Can Black Knight Weapons Go Past +5 in Dark Souls? The Definitive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The short and direct answer is no, Black Knight weapons cannot be upgraded past +5 in Dark Souls. This is a core mechanic of how these unique weapons function within the game, and understanding it is crucial for any player looking to maximize their potential. Black Knight weapons, including the Black Knight Sword, Black Knight Greatsword, and Black Knight Halberd, are considered special weapons. These weapons follow a different upgrade path than standard weapons and are reinforced using Twinkling Titanite.
Understanding Special Weapons and Twinkling Titanite
In Dark Souls, weapons are divided into categories based on how they’re upgraded. Standard weapons utilize regular Titanite Shards, Large Titanite Shards, Titanite Chunks, and Titanite Slabs to progress through their upgrade paths up to +15. However, special weapons, such as those crafted from boss souls and Black Knight weapons, follow a different upgrade path entirely. These weapons are upgraded using Twinkling Titanite.
The use of Twinkling Titanite is the critical distinction here. Any weapon upgraded using Twinkling Titanite has its upgrade path capped at +5. This means that whether you have a Black Knight Sword, Greatsword, Halberd, or any other weapon using this material, they will reach their maximum potential at +5. This upgrade path is not less powerful; rather, each upgrade level on these weapons provides a substantial increase in stats, roughly equivalent to two upgrade levels on a normal +15 weapon.
Why the +5 Cap?
The +5 cap on these weapons isn’t arbitrary. It’s designed to balance the game by offering powerful, early-to-mid-game options that eventually get outclassed by fully upgraded standard weapons. When a Black Knight weapon reaches +5, it performs exceptionally well, often outperforming comparable +10 regular weapons. Think of Black Knight weapons as having already been upgraded to +10 before you even find them. Each additional upgrade with Twinkling Titanite then pushes it beyond that baseline to achieve its maximum +5 level. This system allows players to utilize weapons that would otherwise be too powerful for their current progress.
The Power of Black Knight Weapons
Black Knight weapons are formidable not just due to their high base damage, but also their unique move sets and strategic advantages. Many players gravitate to these weapons early game precisely because they offer a path to tackling tough areas quickly. The Black Knight Halberd, for example, is often cited as one of the best weapons in the game due to its reach, speed, and significant damage output. Although Black Knight weapons are potent, the inability to buff, infuse, and upgrade past +5 is part of the balancing act, making a player look at many options throughout the game.
Black Knight Weapons: The Core Concepts
Let’s look into the reasons why Black Knight weapons are so sought-after.
- Powerful Early-Game Options: The ability to achieve a high power level early in the game makes Black Knight weapons extremely valuable. You can often find them without the need to kill bosses and take the souls to make a boss weapon.
- Unique Move Sets: Each weapon has its own unique moveset which can drastically influence combat situations and is tailored to certain play styles.
- Balanced Power Curve: The upgrade system for Black Knight weapons is designed to provide substantial power early to mid game, but also allow you to branch out and find weapons that you are able to buff or enchant late game.
- Strategic Advantages: The range of the Black Knight Halberd is a prime example of the strategic advantages some of these weapons provide.
- Cannot be Infused or Buffed: While powerful on their own, these weapons cannot be buffed or infused with magic or elemental damage which might hinder their potential late game.
Frequently Asked Questions About Black Knight Weapons
Here are some frequently asked questions to provide more insight into the mechanics and usage of Black Knight weapons:
1. What is the maximum upgrade level for Black Knight weapons?
The maximum upgrade level for all Black Knight weapons is +5.
2. Why can’t Black Knight weapons be upgraded past +5?
Black Knight weapons are special weapons that use Twinkling Titanite for upgrades. Weapons using this resource have a maximum upgrade level of +5. This is a part of the game’s balancing mechanics.
3. What upgrade materials are required for Black Knight weapons?
They require Twinkling Titanite for all upgrades.
4. Is a +5 Black Knight weapon equivalent to a +10 or +15 standard weapon?
A +5 Black Knight weapon is roughly equivalent to a +10 standard weapon in terms of raw power. This makes them potent in the early and mid stages of the game.
5. Can you use embers to upgrade Black Knight weapons?
No. Embers are for standard weapons, not for special weapons that use Twinkling Titanite.
6. Do Black Knight weapons scale with player stats?
Yes, they do, primarily with Strength and Dexterity. However, their scaling is often less than standard weapons, making the base damage a more significant factor in their performance.
7. What are the main Black Knight weapons in Dark Souls?
The primary Black Knight weapons are the Black Knight Sword, Black Knight Greatsword, and Black Knight Halberd.
8. Is the Black Knight Halberd the best Black Knight weapon?
Many players consider it to be one of the best weapons in the game due to its damage, reach, speed, and viable usage for all encounters.
9. Can Black Knight weapons be enchanted or buffed?
No, Black Knight weapons cannot be enchanted or buffed. This is a significant trade-off for their high base damage and upgrade advantages.
10. Can Black Knight weapons be infused with elemental damage?
No. Black Knight weapons cannot be infused with elemental damage, such as Lightning or Fire.
11. Is the Black Knight Sword better than the Zweihander?
The Black Knight Sword is generally considered better in the early-to-mid game because it is much easier to upgrade. However, the Zweihander may be better in late game because of its reach, stagger, and damage output once fully upgraded.
12. How do I get the Black Knight Halberd early in the game?
The best way to get the Black Knight Halberd is to farm the Black Knight with the Halberd in Undead Burg or the one located in the Kiln of the First Flame. However, it is a random drop, so you might have to kill a few of them to get your hands on it.
13. Why is the Black Knight Halberd used in speedruns?
The Black Knight Halberd’s powerful move-set and damage output make it ideal for quickly taking down bosses and enemies and is ideal for many move swap glitches.
14. Are Black Knight weapons still viable in the late game?
While they might be out-damaged by fully upgraded standard weapons, Black Knight weapons remain viable options because of their high base damage, move sets, and strategic advantages.
15. Should I do a full playthrough using only Black Knight weapons?
A full playthrough with just Black Knight weapons is not uncommon. The move sets and base damage can be effective throughout the game, but you will have to get good with the lack of infusions and buffs.
Conclusion
While Black Knight weapons can’t go beyond +5, their strategic importance, unique qualities, and powerful damage output make them invaluable tools for players throughout their Dark Souls journey. Understanding their upgrade limitations and utilizing their strengths can be key to success, particularly in the early to mid portions of the game. Ultimately, knowing these weapons’ limitations is crucial to crafting a strategy for every encounter.