Unraveling the Dartmoor Mystery: Who Killed Zachary Carlisle in Hitman 3?
The answer, plain and simple, is Emma Carlisle. While the Hitman 3 mission “Death in the Family” presents a compelling murder mystery, the true culprit behind Zachary Carlisle’s demise is Emma, driven by a complex web of family secrets and personal ambition. But the brilliance of Hitman 3 lies in the player’s agency. Agent 47, disguised as a private investigator, can manipulate evidence to accuse other suspects, leading to different outcomes and altering Alexa Carlisle’s fate. Let’s delve deeper into the details and explore the intricacies of this captivating mission.
Dissecting the Crime Scene: Evidence Against Emma
Emma’s motive stems from her relationship with the Carlisle family. As both Alexa’s daughter-in-law and illegitimate niece, she harbors resentment and seeks to secure her own future. The game provides a plethora of evidence pointing directly to her guilt:
- Emma’s Dirty Shoes: Found in her and Gregory’s room, these shoes indicate Emma was recently in the muddy grounds of the greenhouse.
- Greenhouse Key Fob: Located in her room, this key fob grants access to the greenhouse, the location where she prepared the poison.
- The Greenhouse: A crucial location. Here, you’ll find evidence of the distilled poison she used to kill Zachary.
- Distillation Kit Manipulation: The repaired distillation kit demonstrates Emma’s knowledge and involvement in creating the poison.
- Opportunity: After the family meeting, Emma retreats to the Greenhouse, providing her the opportunity to prepare the deadly substance.
- Poisoned Drink: Emma spikes a drink in the Sitting Room, which is then consumed by Zachary.
While it’s possible to frame other characters, the collected evidence undeniably suggests Emma’s direct involvement in Zachary’s murder.
The Art of Deception: Framing Other Suspects
The beauty of “Death in the Family” lies in its intricate web of suspects and the potential to frame someone other than the true killer. You can manipulate the environment and evidence to point the finger at various individuals:
- Mr. Fernsby (The Butler): By planting evidence, you can convince Alexa that the loyal butler is responsible.
- Zachary Carlisle (Himself): You can present a case that Zachary took his own life, driven by guilt and despair.
- Other Family Members: While more difficult, planting specific evidence can implicate other Carlisle family members in the crime.
Each accusation leads to a different outcome, impacting Alexa Carlisle’s reaction and the rewards you receive.
The Consequences of Your Choices: Alexa Carlisle’s Fate
Your choice of suspect significantly affects Alexa Carlisle’s reaction.
- Accusing Emma: Reveals Emma’s complicated familial connection, ultimately leading to Alexa’s anger and a sense of betrayal.
- Accusing Mr. Fernsby: Results in Alexa’s heartbreak and a potential opportunity to eliminate her in a seemingly accidental manner.
- Accusing Zachary: Leads to Alexa experiencing intense guilt, prompting her to offer you the case file without further conflict.
The consequences are far-reaching, influencing not only the mission’s outcome but also the emotional narrative surrounding the Carlisle family.
The Secret Ending: A Twist in the Tale
While “Death in the Family” has multiple outcomes based on your chosen suspect, Hitman 3 also features a secret ending in a later mission. During the final confrontation with Arthur Edwards, you have the option to inject yourself with the serum instead of administering it to him. This decision leads to a drastically different conclusion, bringing Agent 47 back to his roots.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are 15 frequently asked questions, providing more context and details about the Zachary Carlisle murder in Hitman 3:
What are the 6 clues in Zachary’s bedroom?
The six clues in Zachary’s bedroom that are relevant for your investigation are:
- Zachary Carlisle’s Body (Camera Scan)
- Nightstand Whiskey Bottle (Camera Scan)
- Zachary’s laptop
- Suicide Note
- Walking Cane (hidden passage)
- Secret Room
How do you convince Alexa that Zachary committed suicide in Hitman 3?
To successfully frame Zachary, you must scan the whiskey bottle on his nightstand to confirm the poison ingestion method, analyze his laptop for evidence of emotional distress, and examine the suicide note for a handwriting sample confirming it’s his. Then, you present this evidence to Alexa, crafting a narrative of self-inflicted demise.
Can you accuse Emma in Hitman 3?
Absolutely! Accusing Emma is the most straightforward path to solving the murder, as the game presents a wealth of evidence linking her to the crime. You’ll need to gather evidence from her room, the greenhouse, and analyze the poison used to definitively point the finger at her.
What evidence is needed against Emma in Hitman 3?
To convincingly accuse Emma, you require: Emma’s dirty shoes, the Greenhouse Key Fob from her room, and evidence from the Greenhouse demonstrating the repaired distillation kit and the prepared poison. These pieces of evidence collectively paint a picture of her involvement in Zachary’s death.
What happens if you frame Mr. Fernsby?
If you successfully frame Mr. Fernsby, Alexa will be devastated. She will hand over the intel you need to complete the level, then dismiss her guards to grieve privately on her balcony, where you can trigger an “accidental” fall.
What happens if you accuse Zachary?
Accusing Zachary triggers intense guilt within Alexa. She will provide you with the intel you need and retreat to process her grief, offering an opportunity for a more subtle and perhaps less violent resolution.
What happens if you ask for money in Hitman 3?
If, after solving the mystery, you choose to ask Alexa for money rather than the case file on Arthur Edwards, she will thank you and dismiss you. She’ll be none the wiser about your true intentions and you’ll miss the opportunity to acquire crucial information.
How do you get another death in the family Hitman 3?
To achieve “Another Death in the Family,” you must cause a second death – typically Alexa’s. This can be achieved by pushing her off the balcony after framing Fernsby or by allowing Emma to poison her during a second playthrough where you avoid accusing Emma.
Is there a secret ending in Hitman 3?
Yes! The secret ending is triggered in the final mission by injecting yourself with the serum intended for Arthur Edwards. This leads to a unique and unexpected conclusion to the Hitman trilogy.
Who should I fire Hitman 3?
This question pertains to the Chongqing mission, not Dartmoor. To efficiently trigger Imogen Royce’s demise, you should fire Alicia, Jeremy, and Sharon in that specific order.
What is the secret ending in Hitman 3?
The secret ending, as mentioned, involves injecting yourself with the serum. This action erases Agent 47’s memory and aligns him with the Constant, providing a stark contrast to the game’s other endings.
Who are the suspects in Hitman 3?
The primary suspects in the “Death in the Family” mission are: Zachary, Gregory, Edward, Rebecca, Emma, Patrick, and Mr. Fernsby. Each character has their own motivations and potential connections to the crime, making for a compelling investigation.
How do you get the PI in Hitman 3?
To acquire the Private Investigator disguise, you must intercept him before he reaches the mansion. Subdue him unnoticed and take his attire to gain access to the investigation without raising suspicion.
How many endings does Hitman 3 have?
Hitman 3 has three primary endings: two based on your choice in the final mission (eliminating Arthur Edwards or not) and a secret ending triggered by self-injection. Each offers a distinct resolution to the overarching narrative.
Why can’t I accuse Emma?
If you’re unable to accuse Emma, it’s likely because you haven’t gathered all the necessary evidence. Ensure you’ve thoroughly investigated her room, the greenhouse, and collected all relevant clues to solidify your case.
Learning Through Games: More Than Just Entertainment
The Hitman series, and Hitman 3 in particular, demonstrates the power of video games as tools for critical thinking and problem-solving. The intricate murder mystery in “Death in the Family” requires players to analyze evidence, consider different perspectives, and make strategic decisions based on incomplete information. This aligns with the core principles of Games Learning Society, which explores the educational potential of video games. The ability to manipulate variables and observe consequences within a safe, virtual environment promotes valuable skills applicable to real-world situations. Visit GamesLearningSociety.org to learn more about the intersection of gaming and education.
In conclusion, while Hitman 3 offers a variety of paths and outcomes, the true killer of Zachary Carlisle is Emma. However, the game’s genius lies in its ability to empower players to manipulate the narrative and shape the fate of the Carlisle family. Whether you choose to expose Emma’s deceit or frame another suspect, the consequences of your actions will resonate throughout the mission, leaving a lasting impact on Alexa Carlisle and the twisted secrets of the Carlisle family.