Why Didn’t Marlene Take Ellie to the Fireflies?
Marlene didn’t take Ellie to the Fireflies because she had been entrusted by Ellie’s mother, Anna, to keep Ellie safe, and allowing Ellie to join the Fireflies would have been contrary to Anna’s last wish. This decision was further complicated by Marlene’s priorities as the leader of the Fireflies, which often led her to make difficult choices for the sake of the organization, even if it meant sacrificing her personal relationships and emotions.
Understanding Marlene’s Decision
Marlene’s relationship with Ellie was complex, marked by a deep affection for the young girl, yet also a sense of responsibility to the Fireflies and to fulfilling Anna’s wish. This dichotomy is central to understanding why Marlene chose not to take Ellie to the Fireflies immediately.
Marlene’s Role in Ellie’s Life
Marlene had been watching over Ellie from afar for most of her life, ensuring her safety and making crucial decisions about her upbringing, including arranging for her to be placed in a military school. This level of involvement underscores Marlene’s commitment to Anna’s request and her own sense of duty towards Ellie.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Why did Marlene put Ellie in FEDRA? Marlene placed Ellie in FEDRA’s Boston base for her safety, where she would be fed, educated, and face minimal risk of danger, allowing Marlene to keep tabs on her from a distance.
- What secret did Marlene tell Ellie? Marlene revealed that she was responsible for Ellie’s placement in the FEDRA military school immediately after her birth, a truth that shocked Ellie and led her to question Marlene’s motives.
- Did Marlene know Ellie was immune? There are hints that Marlene might have had knowledge of Ellie’s immunity to the Cordyceps infection, which could have influenced her decisions regarding Ellie’s protection and future.
- Why was Ellie’s mom running through the woods? Ellie’s mom, Anna, was pregnant with Ellie and fleeing from an Infected, seeking refuge in a remote farmhouse where she could give birth safely.
- Did Ellie’s mom lie to Marlene? Anna lied to Marlene about the timing of her bite in relation to Ellie’s birth, stating the umbilical cord was cut before she was bitten, which was not true.
- Did Marlene tell Ellie about her mom? Marlene shared information about Ellie’s mom, Anna, with Ellie, including giving her a switchblade that once belonged to Anna, creating a connection between Ellie and her past.
- Did Ellie know Joel lied? Ellie had a sense that Joel might be lying to her, but she chose to believe him to protect herself from further harm and emotional pain.
- What did Maria leave Ellie on the bed? Maria gave Ellie a haircut, clean clothes, and a menstrual cup, along with an accompanying pamphlet, items that represented a normal life amidst the chaos.
- What is Veronica’s secret in The Last of Us? Ellie, going under the name Veronica, was subjected to tests that aimed to understand her intelligence and potentially her immunity to the Cordyceps brain infection.
- Would they have found a cure if Ellie died? The death of Ellie would not have led to a cure for the Cordyceps infection, as her immunity was a unique biological response that couldn’t be replicated as a vaccine or cure.
- Was Ellie immune because of her mom? Ellie’s immunity is believed to stem from her exposure to the Cordyceps fungus in utero, as her mother Anna was bitten during childbirth.
- Were the Fireflies good or bad? The Fireflies are portrayed as a complex organization with both noble intentions and questionable methods, making their nature morally ambiguous.
- Why does Marlene want Joel to take Ellie? Initially, Marlene asked Joel to take Ellie on a journey to the capital building as part of a larger plan, though this plan was altered by events.
- Why did Marlene shoot Anna? Marlene shot Anna to spare her the suffering of turning into an Infected, a ** mercy killing** that reflected the harsh realities of their world.
- Who are Ellie’s real parents? Ellie’s mother was Anna, a nurse, while her father’s identity remains unknown, leaving Ellie with a mysterious and tragic family history.