Who Pays More for Fish in Animal Crossing?

The short answer is: C.J. the beaver pays the most for fish in Animal Crossing: New Horizons. He buys fish for 150% of their original value compared to what Timmy and Tommy at Nook’s Cranny offer. This makes him the go-to guy when you’re looking to maximize your profits from your fishing endeavors. While Nook’s Cranny is a reliable place to sell your catches, you’ll want to save those premium fish for C.J.’s visits to your island.

The Value of Your Catch: A Breakdown

Understanding the economics of fish selling in Animal Crossing is crucial for getting the most out of your fishing time. Here’s a breakdown of who pays what:

Nook’s Cranny: The Base Value

Timmy and Tommy at Nook’s Cranny provide the baseline price for all fish. This is the standard value you see listed in various guides. They’re reliable and always available, but their prices are not the most profitable. Crucially, if you use the drop-off box outside when the shop is closed, you will only receive 80% of the standard value for your fish – so always wait for the shop to be open!

C.J.: The Profit Maximizer

When C.J., the charismatic beaver, visits your island, you have the opportunity to significantly increase your fish profits. He pays a whopping 150% of the base value, meaning you get 1.5 times more Bells per fish compared to selling at Nook’s Cranny. For example, if a fish normally sells for 1,000 Bells at Nook’s, C.J. would pay you 1,500 Bells.

Top-Tier Fish

Some fish are naturally more valuable than others. These top-tier fish can bring in a significant amount of Bells, especially when sold to C.J. Here are some of the most expensive fish:

• Stringfish: 15,000 Bells
• Dorado: 15,000 Bells
• Barreleye: 15,000 Bells
• Coelacanth: 15,000 Bells
• Golden Trout: 15,000 Bells
• Great White Shark: 15,000 Bells

Selling any of these to C.J. will net you a cool 22,500 Bells a piece! This is a major incentive to actively fish for them.

Strategies for Selling Smart

1. Save for C.J.: Whenever possible, hold onto your valuable fish and sell them to C.J. This maximizes your earnings. Store them in your house if you need to.

2. Check Daily: Keep an eye out for C.J., who randomly visits your island. He typically stays for the day and leaves at 5 am the following morning.

3. Complete the Challenge: Before C.J. will buy your fish, he will ask you to complete a Seasports Challenge.

4. Don’t Sell Sea Creatures: C.J. only buys fish you catch with a fishing rod, not sea creatures caught through diving.

5. Donating to the Museum: Remember to donate the very first of each fish to Blathers to fill out your museum!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Here are some frequently asked questions that will further enhance your understanding of selling fish in Animal Crossing: New Horizons:

1. What is the most profitable fish in Animal Crossing?

The most profitable fish are a tie between six species: Stringfish, Dorado, Barreleye, Coelacanth, Golden Trout, and the Great White Shark, all selling for 15,000 Bells at Nook’s Cranny. When you sell them to C.J. for 150% value, they are worth 22,500 Bells.

2. Does C.J. pay more for fish than Nook?

Yes, C.J. pays significantly more for fish. He buys fish for 150% of the price that Timmy and Tommy offer at Nook’s Cranny.

3. How do I find C.J.?

C.J. is a random visitor to your island, and he’ll be somewhere around the map when he appears. He does not get announced by Isabelle so make sure to check! C.J. typically leaves at 5 am the following day.

4. Is it worth saving fish for C.J.?

Absolutely! Saving your fish for C.J. is the best strategy for maximizing your profit. The extra 50% he pays makes a huge difference.

5. What does C.J. do besides buying fish?

In addition to buying your fish, C.J. will also commission you to create fish models using three of the same fish. You send off the fish and he’ll send you a model in the mail the next day.

6. Does C.J. buy sea creatures?

No, C.J. does not buy sea creatures obtained through diving. He only buys fish caught using a fishing rod.

7. What are the rarest fish in Animal Crossing?

Some of the rarest fish include the Coelacanth, Great White Shark, Golden Trout and the Stringfish. These are often the most valuable and sought after.

8. What is the fastest way to get rich in Animal Crossing?

The fastest ways to get rich include selling high-value fish and bugs to C.J. and Flick, playing the stalk market, selling hot items at Nook’s Cranny, and using Nook Miles to purchase Bell Vouchers.

9. Should I donate fish to Blathers?

Yes, always donate the first of any fish to the Museum. This will help you complete your collection and unlock museum upgrades. After the first one, it’s up to you if you donate additional catches, or sell them for Bells!

10. What is the most expensive item in Animal Crossing?

The most expensive buyable item is the Crown, which costs 1,000,000 Bells. The most valuable crafted items are the Trophy Case and Street Piano.

11. What are the most expensive bugs in Animal Crossing?

The most expensive bugs are the Golden Stag, Giraffe Stag, and Horned Hercules, all selling for 12,000 Bells at Nook’s Cranny. Flick will pay more for these.

12. Does Flick pay more for bugs than Nook?

Yes, Flick, the bug enthusiast, pays 1.5x more than Nook’s Cranny for bugs. Similar to C.J. for fish, Flick is the go-to for maximizing bug profits.

13. Are C.J. and Flick dating?

No, despite the rumor, C.J. and Flick are not dating.

14. What is the best thing to sell in Animal Crossing?

The best things to sell are high-value fish and bugs to C.J. and Flick, as well as rare crafted items.

15. Is it better to sell fish or bugs in Animal Crossing?

It depends on the availability of each visitor to your island. Both C.J. and Flick pay 150% of the base price, so the value depends on the rarity of the creatures you catch. Prioritize selling to these visitors if they are on your island.

Conclusion

Understanding who pays more for fish in Animal Crossing: New Horizons is vital for players looking to maximize their earnings. C.J.’s generous 150% offer on fish purchases makes him the top choice for selling your catches. By remembering these tips and strategies, you’ll be on your way to becoming a Bell-ionaire in no time! Happy fishing!