Cows vs. Goats: Which is the More Profitable Farm Animal in Stardew Valley?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The age-old question plagues every budding Stardew Valley farmer: cows or goats, which animal truly reigns supreme in the pursuit of profit? While early game, the lower entry cost of a goat may seem appealing, the long-term answer, and what to plan for is Cows! While individual goat cheese sells for a higher initial price, the key lies in the more frequent milk production of cows. Over time, cows produce milk every day, while goats produce milk only every other day. This consistent daily output allows for a greater volume of cheese production, ultimately leading to higher profits in the long run. Of course, the artisan profession and cheese aging come into play, which we’ll delve into. Let’s explore the nuances of each animal, considering factors like initial investment, production frequency, artisan goods, and overall farm strategy, to definitively crown the champion of Stardew Valley profitability.
The Basics: Cows and Goats in Stardew Valley
Before diving into the nitty-gritty details of profit margins, let’s establish a basic understanding of cows and goats within the game:
-
Cows: Purchased for 1,500g from Marnie’s Ranch, cows produce milk daily once matured. Happy cows, nurtured with love and ample hay, can even produce Large Milk, which is more valuable. Cows, with a high friendship level, are easier to gain and maintain because of their frequent output!
-
Goats: Acquired for 4,000g from Marnie’s Ranch, goats produce milk every other day once matured. Similar to cows, happy goats with a high friendship level will produce Large Goat Milk, which is also more valuable.
Profit Breakdown: Milk vs. Cheese
The most direct comparison lies in the milk and cheese each animal produces. Here’s a breakdown of the base values:
- Cow’s Milk: Sells for 125g.
- Large Milk: Sells for 190g.
- Cheese (Cow): Sells for 230g.
- Large Cheese (Cow): Sells for 345g.
- Goat Milk: Sells for 225g.
- Large Goat Milk: Sells for 345g.
- Goat Cheese: Sells for 400g.
Initially, Goat Cheese seems more profitable than regular Cheese. However, consider the production frequency. In a week, a cow produces 7 milk, a goat produces 3.5 milk. This means a cow can produce 7 cheeses per week and a goat produces 3.5 cheeses.
The Power of the Artisan Profession and Cheese Aging
Here’s where things get interesting. The Artisan profession, obtained at Farming Level 10, increases the value of artisan goods by 40%. This significantly impacts cheese profits:
- Cheese (Cow) with Artisan: 322g
- Large Cheese (Cow) with Artisan: 483g
- Goat Cheese with Artisan: 560g
The other factor is cheese aging. By placing cheese into casks in the cellar, it ages from normal to silver, gold and iridium quality. Gold quality, the most common outcome, increases the base price by 50% and the Iridium doubles it.
The price of the gold quality cheeses are as follows:
- Cheese (Cow) with Artisan: 483g
- Large Cheese (Cow) with Artisan: 724.5g
- Goat Cheese with Artisan: 840g
Cows vs. Goats: A Weekly Profitability Comparison
Based on the information provided, in general, the daily consistent output of cows makes them more profitable for cheese. However, if you do not milk them every day, their friendship decreases faster and they may not produce large milk. Goats, on the other hand, do not decrease as fast.
Cows are great for consistent, high-volume profit, especially with the artisan profession.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some frequently asked questions about maximizing profits with cows and goats in Stardew Valley:
1. How do I maximize friendship with my cows and goats?
Pet them daily, ensure they have access to food (either grass or hay), and keep the barn clean by removing manure. A heater during winter also helps maintain their happiness.
2. Is it worth aging goat cheese in casks?
Yes! Aging Goat Cheese significantly increases its value, especially with the Artisan profession. It’s one of the best ways to maximize the profit potential of goats.
3. How many animals should I have in my barn?
The optimal number depends on your resources and time. A fully upgraded barn can house 12 animals. Start with a few and gradually increase the number as your farm expands.
4. Do different breeds of cows or goats affect milk production?
No, Stardew Valley doesn’t have different breeds of cows or goats. All cows and goats produce the same type of milk.
5. Can I automate the milk and cheese production process?
While you can’t fully automate it, you can use auto-grabbers in the barn to collect milk automatically. This saves a significant amount of time. Also, upgrading to a level 2 barn gives the auto-grabber!
6. What’s the best strategy for making money in the early game?
In the early game, crops are generally more profitable than livestock. However, getting a few cows or goats early on can provide a steady income stream. You’ll get a goat milk needed for a bundle.
7. Are there any events or festivals that affect animal profits?
No, there aren’t any specific events or festivals that directly impact animal profits. However, festivals can provide opportunities to socialize and increase friendship with villagers, which can indirectly benefit your farm.
8. Do animals ever get sick or die in Stardew Valley?
Animals cannot die of old age or illness. However, they can become unhappy if neglected, which reduces their milk production.
9. Can I move my barn or coop after I’ve built it?
Yes, you can visit Robin’s shop and request to move any farm building for free.
10. What is the difference between regular and large milk?
Large Milk sells for more and can be used in certain cooking recipes. Happy and well-cared-for animals are more likely to produce Large Milk.
11. How does the season affect milk production?
Milk production is not directly affected by the season. However, in winter, you’ll need to provide hay for your animals as they cannot graze on grass outside.
12. Is it better to sell milk or cheese?
Cheese is generally more profitable than milk, especially with the Artisan profession. However, milk can be used in cooking recipes.
13. Do pigs compete with cows and goats for resources?
Pigs do not compete with cows and goats. They live in separate barns and require different types of food (truffles found outside, not hay).
14. How does Games Learning Society relate to Stardew Valley?
While not directly related, the Games Learning Society or GamesLearningSociety.org promotes understanding how games can be used for learning and engagement. Stardew Valley itself offers a multitude of learning opportunities, including resource management, strategic planning, and economic principles.
15. Can animals escape their enclosure?
Animals will not escape their enclosure unless fences are broken. Maintaining fences is crucial for keeping your animals contained.
The Final Verdict
While goats offer an early-game advantage with their higher-value cheese, cows ultimately prove to be more profitable in the long run due to their consistent daily milk production. Coupled with the Artisan profession and the potential for Large Milk, cows provide a steady and reliable income stream. However, a well-rounded farm with both cows and goats can offer a diverse range of artisan goods and contribute to a thriving Stardew Valley economy. Ultimately, the choice is yours, farmer!