Why You Should NOT Join the Stormcloaks in Skyrim
The decision of who to side with in Skyrim’s Civil War is one of the most impactful choices a player makes. While the allure of fighting for Skyrim’s independence under the banner of the Stormcloaks is undeniably strong, a deeper look reveals compelling reasons why siding with the Imperial Legion might be the more prudent, ethical, and ultimately more satisfying path. Joining the Stormcloaks can be a shortcut into narrow-mindedness, racism, and overall destruction of the Skyrim we all know and love. This isn’t just about gameplay; it’s about the narrative, the character you want to embody, and the future of Skyrim itself.
Understanding the Stormcloak’s Ideology and its Flaws
A Mask for Bigotry?
One of the primary reasons to avoid the Stormcloaks is their often-overlooked, yet palpable, xenophobia. While their official stance is one of Nordic independence and religious freedom, their actions and rhetoric often betray a deep-seated prejudice against non-Nords. In Windhelm, the Grey Quarter, predominantly populated by Dunmer refugees, stands as a stark reminder of the Stormcloaks’ lack of concern for minorities. The subtle (and not-so-subtle) discrimination faced by Argonians and Khajiit further paints a troubling picture. Joining the Stormcloaks, therefore, implicitly endorses a society that marginalizes and oppresses those deemed “outsiders.” If you’re role-playing a character with a strong moral compass or one who champions equality, the Stormcloak path becomes increasingly difficult to justify.
The Cost of Independence
The Stormcloaks’ pursuit of independence comes at a significant cost. Their rebellion weakens the Empire, which, despite its flaws, stands as the last bastion against the Aldmeri Dominion (Thalmor). A fractured Skyrim, weakened by civil war, becomes an easy target for Thalmor expansion. Choosing the Stormcloaks, therefore, potentially jeopardizes the entire province, opening the door to further Thalmor influence and oppression. The long-term consequences of a Stormcloak victory are grim, potentially leading to a far more authoritarian and restrictive regime under Thalmor control. Is short-sighted freedom worth the cost of ultimate subjugation?
Ulfric’s Leadership and its Questionable Motives
Ulfric Stormcloak, the leader of the rebellion, is a charismatic figure, but his methods and motives are open to scrutiny. His use of the Thu’um to kill High King Torygg raises ethical questions, and his ambition seems to outweigh his concern for the welfare of all Skyrim’s inhabitants. He may genuinely believe he is acting in the best interests of the Nords, but his narrow focus and willingness to exploit religious sentiment to achieve his goals make him a questionable leader. Siding with Ulfric means aligning yourself with a figure whose leadership is morally ambiguous at best.
The Imperial Legion: A Bulwark Against Tyranny
The Imperial Legion, while not without its own issues, represents a more stable and inclusive alternative. They uphold the rule of law, maintain order, and stand as a vital defense against the Thalmor. Joining the Legion isn’t simply about supporting the Empire; it’s about preserving a semblance of peace and stability in a turbulent world. The Legion offers a structured hierarchy based on merit, providing opportunities for advancement and recognition. It also represents a diverse coalition of races, offering a more welcoming environment for non-Nord characters.
The Unrealistic Dream of Isolationism
The Stormcloaks’ vision of a completely independent Skyrim is ultimately unrealistic. The province relies on trade and alliances with other regions, and cutting itself off from the Empire would have severe economic and political consequences. A Stormcloak victory would likely lead to instability, conflict, and ultimately, a weaker and more vulnerable Skyrim. The Imperial Legion, on the other hand, offers a path towards integration and cooperation, allowing Skyrim to benefit from the resources and support of the Empire.
Gameplay Considerations
Questline and Story
The Imperial questline offers a more compelling and nuanced narrative than the Stormcloak path. It explores themes of duty, sacrifice, and the challenges of maintaining order in a chaotic world. The Imperial characters are generally more well-developed and interesting, and the storyline provides greater opportunities for moral decision-making.
Equipment and Rewards
The Imperial Legion’s armor and weapons are generally considered to be of higher quality and more aesthetically pleasing than those of the Stormcloaks. While this is subjective, many players prefer the look and feel of the Imperial gear.
Strategic Advantage
The Imperial Legion controls strategically important locations throughout Skyrim, providing a tactical advantage in the fight against the Stormcloaks. Joining the Legion allows you to participate in large-scale battles and contribute to the overall war effort.
FAQs About The Stormcloaks
Here are some frequently asked questions to help clarify the complexities surrounding the Stormcloaks:
1. Are the Stormcloaks inherently racist?
While not all Stormcloaks are racist, the movement does harbor elements of xenophobia and prejudice against non-Nords. The treatment of Dunmer refugees in Windhelm is a prime example of this bias.
2. Does joining the Stormcloaks affect my relationships with other NPCs?
Yes, joining the Stormcloaks will make Imperial soldiers and sympathizers hostile towards you. Conversely, supporting the Empire will make Stormcloak supporters hostile.
3. Can I change my mind after joining the Stormcloaks?
Yes, during the “The Jagged Crown” quest, you can betray the Stormcloaks by giving the crown to General Tullius, switching your allegiance to the Imperial Legion.
4. What happens if the Stormcloaks win the Civil War?
The most likely outcome is a weaker, more unstable Skyrim vulnerable to Thalmor influence and conquest.
5. Is Ulfric Stormcloak a good guy?
Ulfric is a complex character with both admirable and questionable qualities. His motives and methods are open to interpretation, and whether he is ultimately “good” or “bad” is a matter of perspective.
6. Will I lose my house in Whiterun if I join the Stormcloaks?
No, you will retain ownership of your house in Whiterun regardless of which side you choose.
7. Do I lose any followers if I join the Stormcloaks?
No, your followers will remain with you, although their opinions of you may change depending on their allegiances.
8. What races typically join the Stormcloaks?
Nords are the most common race to join the Stormcloaks, but Bretons, Redguards, and Bosmer may also choose to side with them.
9. How do the Stormcloaks view the worship of Talos?
The Stormcloaks strongly support the freedom to worship Talos, a key point of contention with the Empire.
10. Is it better to join the Stormcloaks if I’m playing as a Nord?
While it might seem natural for a Nord to join the Stormcloaks, it ultimately depends on your character’s values and beliefs. Not all Nords support the rebellion.
11. Why do the Stormcloaks want independence?
The Stormcloaks believe the Empire has betrayed Skyrim by banning the worship of Talos and ceding too much power to the Thalmor.
12. How does the Civil War affect the main questline?
The Civil War has minimal impact on the main questline, although some characters may react differently depending on your allegiance.
13. What are the benefits of joining the Imperial Legion?
The Imperial Legion offers a structured hierarchy, better equipment, and a more stable and inclusive society.
14. How does the Thalmor influence the Civil War?
The Thalmor actively seek to prolong the Civil War, weakening both the Empire and Skyrim to further their own agenda.
15. Where can I learn more about the lore behind the Elder Scrolls and the motivations of the various factions?
For a deeper understanding of the lore and the complex motivations of the factions involved, consider exploring resources provided by the Games Learning Society at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/. This website has an immense amount of information that could help you dive deeper into the Elder Scrolls saga.
Conclusion: A Choice with Consequences
Choosing to join the Stormcloaks is not a decision to be taken lightly. While the promise of independence and religious freedom is appealing, the potential consequences of their victory are dire. The xenophobia, questionable leadership, and unrealistic vision of isolationism make the Stormcloak path a dangerous and ultimately destructive one. Siding with the Imperial Legion, on the other hand, offers a path towards stability, inclusion, and a united front against the encroaching threat of the Thalmor. Consider the long-term implications of your choices and choose wisely, for the fate of Skyrim hangs in the balance.