Can Arthur Get Fat in Red Dead Redemption 2? A Deep Dive into Weight Gain and Loss
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Yes, Arthur Morgan can absolutely get fat in Red Dead Redemption 2. The game features a dynamic weight system that realistically reflects Arthur’s eating habits and activity levels. You can influence his physique, turning him into a lean gunslinger or a slightly portly outlaw. This system, while seemingly superficial, actually impacts gameplay, affecting his stamina and resistance to damage. So, strap on your spurs, grab a steak, and let’s delve into the meaty details of Arthur’s fluctuating weight.
Understanding the Weight System
The core mechanic is simple: eat more and exercise less to gain weight, and eat less and exercise more to lose weight. Arthur’s weight is categorized into three main states:
- Underweight: Arthur’s stamina core regenerates faster, but he takes more damage.
- Average: A balanced state with no specific advantages or disadvantages.
- Overweight: Arthur has increased damage resistance, but his stamina core regenerates slower.
The game subtly communicates Arthur’s weight status through visual cues (his physique changes) and by displaying a notification in the top-left corner of the screen when his weight shifts between categories.
Factors Influencing Arthur’s Weight
Several factors contribute to Arthur’s weight fluctuation:
- Food Consumption: This is the most significant factor. Regularly consuming meals, especially high-calorie foods, will lead to weight gain.
- Activity Level: Engaging in strenuous activities such as running, riding, and fighting burns calories and promotes weight loss.
- Rest: Resting, either by sleeping or using the “kneel” option (holding Triangle/Y), helps Arthur digest food and gain weight.
- Story Progression: A crucial caveat is Arthur’s health status. As the story progresses and he contracts Tuberculosis (TB), his ability to gain weight is severely hampered.
The TB Factor: A Weight Loss Roadblock
Unfortunately, Arthur’s battle with Tuberculosis significantly complicates the weight gain process. After a certain point in the story, his illness kicks in, and he’ll begin to lose weight regardless of his diet. The game subtly signals this with increased coughing and a paler complexion. While you can temporarily mitigate the weight loss by constantly stuffing him with food, it becomes increasingly difficult, and eventually impossible, to maintain an overweight status. This mechanic effectively underscores the devastating effects of TB on Arthur’s body.
Optimizing Weight Gain: The Gluttony Strategy
If you’re determined to fatten up Arthur before his illness takes hold, you need to embrace a strategic approach to gluttony:
- Frequent Feasting: Eat multiple meals per day. Don’t just restore your cores; overeat. Stuff Arthur until he physically can’t eat anymore.
- High-Calorie Choices: Prioritize high-calorie foods like cooked big game meat (alligator, bear, wolf), which provide a substantial calorie boost.
- Rest and Digest: After each meal, immediately rest by kneeling or sleeping. This allows Arthur to efficiently process the calories.
- Minimize Activity: Reduce strenuous activities like sprinting and long rides to conserve calories.
- Maintain the Routine: Consistency is key. Missing even a couple of overeating sessions can set back your progress.
Is Being Overweight Beneficial?
The benefit of being overweight is increased damage resistance. In a firefight, Arthur can withstand more punishment before going down. However, the drawback is reduced stamina regeneration. This means he’ll tire more quickly during activities like running and swimming. Ultimately, whether being overweight is “better” depends on your play style. If you favor combat and don’t mind a slower pace, the extra health can be advantageous. If you prefer exploration and agility, maintaining an average weight might be more suitable.
Arthur’s Appearance and Morality
Interestingly, Arthur’s weight doesn’t directly influence his honor or how NPCs interact with him. It’s primarily a cosmetic and gameplay-related feature. However, some players feel that a well-fed Arthur reflects a more carefree and indulgent lifestyle, potentially aligning with a low-honor playthrough. Conversely, a lean Arthur might be interpreted as a more disciplined and honorable character. These are, of course, subjective interpretations.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. How quickly can Arthur get fat in Red Dead Redemption 2?
It depends on your dedication to the overeating routine. With consistent feasting and resting, you can see a noticeable weight gain within a few in-game days.
2. Can Arthur become obese?
While you can make Arthur overweight, the game doesn’t have a specific “obese” state. There appears to be an upper limit to how much weight he can gain.
3. What happens if Arthur is overweight?
He experiences a reduction in stamina regeneration and gains increased damage resistance.
4. How do you make Arthur fat fast?
Repeatedly eat high-calorie foods and then rest immediately. Prioritize cooked big game meat and minimize physical activity.
5. Can you make Arthur overweight in Chapter 6?
It’s significantly harder, but technically possible to make Arthur overweight in Chapter 6. But as his TB progresses, it becomes nearly impossible to maintain an overweight status, as the disease actively works against any weight gain.
6. What is Arthur Morgan’s body type?
Arthur’s default body type is athletic.
7. Why is Arthur always underweight RDR2?
After contracting Tuberculosis, Arthur’s body struggles to absorb nutrients, leading to involuntary weight loss.
8. Is overweight better in RDR2?
It depends on your play style. Overweight Arthur has increased damage resistance but reduced stamina regeneration.
9. What is the most fattening food in RDR2?
Cooked big game meat is the most effective for weight gain.
10. Can you get fat in Red Dead Online?
Yes, Red Dead Online characters can also gain weight through excessive eating and minimal activity, mirroring the single-player experience.
11. Why does Arthur cough when eating?
After contracting Tuberculosis, Arthur coughs due to the damage inflicted on his lungs.
12. Can you make Arthur stronger?
Yes, by eating regularly to maintain a healthy weight, acquiring beneficial equipment, and increasing his stats through gameplay.
13. Can Arthur avoid getting TB in RDR2?
The only way to avoid Arthur contracting TB is to avoid progressing through the main storyline.
14. Can you cure Arthur’s tuberculosis?
No, there is no cure for Arthur’s tuberculosis in Red Dead Redemption 2. The story dictates his fate.
15. Is it better to be good or bad in RDR2?
Whether it’s better to be good or bad depends on your preferred playstyle. A high-honor playthrough offers discounts and other benefits, while a low-honor playthrough allows for more unrestricted outlaw activities.
Conclusion: A Weighty Matter
The weight system in Red Dead Redemption 2 is a fascinating detail that adds depth and realism to the game. While it’s fun to experiment with Arthur’s physique, it’s important to remember that his health ultimately takes precedence as the story unfolds. So, enjoy the process of stuffing Arthur with food, but be prepared for the inevitable weight loss that comes with his tragic fate. Understanding the nuances of this system allows you to further immerse yourself in the world of Red Dead Redemption 2 and connect with Arthur Morgan on a deeper level. For more information about games and learning, visit the GamesLearningSociety.org website.