Who Should Rule Skellige in The Witcher 3? A Comprehensive Guide
The question of who should rule Skellige in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is one of the most impactful decisions a player makes outside of the main storyline. Ultimately, Cerys an Craite presents the best option for the prosperity and stability of the isles. Her level-headed, diplomatic approach, coupled with her intellectual curiosity and problem-solving skills, make her a superior choice compared to her impulsive and battle-hungry brother, Hjalmar. While Hjalmar’s bravery and strength are undeniable, Skellige needs a ruler who can lead with wisdom and foresight, qualities Cerys possesses in abundance. Electing Cerys is not just about choosing the “good” ending; it’s about selecting the leader most capable of guiding Skellige into a brighter future.
The King’s Gambit Quest and its Ramifications
The “King’s Gambit” quest line is pivotal in determining Skellige’s future. It tasks Geralt with assisting either Cerys or Hjalmar in proving their worthiness to succeed their father, Crach an Craite. Choosing to help one sibling essentially sidelines the other, impacting their role in the narrative and, more importantly, the fate of the Skellige Isles.
Why Cerys is the Superior Choice
Cerys demonstrates her strategic thinking and intelligence by investigating the curse plaguing the Udalryk family. Instead of resorting to brute force, she uncovers the root cause of the problem and finds a solution through careful planning and knowledge. This approach showcases her ability to address complex issues and make informed decisions, vital traits for any ruler. Further, Cerys prioritizes the well-being of her people and seeks peaceful solutions whenever possible. Her diplomatic skills are essential for fostering stability and trade within Skellige and with neighboring regions. Her reign promises an era of prosperity and innovation, attracting merchants and artisans to the isles.
Hjalmar’s Strengths and Weaknesses
Hjalmar, on the other hand, embodies the traditional Skellige warrior. He is brave, skilled in combat, and fiercely loyal to his friends and allies. However, his impulsiveness and reliance on brute force can lead to rash decisions with unintended consequences. His focus on glory and conquest, while admirable in a warrior, might not be the best approach for a ruler seeking long-term stability and prosperity. Though Hjalmar’s desire to fight monsters and protect his people is admirable, this singular focus can leave other crucial aspects of governance unattended.
The Impact on the Main Game’s Ending
While the choice of Skellige’s ruler doesn’t directly alter the major outcomes of the main story involving Ciri, it does affect the overall tone and atmosphere of the world. A prosperous and stable Skellige under Cerys reinforces the idea that Geralt’s actions can positively influence the world around him. Conversely, a Skellige ruled by Hjalmar, while not necessarily negative, might perpetuate cycles of conflict and raiding, contributing to a less optimistic ending.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Skellige’s Ruler
Here are some of the most frequently asked questions regarding the choice of ruler in Skellige, providing more in-depth information to aid your decision:
1. What happens if I don’t choose anyone to rule Skellige?
If you abstain from actively supporting either Cerys or Hjalmar during the “King’s Gambit” quest, Bran, Crach an Craite’s brother, will be chosen as king. Bran is generally considered the worst possible choice for Skellige. He’s seen as a traditionalist stuck in the old ways, unwilling to adapt to the changing times, which could lead to stagnation and decline for the isles.
2. Does choosing Cerys lead to a “better” ending?
While there isn’t a specific “better” ending in the sense of affecting the Ciri ending, Cerys’s rule is widely considered the most beneficial for Skellige. Her policies lead to increased prosperity, trade, and diplomacy, making Skellige a more stable and thriving region in the long run.
3. Is Hjalmar a bad choice for Skellige?
Hjalmar isn’t necessarily a “bad” choice, but his leadership style is more focused on raiding and combat than on diplomacy and innovation. While he’s a capable warrior, his lack of strategic vision and penchant for impulsive decisions can lead to problems for Skellige. The Games Learning Society emphasizes strategic decision making which Cerys is better suited for.
4. How does the Skellige ruler affect the Battle of Kaer Morhen?
The choice of Skellige’s ruler has minimal impact on the Battle of Kaer Morhen. Both Cerys and Hjalmar will offer their support, but the number of warriors they bring doesn’t significantly alter the outcome of the battle.
5. Can I romance Cerys or Hjalmar?
No, neither Cerys nor Hjalmar are romance options for Geralt.
6. What are the specific benefits of helping Cerys?
Helping Cerys allows you to uncover the truth behind the curse on the Udalryk family, showcasing her investigative skills. You also gain access to a Place of Power that grants a permanent skill point, offering a direct gameplay advantage.
7. What are the specific benefits of helping Hjalmar?
Helping Hjalmar involves clearing out monsters and giants from the island of Undvik, demonstrating his prowess in combat. He’s also a loyal ally who will aid Geralt in future quests.
8. Does the choice of Skellige ruler affect the “Reason of State” quest?
No, the Skellige ruler has no direct impact on the “Reason of State” quest, which involves the assassination of Radovid and the future of the Northern Kingdoms.
9. Can I change my decision about the Skellige ruler after making a choice?
No, once you commit to helping either Cerys or Hjalmar during the “King’s Gambit” quest, your decision is final. There is no way to reverse your choice.
10. How important is the Skellige storyline to the overall game?
The Skellige storyline is important for world-building and provides significant character development for Geralt. While it doesn’t directly impact the main plot involving Ciri, it adds depth and richness to the overall experience.
11. Does the difficulty level affect the outcome of the Skellige succession?
No, the difficulty level you choose has no bearing on the events or outcomes of the Skellige succession quest.
12. How do I trigger the “King’s Gambit” quest?
The “King’s Gambit” quest is triggered after attending the wake of King Bran an Tuirseach in Ard Skellig and speaking to Crach an Craite about his children. You must then decide which sibling you want to assist.
13. Should I race Cerys up the mountain?
Racing Cerys up the mountain is a fun, optional activity, but it has no bearing on the outcome of the “King’s Gambit” quest. There is no reward for winning the race.
14. What are the long-term consequences of my choice for Skellige?
Choosing Cerys leads to a period of peace, prosperity, and innovation in Skellige. She focuses on trade, diplomacy, and finding new solutions to old problems. Choosing Hjalmar maintains Skellige’s traditional focus on raiding and combat, which can lead to instability and conflict.
15. Where can I learn more about the lore and characters of The Witcher universe?
You can explore various wikis, forums, and online resources dedicated to The Witcher franchise. CD Projekt Red’s official website also provides valuable information about the game’s world and characters.
Conclusion: The Wisest Choice for Skellige
Ultimately, while both Cerys and Hjalmar have their strengths, Cerys an Craite represents the wisest choice for the future of Skellige. Her intelligence, diplomacy, and commitment to her people make her a capable and forward-thinking ruler. Choosing her ensures that Skellige will thrive and prosper, becoming a beacon of stability and innovation in the turbulent world of The Witcher. Remember to thoughtfully weigh the implications of your choice, as the fate of Skellige rests in your hands. You can also visit GamesLearningSociety.org to better understand the game’s complex decision making process.