Are Colossal Swords Bad in Elden Ring? A Deep Dive
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The question of whether colossal swords are “bad” in Elden Ring is complex and doesn’t have a simple yes or no answer. The truth is, they occupy a specific niche with unique strengths and weaknesses. They’re not inherently bad, but they are certainly not a universal solution, and understanding their role is crucial for success in the Lands Between. In short, colossal swords are not bad, but they are highly specialized. They demand a particular playstyle and are best suited for certain situations while being less effective in others.
The Unique Nature of Colossal Swords
Colossal swords in Elden Ring are defined by their massive size and weight. This translates into several key characteristics:
- High Poise Damage: They excel at staggering enemies, including bosses, much faster than smaller weapons. Aggressive play with a colossal sword can consistently interrupt enemy attacks, creating openings for follow-ups. This is their most significant strength.
- Low DPS (Damage Per Second): Their slow swing speed means that despite their high damage per hit, they don’t deal consistent damage over time like faster weapons. This makes them less ideal for sustained fights against highly mobile enemies.
- High Risk: The long wind-up and recovery animations leave you vulnerable to enemy attacks, making timing and positioning crucial. Getting hit or interrupted while swinging a colossal sword is common.
- Resource Intensive: Colossal swords require a significant amount of stamina per swing, potentially limiting the number of attacks you can perform before needing to recharge.
- Not Ideal for Crowds: While they can hit multiple enemies at once with certain attacks, their slow speed and vulnerability make them less effective than faster weapons designed for crowd control.
When Colossal Swords Shine
Despite their drawbacks, colossal swords are powerful in specific situations:
- Boss Fights (Stagger Focus): Their ability to break enemy stances quickly makes them exceptionally useful against bosses, creating opportunities for critical hits and stunning blows.
- Large Enemies: Enemies with substantial poise can be quickly brought down by their staggering power, preventing them from performing dangerous attacks.
- Specific Builds: When combined with talismans that enhance poise or weapon skills that increase their speed or damage, colossal swords can become devastating.
When Colossal Swords Struggle
Conversely, there are situations where colossal swords falter:
- Fast, Agile Enemies: They struggle against enemies that move quickly and relentlessly attack. Their slow swing speed can be easily exploited by such foes.
- Crowd Control: Against large packs of enemies, faster, multi-hit weapons and spells are generally more effective for managing the sheer volume.
- Situations Requiring Mobility: The weight of colossal swords impacts your agility, making dodging and repositioning more difficult, especially when burdened with heavier armor.
The Verdict: Not Bad, But Not for Everyone
So, are colossal swords bad? No, they aren’t inherently bad. They’re a highly specialized tool. Their low DPS and slow speed are balanced by their exceptional stagger potential and high per-hit damage. Whether they are good for you depends entirely on your playstyle and how you approach combat in Elden Ring. If you favor a methodical, heavy-hitting, poise-breaking approach, then colossal swords can be a fantastic choice. However, if you prefer a faster, more agile style, or need weapons for crowd control, you might find other weapon types more suitable. Understanding the strengths and weaknesses of colossal swords is key to using them effectively and succeeding in Elden Ring.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What makes colossal swords different from greatswords?
Colossal swords are significantly larger and heavier than greatswords, resulting in slower attack speeds, higher poise damage, and lower DPS. Greatswords offer a more balanced approach, with faster attacks and a more agile moveset.
2. Are colossal swords viable in Elden Ring?
Absolutely! Colossal swords are viable and can be incredibly powerful, especially against bosses and large enemies. However, they require a specific playstyle that emphasizes calculated attacks and taking advantage of openings.
3. Can you parry colossal swords?
No, you cannot parry a two-handed colossal sword attack.
4. Is it worth powerstancing colossal swords?
In most cases, powerstancing colossal swords is not recommended. It is generally more effective to use a single colossal sword, allowing you to attack more frequently and efficiently with less stamina consumption.
5. What is the best colossal sword in Elden Ring?
There isn’t one definitive “best” colossal sword, as it depends on your build and preferences. However, popular choices include the Godslayer’s Greatsword, Zweihander, and Maliketh’s Black Blade.
6. What talismans work well with colossal swords?
The Great-Jar’s Arsenal talisman is essential for increasing your equip load, allowing you to wear heavier armor with colossal swords while avoiding heavy roll penalties. Talismans that boost damage or poise are also beneficial.
7. Which weapon has the best stance break in Elden Ring?
While colossal swords are great at poise damage, specific Ashes of War like Lion’s Claw, Hoarah Loux’s Earthshaker, and Glintblade Phalanx are known for their stance breaking ability.
8. What is the easiest colossal weapon to obtain in Elden Ring?
The Greatsword is one of the easiest colossal weapons to find early in the game, making it a good starting point for players interested in trying the weapon type.
9. What is the hardest weapon type to use in Elden Ring?
While not universally agreed upon, weapons like daggers, claws, and fists are often considered harder to master due to their short range and reliance on specific builds. Weapons like flails and thrusting swords can also be challenging for new players.
10. What is the longest-reach weapon in Elden Ring?
The Pike spear boasts the longest reach among all weapons in Elden Ring.
11. What is the most overpowered sword in Elden Ring?
The Dark Moon Greatsword is often considered one of the most overpowered swords, thanks to its unique skill – Moonlight Greatsword, and potent magic damage output.
12. What is the best weapon combo in Elden Ring?
There isn’t one best combo, but the Godskin Peeler and Eleonora’s Poleblade are frequently recommended as a strong twinblade combo.
13. Is the Zweihander a colossal weapon?
Yes, the Zweihander is classified as a colossal sword in Elden Ring. It is one of the lightest colossal swords available, making it versatile and easier to wield.
14. Is it better to dual wield Rivers of Blood?
Dual-wielding Rivers of Blood is not typically recommended, though many players prefer to pair Rivers of Blood with another katana like the Uchigatana or Nagakiba for a mix of weapon arts and status build up.
15. What weapon does the least damage in Elden Ring?
Bare Fists are considered the lowest damage weapon in Elden Ring, followed closely by torches and certain daggers.