Will Redd Sell Art You Already Have in Animal Crossing: New Horizons?
The short answer is yes, Redd can absolutely sell you art you already have in Animal Crossing: New Horizons. This applies to both genuine and fake artworks. If you’ve been diligently expanding your museum’s art gallery, or perhaps have a penchant for decorating your island with duplicates, you’ll quickly find that Redd’s inventory is not designed to provide only new, unique pieces. Understanding how this works and what it means for your collection is crucial for any avid art enthusiast in the game.
Understanding Redd’s Inventory
Redd, the sly fox, arrives on your island with his “Treasure Trawler” docked at the secret beach on the north shore. He displays four pieces of art on any given visit. These can be a mix of paintings and sculptures, and the crucial part is that these pieces can be either authentic or forgeries. The game doesn’t track what you’ve already purchased or donated, meaning the same art, real or fake, can appear repeatedly. This element of chance is part of the challenge when dealing with Redd.
The Possibility of Duplicates
The most important aspect to grasp is that Redd’s stock isn’t curated to only present unique items you don’t have. He can, and often will, offer art pieces you already own. This applies across the board:
- Real Duplicates: He can sell you a real painting or statue that you’ve already donated to the museum or placed on your island.
- Fake Duplicates: Similarly, he can offer fake versions of art you already own, further increasing the chances of your inventory cluttering up with unusable forgeries.
- Mixed Duplicates: You may even see a scenario where you have a genuine statue on your island and he presents a fake version of the exact same statue.
Why Duplicates Matter
The fact that Redd can and does sell duplicates has several implications for players:
- Museum Completion: It prolongs the process of completing your museum art collection, as you can’t guarantee every Redd visit will bring a new, much-needed piece.
- Inventory Management: Accumulating duplicate forgeries can quickly fill up your storage space and become an annoyance. You cannot sell them to Timmy and Tommy, nor can you donate them to Blathers.
- Island Decor: If you’re aiming to decorate with multiple copies of the same artwork, this system can work in your favor as you can purchase identical pieces repeatedly.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Redd and His Art
To further clarify how Redd operates and answer common questions, here’s a comprehensive FAQ section:
1. Can I buy two of the same painting from Redd on the same visit?
No, you can only buy one piece of art per day from Redd. Even if he has multiple pieces that you want, you’re limited to a single purchase.
2. Does Redd ever sell all fakes?
Yes, it’s absolutely possible for Redd to offer four forgeries during a single visit. You have to be vigilant in checking the art before purchase.
3. How can I tell if the artwork from Redd is real or fake?
You need to compare the details of the artwork from Redd to its real-world counterpart. Fakes will often have small, yet noticeable differences, such as missing details, added elements, color variations, or size discrepancies.
4. Is the first painting Redd sells me always real?
Yes, the very first piece of art Redd sells you in the game is guaranteed to be authentic. This is intended to help you unlock the museum’s art gallery extension.
5. Can Blathers identify fake art?
Yes, Blathers will immediately recognize fake art and refuse to accept it into the museum’s collection. He will hand back the forgery.
6. What can I do with fake art from Redd?
Once purchased, fake art can’t be sold to Timmy and Tommy, donated to the museum, or gifted to villagers. Most players end up discarding them or using them for unusual decoration purposes.
7. Can I purchase art from Redd on a friend’s island?
Yes, you can visit Redd on a friend’s island, but you can still only buy one piece of art per day, total. If you buy from Redd on your island, you can’t buy from a friend’s island the same day.
8. Is there a pattern to when Redd visits my island?
No, Redd’s visits are not on a fixed schedule. He appears randomly, making it challenging to plan around his arrival.
9. Can Redd sell multiple real artworks at once?
Yes, it’s possible for Redd to sell more than one genuine artwork on a single visit, although it is rare. If this happens, it’s a great opportunity to add valuable pieces to your collection.
10. How can I tell if a “Scary Painting” is real?
The easiest method is to look at the eyebrows. On a real Scary Painting, the subject’s eyebrows slant down towards the middle; on a fake, they slant up.
11. How can I tell if a “Mystic Statue” is real?
The fake mystic statue has an earring on its right ear, while the real statue does not.
12. How can I tell if a “Beautiful Statue” is real?
The fake Beautiful Statue has three necklaces around its neck, whereas the real one has none.
13. How can I tell if a “Solemn Painting” is real?
The real Solemn Painting shows the man in the background with his arm behind a curtain. In the fake, his arm is raised.
14. How can I tell if an “Amazing Painting” is real?
The man in the center of the real Amazing Painting is wearing a black hat. In the fake, the black hat is missing.
15. Can I gift fake art to villagers?
Yes, you can gift fake art to villagers, but they may express disappointment because it is a forgery. It’s generally better to avoid gifting them fake pieces.
Conclusion
Redd’s unpredictable nature and propensity to sell duplicate art, both genuine and fake, adds a layer of complexity to building your museum’s art collection in Animal Crossing: New Horizons. Being aware of these possibilities helps you manage your expectations and strategize accordingly. Always inspect the art pieces meticulously before making a purchase and be prepared to see the same pieces multiple times. While it can be frustrating, it makes each acquisition of a genuine, new piece even more rewarding. Happy hunting!