Why Didn’t Dutch Let Arthur Kill Micah?

Dutch didn’t let Arthur kill Micah because he was consumed by greed and loyal to Micah, who had saved his life in the past, and also because John Marston’s storyline would have been affected if Arthur had killed Micah, as John owed Arthur a lot for helping him escape the gang and start a new life. This decision had significant implications for the plot and characters of Red Dead Redemption 2, highlighting the complexities of Dutch’s character and his relationships with other gang members.

Understanding Dutch’s Motivations

Loyalty and Greed

Dutch’s motivations are rooted in his narcissistic personality disorder, which leads him to prioritize his own interests and desires above all else, including his relationships with other gang members. His loyalty to Micah is also a significant factor, as Micah had saved his life in the past, creating a sense of debt and obligation.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Did Dutch know Micah was a rat?: Yes, Dutch realized that Micah was a traitor as Arthur lay dying and pleaded with him to see the truth.
2. Why didn’t Arthur cough on Micah?: Arthur was self-aware of his illness but tried to avoid coughing on others, including Micah, out of consideration for their health.
3. Could Arthur have beaten Micah if he wasn’t sick?: Yes, Arthur was the physically strongest man in the Van der Linde gang, and if he hadn’t been sick, he likely would have been able to overpower Micah.
4. Could Arthur have survived tuberculosis?: No, the chances of Arthur overcoming his severe case of TB were slim to none, both in the game and in the nonfictional 1890s.
5. Why did Dutch like Micah so much?: Dutch felt a sense of loyalty and obligation to Micah, who had saved his life, and also saw Micah as a loyal and useful member of the gang.
6. What mental illness does Dutch have in RDR2?: Dutch is suffering from a personality disorder, specifically narcissism, characterized by dramatic and exaggerated traits, emotional intensity, and unpredictable behavior.
7. What did Dutch and Micah do to the girl?: The details of the girl’s death are ambiguous, but it is mentioned that Micah encouraged Dutch to kill her, and Dutch later justified it as necessary for their survival.
8. Why did Dutch go bad?: Dutch’s descent into madness and paranoia was triggered by the decline of the Wild West and the loss of his gang members, leading him to become increasingly erratic and violent.
9. Where does Dutch go after killing Micah?: Dutch walks away unharmed after helping John and Sadie put an end to Micah, and his fate is left uncertain until the events of the original Red Dead Redemption.
10. Why did Dutch stop trusting Arthur?: Dutch saw Arthur as a threat to his authority and leadership, and his trust in Arthur was eroded by Arthur’s growing doubts and disillusionment with the gang’s activities.
11. Did Micah kill Jack’s dog?: It is heavily implied that Micah killed Jack’s dog, Cain, as he tells Jack that the dog must have run away, but his tone suggests otherwise.
12. Who killed Dutch Van der Linde?: Dutch meets his end in 1911, when he is tracked down by John Marston and commits suicide by backing off a cliff.
13. What mental illness does Micah Bell have?: Micah exhibits traits consistent with psychopathy, including a lack of empathy, impulsivity, and a tendency to manipulate and exploit others.
14. Who had the saddest death in RDR2?: Arthur Morgan’s death is widely regarded as one of the saddest moments in the game, as he sacrifices himself to save John and his family.
15. Why is Hosea better than Dutch?: Hosea is seen as a better leader than Dutch because he expresses a desire for the younger gang members to find good lives for themselves and leave the gang’s violent activities behind, demonstrating a more compassionate and responsible approach to leadership.