Are Proxies Okay in Commander?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Proxies are generally okay in Commander, as the format is often more relaxed and casual, with many players using proxies as a way to make the game more accessible and affordable. However, it’s essential to note that official tournaments and sanctioned events may have strict rules against using proxies, so it’s crucial to check with the event organizer or judge before playing with proxy cards.
Understanding Proxies in Commander
What are Proxies?
Proxies are recreated versions of Magic: The Gathering cards, often used as a substitute for the real thing. They can be homemade or purchased from third-party vendors, and are commonly used in casual games and non-sanctioned events.
Are Proxies Allowed in Commander?
While proxies are generally allowed in Commander, it’s essential to follow the rules and guidelines set by the event organizer or judge. Some official tournaments may not allow proxies, so it’s crucial to check before playing.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Q: Are proxies legal in Magic: The Gathering? A: Proxies are not officially recognized by Wizards of the Coast, but they are commonly used in casual games and non-sanctioned events.
- Q: Can I use proxies in official tournaments? A: No, official tournaments and sanctioned events typically do not allow proxies, as they can be considered counterfeit cards.
- Q: Are proxies okay in cEDH? A: Yes, cEDH is a more relaxed format, and proxies are generally allowed, making it more accessible and affordable for players.
- Q: How do I know if a card is a proxy? A: Proxy cards often have a different rosette pattern than genuine cards, which can be detected using the rosette test.
- Q: Are 40k cards legal in MTG? A: Yes, Warhammer 40,000 Commander Decks cards are legal for play in Commander, Vintage, and Legacy formats, but not in Standard, Pioneer, or Modern formats.
- Q: Are proxy basic lands legal? A: No, proxies are not legal in sanctioned events, but alters (modified cards with new art) may be allowed if they meet certain criteria.
- Q: How do I know if my MTG card is legal in Commander? A: Check the Commander card pool to see if your card is legal, and ensure it meets the format’s rules and guidelines.
- Q: What is proxy cheating? A: Proxy cheating refers to the act of using proxy cards in official tournaments or sanctioned events, which is considered cheating.
- Q: Is proxy illegal in the USA? A: Using a proxy server itself is not illegal, but using it for illicit activities can make it illegal.
- Q: Why do hackers use proxies? A: Hackers use proxy servers to hide malicious network activity, such as DDoS attacks and phishing attempts.
- Q: Are proxies untraceable? A: Proxies can be anonymous, but they are not completely untraceable, as server administrators can still restrict proxy requests.
- Q: Is open proxy bad? A: Open proxies can be risky, as they allow both legitimate and malicious traffic to pass through, and are not policed or monitored closely.
- Q: Are reverse proxies bad? A: Reverse proxies can provide security, but they also come with risks, such as information storage and data encryption.
- Q: What proxies should I use? A: Residential proxies are considered the best option for most uses, as they are IP addresses of real devices and are harder to detect.
- Q: Are proxy servers free? A: Free proxies are available, but they often come with security risks, such as unencrypted data and traffic monitoring, so it’s recommended to use paid proxy services for better security and reliability.