Can Frost Lynx Tap a Tapped Creature? A Deep Dive into Magic: The Gathering Rules
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Yes, Frost Lynx can target and “tap” a creature that is already tapped. While this might seem counterintuitive, it’s a crucial aspect of understanding how abilities and game rules interact in Magic: The Gathering (MTG). The key here is that Frost Lynx’s ability tracks the creature, not its controller, and it doesn’t actually “untap” or “re-tap” a creature. Even though a tapped creature can’t be tapped again in the traditional sense of turning it sideways, the effect of Frost Lynx’s ability still applies: that creature won’t untap during its controller’s next untap step. This article will delve into the nuances of this interaction and address frequently asked questions regarding tapping, untapping, and other relevant game mechanics.
Understanding Frost Lynx’s Ability
Frost Lynx’s ability reads something along the lines of “When Frost Lynx enters the battlefield, tap target creature. That creature doesn’t untap during its controller’s next untap step.” The first part of the ability “tap target creature” is crucial, while the second part is a delayed effect that occurs on the following turn.
How Tapping Works in MTG
In MTG, “tapping” generally refers to turning an untapped permanent (usually a creature, artifact, or land) sideways to signify that it has been used or is under the effect of an ability. Once tapped, the permanent cannot be tapped again. However, some card effects can still try to “tap” a tapped card, as in the case of Frost Lynx.
The “Tap” Command on a Tapped Creature
While you cannot physically further tap a tapped card, Frost Lynx’s ability still targets the chosen creature and applies its secondary effect, which prevents the creature from untapping during its controller’s next untap step. This is because the Frost Lynx’s ability is not dependent on the act of tapping the target, but on the target itself. Whether the creature was already tapped or untapped when the ability resolved is irrelevant to whether it is prevented from untapping.
The Difference Between the Action and the Effect
It’s important to distinguish between the physical act of tapping a card and the effect of an ability that states “tap target creature”. When a spell or ability attempts to tap a tapped permanent, no physical change occurs, but the additional effects associated with the ability still happen (e.g., the creature is unable to untap next turn as with Frost Lynx). This can be confusing but is a core part of understanding MTG rules.
Related FAQs about Tapping and Related Mechanics
To further clarify these concepts, let’s explore some commonly asked questions about tapping, untapping, and related mechanics:
1. Can You Tap a Tapped Creature?
Short answer: Yes, you can target a tapped creature with an effect that says “tap target creature”. While it doesn’t result in a visible change, other parts of the ability will still apply.
2. What Happens If You Try to Tap an Already Tapped Creature?
Nothing physically happens to the creature. The creature remains tapped. However, any secondary effects associated with that ability still apply, like the prevention of untapping.
3. Can You Tap Your Own Attacking Creatures Before Damage?
Yes. Certain cards like Glimpse the Sun God can “tap” your attacking creatures before combat damage is dealt, potentially triggering Heroic abilities. While your creatures are already tapped from attacking, the “tap” from the spell won’t physically change the cards, but the Heroic effect would still trigger.
4. Can a Tapped Creature Attack?
No, once a creature attacks, it becomes tapped. Tapped creatures cannot attack. Creatures also can’t attack if they are under the effect of summoning sickness.
5. Do Creatures Tap When They Fight?
No. Fighting does not involve tapping; creatures simply deal damage to each other when they fight, whether or not they have summoning sickness or other tapping restrictions.
6. Can You Use a Tap Ability When a Creature Has Summoning Sickness?
No. Creatures with summoning sickness cannot attack or use abilities that require the tap symbol in their cost.
7. Can You Enchant a Tapped Creature?
Yes, you can enchant a tapped creature. Unless the enchantment specifically states that it must enchant an untapped creature, a creature’s tapped or untapped status doesn’t prevent it from being enchanted.
8. Can You Tap a Permanent That’s Already Tapped?
Technically, no, you cannot physically tap a permanent that is already tapped by turning it sideways. However, abilities that instruct you to “tap” a permanent will still resolve.
9. Can You Use a Tap Ability at Instant Speed?
Yes, you can use tap abilities at instant speed, as long as you have priority, pay the associated costs, and the creature doesn’t have summoning sickness.
10. Can You Transform a Tapped Creature?
Yes, transforming a permanent does not change its tapped status. If you transform a tapped creature, the resulting permanent will also be tapped.
11. Does Sleep Affect Tapped Creatures?
Yes, spells like Sleep can affect tapped creatures. While they can’t be further tapped, they can still be prevented from untapping. Sleep’s text reads “Tap all creatures target player controls.” This effect will apply regardless of their current status.
12. Does Indestructible Beat Deathtouch?
Yes, indestructible creatures are immune to deathtouch. Deathtouch causes creatures to be destroyed due to “lethal damage,” and indestructible creatures can’t be destroyed by lethal damage.
13. Does Hexproof Prevent Deathtouch?
No, hexproof does not prevent deathtouch. Hexproof only prevents targeting, and deathtouch does not target.
14. Can You Tap a Creature Multiple Times in a Turn?
Yes, you can tap a creature multiple times in a turn if you are able to untap it in between those taps, otherwise abilities that say “tap target creature” will only cause the secondary effect to trigger when targeting a tapped creature.
15. Does Regenerating a Creature Tap It?
Yes, after a creature has been dealt lethal damage and successfully regenerated, it becomes tapped. However, creatures that are already tapped can be regenerated, but they will remain tapped.
Conclusion
Understanding the intricacies of how tapping works, especially when dealing with spells that attempt to “tap” already tapped creatures, is crucial for mastering Magic: The Gathering. Frost Lynx’s ability is a perfect example of how game mechanics often have subtle layers that can lead to deeper game interactions. By remembering that many spells and abilities apply secondary effects that do not rely on a physical change to the card, you’ll be able to play the game with increased precision and strategy.