Why is it So Hard to Gain Weight in Red Dead Redemption 2?
The struggle is real. You’re stuffing Arthur Morgan (or your online character) with enough Big Game Meat to feed a small army, yet the weight bar barely budges. Why is it so hard to gain weight in Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2)? The answer lies in a combination of game mechanics, hidden timers, and a dose of realism layered within the game’s intricate systems.
At its core, the weight system in RDR2 is designed to be a slow, gradual process mirroring real-life weight gain (and loss). It’s not an instantaneous “stuff your face and become obese” situation. Instead, the game employs internal cooldowns and caps on how much weight you can gain within a certain in-game timeframe. Simply put, even if you’re constantly eating, the game prevents you from ballooning up overnight. This is further complicated by factors like your activity level and the quality of food consumed. You can’t just gorge yourself and immediately see results; you need to combine it with rest.
Moreover, there’s an invisible “calorie” system at play. Each food item has a different “calorie” value that isn’t explicitly stated, and the game tracks your character’s “calorie surplus” (calories consumed minus calories burned). Gaining weight effectively requires a sustained calorie surplus over multiple in-game days.
Lastly, it’s also crucial to understand that certain story events and character conditions can impede weight gain. For example, Arthur’s tuberculosis will dramatically hinder his ability to gain weight, regardless of his diet. Similarly, high levels of activity will burn more calories, making it harder to achieve the necessary surplus for weight gain. This is a brilliant example of how the game’s mechanics are interwoven with the narrative, adding a layer of realism and challenge.
Deciphering the RDR2 Weight System
The Red Dead Redemption 2 weight system is more than just a cosmetic feature; it directly affects your character’s stats. Understanding how it works is the key to success (or, in this case, achieving a pleasantly plump Arthur).
The Impact of Weight on Stats
Weight in RDR2 influences two primary stats: Health and Stamina.
- Overweight: An overweight character has increased Health but decreased Stamina. They can take more damage in combat but tire out more quickly during activities like running or swimming.
- Average: Represents a balance between Health and Stamina.
- Underweight: An underweight character has decreased Health but increased Stamina. They’re more agile and can run longer but are more vulnerable to damage.
Internal Timers and Limits
As mentioned earlier, RDR2 employs internal timers that limit how much weight you can gain within a specific timeframe. These timers are often tied to in-game hours or even real-time minutes. The exact mechanics are not fully documented by Rockstar, but player experience suggests the following:
- Weight Gain Cap per In-Game Hour: There’s a limit to how much weight you can gain within an in-game hour. Even if you consume a vast amount of food, you won’t see a significant weight change immediately.
- Screen Fade Progression: Some players believe that weight gain progresses when the screen fades (loading screens, sleeping, fast traveling).
The Importance of Rest
Sleeping is crucial for weight gain in RDR2. The game simulates the process of your body absorbing nutrients and converting them into fat while you rest. Regularly sleeping after consuming large meals significantly increases your chances of gaining weight.
The “Calorie” System and Food Quality
While RDR2 doesn’t display a calorie count for each food item, it’s evident that different foods have varying impacts on weight gain. Generally, cooked meats, especially Big Game Meat, are the most effective for bulking up. Processed foods like candy and canned goods have a lower impact.
Activity Levels and Calorie Burning
Arthur isn’t just a eating machine; he is also living in the Wild West. The more time he spends riding, fighting, hunting, the more calories he burns, which makes it even more difficult to gain weight.
Overcoming the Weight Gain Hurdle
While the RDR2 weight system can be frustrating, it is definitely possible to see results. Here’s a strategy to maximize your weight gain potential:
- Consistent Overeating: Eat frequently throughout the in-game day, even when your cores are full. Aim for at least three large meals daily.
- Prioritize Big Game Meat: Focus on consuming cooked Big Game Meat. It’s the most calorie-dense and effective food for weight gain.
- Regular Sleep Schedule: Sleep at least once per in-game day, preferably after a large meal.
- Minimize Activity: Reduce strenuous activities like running and fighting. Focus on tasks that require minimal exertion.
- Utilize Camp Stew: Always eat a bowl of stew at camp whenever possible. This provides a consistent source of calories.
- Patience is Key: Weight gain is a gradual process. Don’t expect immediate results. Be consistent with your diet and rest, and you will eventually see progress.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What is the fastest way to gain weight in RDR2?
The fastest way to gain weight is to repeatedly eat cooked Big Game Meat, followed by sleeping. Minimize activity to reduce calorie burning.
2. Can Arthur gain weight when he has TB?
No. Unfortunately, Arthur’s tuberculosis prevents him from gaining weight. It’s part of the story and adds to the realism of the game.
3. What is the most fattening food in RDR2?
Cooked Big Game Meat (from bears, alligators, wolves, panthers, etc.) is the most fattening food.
4. How often should I eat in RDR2 to gain weight?
Eat at least three substantial meals per in-game day. Eating frequently, even when cores are full, is crucial.
5. Does sleeping help you gain weight in RDR2?
Yes, sleeping is essential for weight gain. It allows your character to “process” the food they’ve consumed and convert it into weight.
6. Can you gain too much weight in RDR2?
Yes, you can become overweight. However, there are no negative consequences beyond reduced stamina.
7. What happens if Arthur is underweight in RDR2?
An underweight Arthur has reduced health but increased stamina. He’s more agile but more vulnerable to damage.
8. How do you fix being underweight in RDR2 Online?
The process is the same as in the single-player game: eat frequently and sleep regularly. Quit and reload if you are not seeing changes.
9. Does Arthur’s weight affect his appearance?
Yes, Arthur’s weight is visually represented in the game. He will appear more muscular when at average weight and noticeably larger when overweight.
10. Can you lose weight in RDR2 if you stop eating?
Yes, if you stop eating, you will gradually lose weight and become underweight.
11. Is it better to be overweight, underweight, or average weight in RDR2?
The best weight depends on your play style. Overweight characters have more health, while underweight characters have more stamina. Average weight provides a balance.
12. Can I see how many calories each item has in RDR2?
No, the game does not display calorie counts for individual food items.
13. Does drinking alcohol affect weight gain in RDR2?
Alcohol doesn’t directly contribute to weight gain, but excessive drinking can negatively affect your character’s health and stamina.
14. How does honor affect weight gain in RDR2?
Honor has no direct impact on weight gain. It primarily affects the story and character interactions.
15. Does the Games Learning Society study game mechanics like the weight system in RDR2?
While the Games Learning Society focuses on the educational aspects of games and learning through game design (GamesLearningSociety.org), understanding game mechanics like the weight system in RDR2 can inform discussions about realism, player agency, and the simulation of real-world processes within virtual environments.
In conclusion, while it can be challenging to gain weight in RDR2, understanding the game’s mechanics and employing the right strategies can help you achieve your desired physique for Arthur or your online character.