Are 5-Star Artifacts Always Better Than 4-Star Artifacts in Genshin Impact?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The simple answer is: not always, but generally yes, in the long run. While a shiny 5-star artifact might seem like the holy grail, the intricacies of Genshin Impact’s artifact system mean that the situation isn’t always black and white. Let’s delve into the nuances and figure out when a 5-star artifact reigns supreme and when a well-rolled 4-star might actually be a better choice, at least temporarily.
The Initial Allure of 5-Star Artifacts
The immediate appeal of a 5-star artifact lies in its potential. These artifacts boast a higher base stat and larger stat scaling compared to their 4-star counterparts. This means that at maximum level, a 5-star artifact will have significantly higher values for its main stat (like ATK%, Crit Rate, or Energy Recharge) and can potentially reach significantly higher values in its substats as well.
Furthermore, 5-star artifacts can reach level 20, compared to 4-star artifacts which max at level 16, allowing for a higher overall stat boost. This alone makes them more desirable for long-term investment.
The Substat Gamble
However, the artifact system in Genshin Impact has a heavy element of randomness. The substats on your artifact are crucial to its overall effectiveness, and the initial substats that appear on your artifact along with the substat upgrades when leveling up are random. While a 5-star artifact can have up to four substats, it is not guaranteed that these substats are useful or will receive upgrades.
A 5-star artifact with two useless substats upgraded three or four times won’t be nearly as good as a 4-star artifact with all good substats fully upgraded. This randomness means that early in your journey, particularly before Adventure Rank 45, you might find that well-rolled 4-star artifacts serve you better.
The 4-Star Artifact Advantage
4-star artifacts are much more accessible, particularly early in the game. They drop more frequently, which means it’s easier to get artifacts with the right main stat and desirable substats. It’s also cheaper to level up a 4-star artifact initially.
In the early game, focusing on building a cohesive set of 4-star artifacts with good substats is far more efficient than chasing after poorly-rolled 5-star artifacts. You’re likely to find that a 4-star artifact with four appropriate substats is far superior to a 5-star artifact with two unfavorable substats.
For example, an early game character benefits far more from a full set of Martial Artist or Berserker artifacts than any poorly rolled 5-star mix and match. This provides great stats and a great bonus to start off with.
The Transition to 5-Star Artifacts
The situation changes dramatically once you reach Adventure Rank 45. At this point, you can consistently farm level 90 domains, which guarantee you at least one 5-star artifact per run. The increased availability of 5-star artifacts means that the gap in performance becomes more noticeable.
It is also important to note that Domains of Blessing Level III guarantees at least one 5-star artifact, making the farm far more fruitful. When farming level 90 domains, each run can give a full 5-star set, making it far easier to collect good pieces.
When Do 5-Star Artifacts Truly Shine?
While a poorly-rolled 5-star artifact can be underwhelming, a 5-star artifact with 3-4 good substats will outperform a 4-star artifact every time. Once you have sufficient 5-star artifacts to pick and choose, you are looking for the right set with good main stats and ideally, three or four useful substats.
The value of 5-star artifacts also increases at higher levels. Leveling your artifacts to +20 provides a massive jump in stats compared to level 16. This scaling difference makes them essential for reaching your characters’ maximum potential.
Using 4-Star Artifacts as Resources
The good news is that your investments in 4-star artifacts are not entirely wasted. You can use your well-leveled 4-star artifacts as fodder to upgrade your 5-star ones. By doing so, you’ll lose a small percentage of experience, but the investment you made to get them upgraded is carried over with your new 5-star artifact.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some additional FAQs to help you navigate the complexities of Genshin Impact’s artifact system:
1. When can I start farming 5-star artifacts?
You can start seeing 5-star artifacts drop from weekly bosses at around Adventure Rank 30, but the drop rate is very low. A guaranteed 5-star artifact is only achieved at Adventure Rank 45 by running the level 90 domains.
2. Is it worth keeping 4-star artifacts?
Yes, absolutely. 4-star artifacts are crucial for early game progression, and they’re essential for upgrading your future 5-star artifacts. Focus on getting a good combination of 4-star artifacts early and save the good ones as fodder once you have a full 5-star set.
3. How rare are 5-star artifacts?
At lower-level domains, the drop rate for 5-star artifacts is extremely low (around 0.6%). The level 90 domain guarantees at least one per run at 100%.
4. Can you destroy 5-star artifacts?
No, 5-star artifacts cannot be destroyed for Mora. However, they can be used for Mystic Offerings to create Artifact Strongboxes.
5. What is the max level for 5-star artifacts?
5-star artifacts can be leveled up to level 20.
6. Can you upgrade a 4-star artifact to a 5-star?
No, you cannot directly upgrade a 4-star artifact to a 5-star. You can, however, use leveled 4-star artifacts to level your 5-star ones, losing only a small percentage of the experience.
7. Are there guaranteed 5-star artifacts outside of domains?
Yes, at Adventure Rank 55 you are guaranteed a 5-star Gladiator’s Finale or Wanderer’s Troupe artifact from weekly boss battles.
8. Do 5-star artifacts do more damage than 4-star artifacts?
Generally, yes. 5-star artifacts have higher base stats and bigger scaling potential at max level. However, a 5-star artifact with bad substats and upgrades can still be outperformed by a 4-star with good substats.
9. Should I farm artifacts before AR 45?
No, it’s generally not recommended to heavily farm artifacts before AR 45. Focus on completing your weekly challenges, collecting resources, and using 4-star artifacts while progressing your adventure rank.
10. Should I stay at AR 45?
Staying at AR 45 is not recommended as it hinders your progress and is less efficient. Ascending to AR 46 provides better rewards and allows you to get stronger quicker.
11. What is the best 4-star artifact set?
This depends on the character and their playstyle. Some of the best 4-star sets include: Instructor, Berserker, The Exile, Brave Heart, Martial Artist, and Gambler.
12. Do Condensed Resin give better artifacts?
No, but it gives more rewards overall. Using condensed resin for higher-level domains makes the most out of the resource.
13. Can you get 5-star artifacts at World Level 3?
Yes, but the drop rate is very low. You can get some through weekly boss battles, but it is inconsistent.
14. What are the best domains to farm in Genshin Impact?
This depends on your characters and their needs. A few good options are the Emblem domain for the Emblem and Shimenawa sets, the VV/Maiden domain for the Viridescent Venerer and Maiden Beloved sets, and the Valley of Remembrance domain for the Pale Flame and Tenacity of the Millelith sets.
15. What is “pity” in Genshin Impact?
Pity is a guaranteed 4-star or 5-star character or weapon after a specific number of wishes in each banner. On both the limited and standard banners, you are guaranteed a 4-star every 10 wishes and a 5-star every 90 wishes.
Conclusion
While 5-star artifacts represent the ultimate goal for any Genshin Impact player, it’s essential to understand that they are not always an automatic upgrade over their 4-star counterparts. Focus on optimizing your 4-star artifacts early on, and then transition to farming 5-star artifacts at Adventure Rank 45. With a good understanding of the artifact system, you can effectively equip your characters for any challenge. Remember that strategic resource management, not just chasing the highest rarity, is key to success in Genshin Impact.