Can John Marston Recover the Elusive Blackwater Money in Red Dead Redemption 2?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Yes, during the epilogue of Red Dead Redemption 2, John Marston can indeed access a portion of the infamous Blackwater heist money. While he doesn’t directly stumble upon the entire stash hidden away years prior, he receives a significant sum that is heavily implied to be derived from those long-lost funds. Specifically, John finds a chest during the final mission, “American Venom,” which contains $20,000, a substantial amount for the time period, and more than enough to get him and his family on the road to a better life. This money is strongly suggested to be a remnant of the ill-fated Blackwater loot.
Unpacking the Blackwater Mystery and John’s Inheritance
The Blackwater heist hangs over the entirety of Red Dead Redemption 2 like a dark cloud. The botched robbery, the resulting deaths, and the relentless pursuit by law enforcement set the stage for the Van der Linde gang’s desperate flight across the American landscape. The money from Blackwater is often referred to and pursued as the “big score”, and it haunts the characters for years. It’s a symbol of their failed dreams and the increasingly desperate measures they are willing to take.
So, while you never get to see the full treasure, John’s acquisition of the $20,000 in “American Venom” serves as a closure of sorts. After the final showdown with Micah Bell, Dutch appears and, in a moment of unexpected clarity, leaves the money for John. This act is interpreted as Dutch’s acknowledgement of his past failures and a tacit endorsement of John’s future. It’s a far cry from finding a hidden vault, but it’s a poignant way to tie up one of the game’s central plot threads.
Frequently Asked Questions About Blackwater and John’s Finances
Let’s delve into some common questions surrounding the Blackwater money and John Marston’s financial situation in Red Dead Redemption 2:
1. Can John find Arthur’s money?
While John can’t directly inherit Arthur’s personal wealth from the main game, there’s a clever workaround. If you deliberately get robbed at the Aberdeen Pig Farm as Arthur and don’t retrieve your money before the epilogue, you can return as John to claim it. This includes all the money that Arthur possessed. However, other valuables like jewelry and provisions are lost.
2. Does John get rich in RDR2?
Technically, John doesn’t become exceptionally wealthy. The $20,000 he receives is a significant amount, especially in 1907, but it’s not enough to live a life of opulent luxury. However, it’s enough to purchase Beecher’s Hope, establish a ranch, and provide a stable future for his family, which is John’s primary goal.
3. Can John get Dutch’s chest from Beaver Hollow?
(SPOILER) If during the storyline the player chooses the honorable option Dutch’s chest remains in Beaver Hollow. Just discovered this, but if you go back as John, if you chose to go with John, Dutch’s chest will still be under the wagon in Beaver Hollow, untouched.
4. Why is John not wanted in Blackwater anymore?
While John was definitely wanted in Blackwater alongside the rest of the Van der Linde gang, the passage of time plays a significant role. By the time John is playable in the epilogue, eight years have passed since the Blackwater Massacre. Law enforcement priorities shift, memories fade, and individual identities become blurred. Also, the deaths of key witnesses and the gang’s disbandment contribute to his lower profile.
5. What happens if you return to Dutch’s money cave after beating Red Dead Redemption 2?
There isn’t a specific “money cave” belonging to Dutch in the traditional sense. The $20,000 John finds in “American Venom” is located at the site of the final confrontation with Micah. Returning to that location after completing the game doesn’t yield any further secrets or hidden treasures.
6. How much money did John get from the Blackwater heist?
Technically, John never directly received money from the Blackwater heist. The $20,000 he finds is generally believed to be a portion of the Blackwater money that Dutch had managed to hold onto. It’s not John’s share from the original plan, but rather a belated and somewhat remorseful gift.
7. Why did Dutch leave the money for John?
Dutch’s motives in leaving the money for John are complex and open to interpretation. After seeing Micah for who he truly was, and witnessing John’s unwavering loyalty, Dutch may have felt a sense of guilt or regret. Leaving the money can be seen as a final act of redemption, an attempt to right some of his past wrongs, and an acknowledgement of John’s inherent goodness. It allows John and his family to have a chance at a better life, free from the outlaw lifestyle.
8. Can you find all the Blackwater money?
No, there is no way to find the entire Blackwater stash in Red Dead Redemption 2. The game intentionally leaves the fate of the remaining money ambiguous. This ambiguity adds to the mystique surrounding the Blackwater incident and reinforces the theme of lost dreams and unfulfilled promises.
9. Is John stronger than Arthur in RDR2?
This is a matter of debate among fans. Arthur Morgan is arguably stronger in terms of physical prowess and hand-to-hand combat. However, John Marston is renowned for his superior gunslinging abilities and experience. Both have access to Dead Eye, but John’s marksman skills are generally considered more refined.
10. Does John inherit Arthur’s guns and outfits?
Yes, John inherits Arthur’s weapons and clothing after completing a few missions in the epilogue. This allows players to continue their gameplay with a familiar arsenal and wardrobe. However, Arthur’s horses are not transferred to John.
11. Can John get the White Arabian horse if Arthur had it?
Yes, the White Arabian horse will respawn at Lake Isabella after Arthur’s death, allowing John to tame it. This is true even if Arthur had previously tamed and bonded with the horse. The game treats wild horses as recurring encounters.
12. What Happens If You Return To Dutch’s Money Cave After Beating Red Dead Redemption 2?
There isn’t a dedicated “Dutch’s money cave” to find. The money John recovers during “American Venom” is at the scene of the confrontation with Micah. Returning there after the game offers no new discoveries.
13. Do you lose everything after Guarma?
During the Guarma chapter, you do temporarily lose access to most of your items and weapons. However, they are returned to you when you return to the mainland. This loss emphasizes the gang’s vulnerability and the desperate circumstances they face.
14. Is Abigail a rat in RDR2?
There’s no evidence within the game to suggest that Abigail was a rat. While she expressed a desire for a peaceful life away from the gang, her actions don’t indicate that she betrayed them to the authorities.
15. Can you save Lenny in RDR2?
Unfortunately, Lenny’s death is a fixed event in the game’s storyline. No matter what actions you take, he will always die during the Saint Denis bank robbery. This is a tragic but crucial plot point that underscores the dangers of the outlaw life.
The Significance of Money in Red Dead Redemption 2
Red Dead Redemption 2 uses money as more than just a gameplay mechanic. It’s a symbol of hope, desperation, and the corrupting influence of greed. The pursuit of the Blackwater money drives many of the gang’s actions, leading to internal conflicts and ultimately contributing to their downfall. John’s eventual acquisition of a portion of those funds represents a chance to break free from that cycle and build a better future for his family.
The narrative intricately weaves financial aspirations with moral dilemmas, compelling players to contemplate the true worth of their actions. The Blackwater money, in particular, functions as a constant reminder of the gang’s tarnished past and the elusive nature of redemption.
Conclusion
While the Blackwater money remains largely out of reach, John Marston’s ability to secure a portion of it in the epilogue offers a sense of closure and a glimmer of hope. It’s a tangible reward for his loyalty, his struggles, and his determination to create a new life for his family.
If you are interested in finding more about game design and the complex narrative structures found in games like Red Dead Redemption 2, be sure to check out the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org. They provide a great wealth of information about the educational and cultural impact of gaming.