Who Killed Haytham Kenway? Unraveling the Father-Son Conflict in Assassin’s Creed III

The answer is straightforward: Connor Kenway, also known as Ratonhnhaké:ton, killed Haytham Kenway in 1781. Their final confrontation marks one of the most emotionally charged and pivotal moments in Assassin’s Creed III. However, the story behind this act is far more complex than a simple declaration of killer and victim. It’s a tragic tale of clashing ideologies, familial bonds strained by war, and the devastating consequences of a conflict that transcended generations. Let’s delve into the circumstances surrounding Haytham’s death and explore the web of relationships that led to this fateful encounter.

The Complex Relationship Between Connor and Haytham

A Father and Son Divided by Ideology

Haytham Kenway, the Grand Master of the Templar Colonial Rite, and Connor Kenway, an Assassin fighting for his people’s freedom, found themselves on opposing sides of the American Revolution. While sharing a bloodline, their deeply rooted allegiances prevented any true reconciliation. Haytham sought to establish order through control, a Templar ideal, while Connor fought for liberty and the preservation of his Native American heritage, goals that put them in direct conflict.

Their relationship wasn’t entirely devoid of affection. There were instances of fleeting cooperation, moments where a fatherly instinct seemed to surface in Haytham. He even rescued Connor from execution earlier in the game, showcasing a complex and conflicted love. However, their fundamental differences in worldview and objectives always resurfaced, making any sustained alliance impossible.

The Inevitability of Their Final Confrontation

The tragic climax occurred during the siege of Fort George. Connor, intent on eliminating Charles Lee, the man responsible for his mother’s death, found himself facing Haytham. During their brutal exchange, both characters understood the gravity of the situation. Ultimately, Connor struck the fatal blow, ending Haytham’s life and solidifying the divide between the Assassins and Templars. Connor’s inscription beside Haytham’s portrait in the homestead basement, “sakataterihwáhten,” meaning “I made a mistake,” highlights the remorse and regret he carried for his actions.

Haytham’s Templar Path: A Fall From Grace?

The Influence of Mentorship and Manipulation

Many players wonder why Haytham Kenway turned to the Templar Order in the first place. As a child, he was trained by his father, Edward Kenway, but unknowingly introduced into the Templar ideology by Reginald Birch, the man Edward trusted. Birch manipulated Haytham, concealing the true nature of the Assassins and Templars, and molding him into a loyal Templar. This early indoctrination shaped Haytham’s worldview, leading him down a path of control and order.

A Realization of Truth?

Later in his life, the dark revelations surrounding Birch’s schemes and motivations caused Haytham to question the very foundations of his Templar beliefs. This realization that he had been a pawn in a larger game, trained his entire life, filled with lies and manipulations, contributed to his complex character, and possibly played a role in his final confrontation with Connor, adding another layer of tragedy to his demise.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Here are 15 frequently asked questions related to Haytham Kenway’s death and his relationship with Connor Kenway:

1. Did Connor regret killing Haytham? Yes, Connor expresses regret through the inscription “sakataterihwáhten” next to Haytham’s portrait, indicating he felt he made a mistake.

2. Why did Haytham Kenway turn bad? Haytham was unknowingly indoctrinated into the Templar Order by Reginald Birch. He was trained to believe in the Templar ideals of control and order from a young age.

3. Who is Connor Kenway’s dad? Haytham Kenway is Connor Kenway’s father. He is also the Grand Master of the Templar Colonial Rite.

4. How old was Haytham when Edward died? Haytham was nine years old when his father, Edward Kenway, was killed.

5. Did Haytham let Connor win? While not explicitly stated, some interpret Haytham’s journal entries, found by Connor after his death, as evidence that he allowed Connor to kill him, hoping Connor would understand his perspective and forgive him.

6. Why did Haytham not become an Assassin? Haytham was raised with Templar ideals, manipulated by Reginald Birch after his father’s death. He was never truly presented with the option to become an Assassin. His father, Edward, taught him to think for himself but never revealed the larger conflict between Assassins and Templars.

7. Is Haytham in Black Flag? No, Haytham is not a playable character or directly present in Assassin’s Creed IV: Black Flag, but his father, Edward Kenway, is the protagonist. Desmond experiences a bleeding effect in the beginning of Assassin’s Creed III where he experiences a memory with Haytham.

8. Why did Haytham betray Connor? Haytham did not necessarily betray Connor, but his Templar allegiance put them at odds. He attempted to sway Connor to the Templar side, but when that failed, their conflicting ideologies made a direct confrontation inevitable.

9. Who killed Connor Kenway’s mother? Connor’s mother, Kaniehti:io, was killed when her village was raided and burned by a group of Templars led by Charles Lee.

10. What happened to Connor Kenway after AC3? After the events of Assassin’s Creed III, Connor continued to lead the North American Assassin Brotherhood. Comic books reveal he had a daughter whom he trained as an Assassin. Abstergo Employee Handbook implies that he died a lonely death, but this is debunked by the comics.

11. Was Haytham a good father to Connor? Their relationship was complex and strained by their allegiances. While there were moments of connection, their conflicting ideologies and roles in the Assassin-Templar conflict prevented them from forming a healthy father-son bond.

12. What are the themes explored in the Connor-Haytham relationship? The relationship explores themes of ideological conflict, familial duty versus personal beliefs, and the tragic consequences of war.

13. What is the significance of Haytham’s death in the Assassin’s Creed universe? Haytham’s death represents the culmination of the ideological clash between Assassins and Templars during the American Revolution and highlights the personal cost of this conflict.

14. Is Haytham Kenway considered an evil character? Haytham’s morality is complex and debated by fans. While he adheres to Templar ideals and engages in morally questionable actions, he also demonstrates moments of compassion and possesses a strong sense of loyalty.

15. What is the legacy of Haytham Kenway? Haytham Kenway remains one of the most memorable characters in the Assassin’s Creed franchise, recognized for his complex motivations, strong personality, and the tragic nature of his relationship with his son, Connor.

The Enduring Legacy of a Father-Son Conflict

The death of Haytham Kenway at the hands of his son, Connor, remains one of the most emotionally impactful moments in the Assassin’s Creed series. It serves as a stark reminder of the devastating consequences of ideological conflict and the personal sacrifices made in the pursuit of freedom and order. The complex relationship between Haytham and Connor transcends a simple good versus evil narrative, offering a nuanced exploration of the human cost of war and the enduring power of familial bonds, even when fractured by conflicting beliefs. The game challenges the player to grapple with moral ambiguities and question the true meaning of justice and freedom, elements that contribute to its enduring appeal.

If you’re interested in learning more about the educational impact of video games and their narratives, consider visiting the Games Learning Society website at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/. GamesLearningSociety.org provides valuable resources and research on how games can be used as tools for learning and social change.