Can Monks Use Two-Weapon Fighting?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
Yes, monks can use two-weapon fighting in Dungeons & Dragons 5th Edition (5e), just like any other character. However, the question of whether they should is a bit more nuanced. While the rules allow it, a monk’s kit often favors other options, making dual-wielding a potentially less optimal choice for many builds. Let’s delve into the details of how two-weapon fighting works for monks, its advantages, disadvantages, and explore some related aspects.
How Two-Weapon Fighting Works for Monks
The core rule for two-weapon fighting is straightforward: if you take the Attack action and attack with a light melee weapon you’re holding in one hand, you can use a bonus action to attack with a different light melee weapon you’re holding in the other hand. Here’s how it applies to monks:
- Light Weapons are Key: To engage in two-weapon fighting, you must wield light melee weapons. This limits the monk’s options to weapons like shortswords and certain simple melee weapons that meet both the light and monk weapon criteria.
- Bonus Action Requirement: The off-hand attack uses your bonus action. This is a crucial point as monks have many other bonus action options that are typically more impactful.
- Damage Implications: The off-hand attack does not add your ability modifier to the damage roll. This can significantly impact the damage output. There are fighting styles and feats that can mitigate this.
- Monk Weapon Compatibility: Monks have a specific list of weapons they are proficient with, called Monk Weapons. These include shortswords and any simple melee weapon that does not have the two-handed or heavy properties. So, a light simple melee weapon makes the best dual-wielding candidate for a monk.
Why Dual-Wielding Might Not be Optimal for Monks
Despite being possible, dual-wielding for monks is often less effective than other options due to the limitations and opportunity costs involved:
- Bonus Action Conflict: The most significant hurdle is the bonus action. Monks heavily rely on their bonus action to use class features like Flurry of Blows, which is typically more damaging. Flurry of Blows allows for two unarmed strikes and adds the monk’s Dexterity modifier to the damage rolls, making it a powerful and common option. Using a bonus action for two-weapon fighting means sacrificing a potential Flurry of Blows or other ki-fueled abilities.
- Limited Weapon Damage: While dual-wielding allows for two attacks, neither weapon benefits from the monk’s Martial Arts feature that improves damage dice.
- Unarmed Strike Versatility: A monk’s unarmed strikes increase in damage as they level, eventually matching or surpassing the damage of common light weapons. Additionally, unarmed strikes allow for more flexibility and can be used in combination with movement and other abilities.
- Ki Dependency: Monks often rely on ki points to enhance their combat abilities. They use a variety of ki-powered features that typically are a better use of your action economy than an additional off-hand attack.
Situations Where Dual-Wielding Could Be Viable
Despite these drawbacks, there are niche situations where dual-wielding can be useful:
- Early Levels: Before the monk’s unarmed strikes scale up and they gain access to Flurry of Blows, using two shortswords might be a viable option to maximize your early damage output.
- Specific Magic Items: If a monk gains access to magic weapons with special properties, and are light, dual-wielding can become a more attractive option. For example, a set of +1 daggers can deal out reasonable early game damage.
- Resource Management: In situations where a monk is low on ki and cannot use Flurry of Blows, a two-weapon attack may be better than a single regular attack.
- Roleplaying Reasons: A player might choose dual-wielding for roleplaying reasons. The aesthetic of two blades can be appealing, and while not always optimal it is a valid choice.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Can monks dual wield katanas?
Strictly by the rules, the katana is not a monk weapon unless it’s been customized via the “Kensei” subclass or a feat. In most cases, the katana is not a light weapon, making it unsuitable for two-weapon fighting. However, it can become a Monk weapon if the character has taken certain special feats like “Monastic Weaponry” and only applies to the katana, or if the DM rules it can be.
2. Do monk’s fists count as weapons for dual-wielding?
No, a monk’s fists are not considered weapons. Instead of using a weapon to make a melee weapon attack, a monk can use an unarmed strike, which are considered forceful blows but not weapons. You can not dual wield unarmed strikes.
3. Can a monk move between attacks?
Yes, a monk can move between their Attack action and any bonus action attacks. This flexibility is crucial for a monk’s mobility on the battlefield.
4. What weapons are considered “Monk Weapons?”
Monk Weapons are shortswords and any simple melee weapon that does not have the two-handed or heavy properties. The quarterstaff is a prime example as it is a simple melee weapon and has neither of those properties. Many DMs may also permit the spear for Monks.
5. Can a monk use a longsword?
Elf monks have proficiency with longswords and shortswords, as standard. Dwarf monks have access to heavy picks and battleaxes. The longsword, normally, is not a monk weapon, but the elf race can make the longsword a viable option for a monk character.
6. Does dual wielding stack with flurry of blows?
No. These are two separate actions, each using your bonus action. Using one prevents the use of the other during the same turn. You must choose which one you will take.
7. Can a monk use shields?
Yes, Monks can use shields without penalty. While they do not typically rely on armor, shields can be useful for some builds.
8. Can a monk dual-wield with different weapons?
Yes. As long as both are light melee weapons that you are proficient with, they can be different. A typical example could be a shortsword in one hand, and a dagger in the other.
9. Is it better to use unarmed strikes or monk weapons?
This depends on the character’s level and circumstances. Early on, a light weapon may be better as unarmed strikes do not have the scaling damage. As levels increase, monks get more out of their unarmed strikes, making them a very powerful option compared to weaker weapons.
10. Can you combine dual wielding and the bonus action attack from some monk subclasses?
No, the bonus action is a single resource. Using it for your off-hand attack means you cannot use another bonus action to trigger a special subclass feature like the “Drunken Master’s” Drunken Technique.
11. Can a monk use a versatile weapon in both hands?
If the versatile weapon is also a monk weapon, yes. The versatility property (and two-hand damage die) and dual wielding can exist concurrently. However, you need the weapon to be light to actually dual wield.
12. What is the best weapon for a monk?
Typically, the spear (when permitted by the DM) is considered the most versatile due to its 1d8 damage dice when used with two hands, and its ability to be thrown for range. The quarterstaff is another common pick, and for some builds using magic weapons could be a viable option.
13. Can monks use heavy weapons?
No most monk’s do not have proficiency with heavy weapons, and these weapons are not compatible with their Martial Arts abilities. At 17th level, a monk gains a passive ability to use heavy martial weapons in defense.
14. Can a monk multi-class?
Yes, monks can multi-class into other classes. Multi-classing can open up unique build options with classes such as Clerics or Rogues that have wisdom or dexterity synergies.
15. Does the Defensive Duelist feat work with monk weapons?
No, a monk’s unarmed strikes aren’t finesse weapons. The Defensive Duelist feat requires a finesse weapon to function.
Conclusion
While monks can use two-weapon fighting, it’s not usually their most effective strategy. Their bonus action is typically better spent on Flurry of Blows, making dual-wielding more situational than central to a monk’s playstyle. Understanding the trade-offs and choosing the appropriate strategy based on the circumstances is vital for playing an effective monk. The flexibility of the monk class allows players to find enjoyment in different styles, even if it isn’t the most optimal damage output.