abigail’s past helps to contextualize her character and her motivations. It highlights the complexities of life within the Van der Linde gang and underscores the sacrifices she makes for her family. Her experiences shape her desire for a stable life and fuel her determination to protect Jack from the outlaw world.
3. Does John know about Abigail’s past relationships?
Yes, John is aware of Abigail’s past relationships within the gang. This knowledge contributes to the tension and complexities in their relationship.
4. How does Arthur feel about Abigail?
Arthur seems to have a complicated affection for Abigail. He cares deeply for Jack and is protective of both of them. His journal entries and interactions with Abigail hint at a past connection and a possible regret or understanding of her choices.
5. Is Jack Marston Arthur’s son?
This is a popular fan theory, but there is no concrete evidence to support it. While Arthur shows a paternal affection for Jack, the game never confirms or denies his biological parentage.
6. Does Abigail love John?
Yes, despite the hardships and challenges, Abigail loves John deeply. Her love for him and Jack is the driving force behind her desire for a better life.
7. How old was Abigail when she joined the Van der Linde gang?
The game suggests she was very young, likely a teenager, when she joined the gang. The exact age is never explicitly stated.
8. Was Abigail forced into these relationships?
The game doesn’t explicitly state that Abigail was forced into any relationships. While the circumstances of her life were undoubtedly challenging, her relationships appear to have been consensual, though within the complex power dynamics of the gang.
9. How does the game portray Abigail’s agency?
Abigail is portrayed as a strong-willed and resilient woman who navigates difficult circumstances. While her options are limited, she actively makes choices to protect herself and her family.
10. What is the significance of Abigail’s transformation in Red Dead Redemption?
In the first Red Dead Redemption, Abigail has clearly matured and is determined to create a better future for Jack. This transformation reflects the character development she undergoes throughout her life, driven by her desire for a stable and loving family.
11. How do other gang members view Abigail?
Gang members have varied opinions of Abigail. Some respect her resilience, while others view her with suspicion or disdain. Her relationships with multiple members likely influenced these perceptions.
12. Does Abigail regret her past?
It is likely that Abigail has mixed feelings about her past. While she may regret some of the choices she made, she also recognizes that her experiences shaped who she is and ultimately led her to John and Jack.
13. What does Abigail want for Jack?
Above all, Abigail wants a normal life for Jack, free from the violence and chaos of the outlaw world. She wants him to receive an education and have opportunities that she never had.
14. How does John try to atone for his past actions toward Abigail?
John tries to atone for his past by dedicating himself to providing for Abigail and Jack. He works hard to build a stable home for them and attempts to leave his outlaw life behind, though it ultimately proves impossible.
15. What can Red Dead Redemption 2 teach us about choices and consequences?
RDR2, and particularly Abigail’s story, is a powerful exploration of choices and consequences. It demonstrates how past decisions can shape one’s future and how individuals can strive for redemption despite their past mistakes. The game encourages reflection on themes of morality, family, and the human condition. Understanding how games can teach us about the world is the kind of thing studied at Games Learning Society. You can find out more about them at GamesLearningSociety.org.