Why does Arthur not like John?

Arthur does not like John because John abandoned his family, including his pregnant girlfriend Abigail Roberts and their son Jack, which led to Arthur feeling betrayed and disappointed in John’s actions, causing a significant strain on their relationship. This event had a profound impact on Arthur, making him lose respect for John and question his commitment to the Van der Linde gang and its members.

Understanding the Complexity of Arthur and John’s Relationship

The relationship between Arthur and John is multifaceted and influenced by various factors, including their shared experiences as outlaws and members of the Van der Linde gang.

Exploring the Reasons Behind Arthur’s Dislike for John

To grasp the depth of Arthur’s feelings towards John, it’s essential to examine the events that led to their falling out and the subsequent betrayal that Arthur felt.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What happened between Arthur and John in 1899? Arthur and John’s relationship was strained in 1899 due to John’s decision to abandon his family, which led to Arthur feeling betrayed and disappointed.
2. Why did Arthur lose respect for John? Arthur lost respect for John because John failed to take responsibility for his actions and abandoned his family, demonstrating a lack of commitment to those he cared about.
3. How did John’s actions affect the Van der Linde gang? John’s actions damaged the gang’s morale and created tension among its members, ultimately contributing to the gang’s downfall.
4. Did Arthur and John ever reconcile? Although Arthur and John reconnected later on, their relationship was never the same, and the trust that once existed between them was irreparably damaged.
5. What role did Abigail play in Arthur and John’s relationship? Abigail’s presence in John’s life highlighted his responsibilities as a partner and father, making his decision to abandon her and their son even more egregious in Arthur’s eyes.
6. How did Dutch Van der Linde influence Arthur and John’s relationship? Dutch’s paranoia and unpredictability created an environment where loyalty and trust were constantly tested, ultimately contributing to the end of Arthur and John’s friendship.
7. What was the final straw in Arthur and John’s relationship? The final confrontation between Arthur and John, in which Arthur discovered Micah’s betrayal, marked the end of their relationship, as Arthur realized John’s limitations and priorities.
8. Did Arthur’s illness affect his relationship with John? Arthur’s tuberculosis made him more reflective and empathetic, but it also limited his ability to reconcile with John or change the course of their relationship.
9. How did Micah’s betrayal impact Arthur and John’s relationship? Micah’s betrayal of the gang exposed the deep-seated issues within the group, including the distrust and resentment between Arthur and John.
10. What did Arthur hope to achieve by reconnecting with John? Arthur hoped to redeem John and reestablish their bond, but ultimately, their differences and past conflicts proved insurmountable.
11. Did John ever express remorse for his actions? John regretted his decision to abandon his family, but his apology came too late to repair the damage done to his relationship with Arthur.
12. How did Abigail’s relationship with John affect Arthur? Abigail’s love and devotion to John highlighted Arthur’s own feelings of betrayal and disappointment, making it harder for him to forgive John.
13. What lessons can be learned from Arthur and John’s relationship? The story of Arthur and John serves as a cautionary tale about the importance of loyalty, trust, and responsibility in relationships.
14. How did the Van der Linde gang’s activities contribute to Arthur and John’s relationship? The gang’s outlaw lifestyle and constant conflicts created an environment where relationships were tested and loyalties were pushed to the limit.
15. What is the legacy of Arthur and John’s relationship? The complex and tragic story of Arthur and John serves as a reminder of the consequences of betrayal and the importance of redemption, leaving a lasting impact on the Red Dead universe.