Are You Allowed to Resell Games? Unlocking the Truth About Reselling Video Games
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Yes, generally, you are allowed to resell physical copies of video games. This right stems from a legal concept called the First Sale Doctrine. However, the world of digital games adds a layer of complexity, where the lines between ownership and licensing become blurred. Let’s dive deep into the nuances of reselling both physical and digital games, along with some commonly asked questions.
Understanding the First Sale Doctrine
The First Sale Doctrine is a cornerstone of copyright law. It states that once a copyright holder sells a particular copy of their work (like a video game), they relinquish control over that specific copy. The buyer is then free to lend, rent, or sell that copy to someone else without infringing on the copyright holder’s rights. This is why you can legally sell your used books, DVDs, and, crucially, physical video games.
The Digital Dilemma: Licenses vs. Ownership
The First Sale Doctrine applies to physical copies you own. However, when you purchase a digital game from platforms like Steam, PlayStation Network, or Xbox Live, you’re typically not buying the game itself. Instead, you’re purchasing a license to play the game.
This distinction is crucial. EULAs (End User License Agreements) and Terms of Service (ToS) for these platforms often explicitly state that you’re granted a non-transferable license, meaning you can’t legally resell or transfer it to another person.
Why Can’t I Resell Digital Games?
Several factors contribute to the limitations on reselling digital games:
- Licensing Agreements: As mentioned, digital game purchases are usually licenses, not outright ownership, restricting resale.
- Non-Deteriorating Nature: Unlike physical media that degrades over time, digital games remain in pristine condition, potentially flooding the market if reselling was allowed.
- Distribution System Control: Platforms maintain tight control over their distribution systems, making it difficult to transfer licenses securely and prevent piracy.
- Account-Bound Licenses: Digital games are usually tied to a specific user account, making it technically challenging to separate the game from the account for resale purposes.
- Protecting Revenue: The current system protects revenue streams for developers and platform holders, ensuring continued investment in new games.
Reselling Physical Copies: Navigating the Landscape
While legally permissible, reselling physical games has its considerations:
- Platform Policies: While reselling is legal, some platform holders discourage it. There are no legal ramifications, but they may not actively support it.
- Market Value: The resale value of a game depends on factors like its popularity, rarity, condition, and current market demand.
- Retailer Trade-in Programs: Retailers like GameStop offer trade-in programs, but the value offered is often less than what you might get selling privately.
Navigating EULAs and TOS
It is important to note that while you are free to sell your physical copies of video games, the EULA and TOS of a game may place other conditions or restrictions on you. Be sure to review these documents before proceeding with a sale.
FAQs: Your Burning Questions Answered
1. Is selling used video games illegal?
No, selling used physical video games is not illegal due to the First Sale Doctrine. You own the physical copy and can resell it.
2. Can I get banned for selling a game account?
Yes, selling game accounts is almost always a violation of the game’s Terms of Service (ToS) and can lead to a permanent ban.
3. Is it legal to sell in-game items for real money?
It depends on the game’s Terms of Service (ToS). Many games prohibit the sale of in-game items for real money, and doing so could result in account suspension or legal action.
4. Can I sell my old gaming console?
Absolutely! You own the console, so you’re free to sell it.
5. What about “Not For Resale” (NFR) copies?
NFR copies are intended for review or promotional purposes and are not meant to be sold. Selling them is unethical, and may carry legal consequences for certain software.
6. Can I sell a game I downloaded illegally, if I now own a legal copy?
No. Illegally downloading copyrighted material is always illegal. Owning a legal copy later doesn’t erase the initial infringement.
7. Is it illegal to sell M-rated games to minors?
The ESRB rating is a guideline, not a law. Selling an M-rated game to a minor is not illegal in most jurisdictions, but retailers may have policies against it.
8. Can I sell a game I got for free through PlayStation Plus or Xbox Games with Gold?
Since you never purchased the game (even though you “claimed” it), selling it would go against the TOS. These games are typically tied to your subscription and not transferable.
9. Is it illegal to resell a limited edition or collector’s edition game?
No, reselling a limited edition or collector’s edition game is legal as long as you legally purchased it in the first place.
10. Can I sell a game I got as a gift?
Yes, if it’s a physical copy. You are now the owner, and the First Sale Doctrine applies. Digital gifts are subject to the same licensing restrictions.
11. Where are the best places to sell used video games?
Popular options include Decluttr, Amazon’s Trade-in Option, Swappa, eBay, OfferUp, Trade4Cash, Gameflip, and The Old School Game Vault.
12. What if I modify a game before selling it?
Selling a modified game may violate the game’s copyright, especially if you’re distributing copyrighted material without permission. However, if the game modifications you are making are your own creation and don’t infringe the underlying copyright, you are free to sell them.
13. Does GameStop buy used games?
Yes, GameStop buys used games for cash or store credit.
14. Can I sell a digital game code I haven’t redeemed?
Yes, you can sell an unredeemed digital game code. However, be careful about fraud and only sell through reputable platforms.
15. Where can I find more information about the educational benefits of games?
You can explore the Games Learning Society at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/, a great source of knowledge about how games can be used for educational purposes.
Conclusion: Reselling Games in the Modern Era
Reselling games, particularly physical copies, is generally legal thanks to the First Sale Doctrine. However, the digital realm introduces licensing agreements that restrict the resale of digital games. Understanding these nuances and platform policies is crucial before engaging in any resale activity. Always check the game’s EULA and ToS to avoid violating any terms and potentially facing account restrictions. So go ahead, clear out that game shelf, but be mindful of the fine print! Remember, the more you know, the savvier you’ll be in the ever-evolving world of video game ownership and resale.