Can Oko the Trickster Be Your Commander? A Deep Dive
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The short answer is: No, Oko the Trickster cannot be your commander in a standard game of Magic: The Gathering. While he is an Oko planeswalker, and that might lead some to believe he’d qualify, Oko the Trickster does not have the text stating, “This card can be your commander”. To understand why, let’s delve deeper into the Commander format rules and the specifics of Oko’s card.
Understanding Commander Rules for Commanders
In the Commander format, also known as EDH (Elder Dragon Highlander), there are specific rules about what constitutes a legal commander. The primary rule states that your commander must be a single legendary creature. However, there’s an exception for certain planeswalkers. These planeswalkers can be used as commanders, but only if the card explicitly states “This card can be your commander.” This phrase is crucial for enabling a planeswalker to lead a Commander deck.
Oko the Trickster simply doesn’t have that crucial text. Instead, he has the following abilities:
- [+1]: Put two +1/+1 counters on up to one target creature you control.
- [0]: Until end of turn, Oko, the Trickster becomes a copy of target creature you control. Prevent all damage that would be dealt to him this turn.
As you can see, his abilities are powerful and versatile, but they don’t make him a legal commander. Without that specified text, he’s just another planeswalker in the 99 of your deck.
The Legacy of Oko and His Banned Counterpart
It’s important to distinguish between Oko the Trickster and his more famous (or infamous) counterpart, Oko, Thief of Crowns. Oko, Thief of Crowns was so powerful that he was banned in multiple formats, including Modern, due to his incredible flexibility and capacity to disrupt the game. He wasn’t banned in commander but its power led to some controversy. Despite the power of Oko, Thief of Crowns, neither this Oko nor the other planeswalker Oko cards like Oko, the Ringleader are valid commanders.
The fact that Oko the Trickster shares a name and character with the banned Oko, Thief of Crowns often leads to confusion. Players might assume that because he’s an Oko planeswalker, he would be a legal Commander. However, the text on the card is what determines legality, not the shared lore or character.
A Flavorful Alternative?
While Oko the Trickster might be a flavorful and interesting choice to lead your deck, the game rules prevent it. He can still be an important component of a deck if you like, but you will need a valid commander to lead it. The article you mentioned states “Oko, the Trickster is the best alternate commander for flavor, since he’s still an Oko Planeswalker,” but this statement is meant to convey that he is a good card to include in a deck with an Oko commander, rather than the card itself being a viable option. He can be a fun addition in the 99, and can provide some good utility, but he can’t sit in the command zone.
The Importance of the Rules
The rules for the Commander format are designed to maintain balance and prevent any one card or strategy from becoming overly dominant. The specific requirement for “This card can be your commander” ensures that only a select group of planeswalkers are able to lead decks, maintaining fairness and strategic diversity.
Now, let’s address some frequently asked questions to further clarify the nuances of Commander legality and Oko.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What are the requirements for a card to be a legal commander?
A card must be a legendary creature or a planeswalker with the specific text: “This card can be your commander”.
2. Why is Oko, Thief of Crowns banned?
Oko, Thief of Crowns was banned in various formats due to his power level and ability to disrupt game patterns and create homogenized gameplay. His ability to transform threats into elk and gain life was too powerful and was considered a threat to the balance of many formats.
3. Can any legendary creature be a commander?
Yes, any legendary creature can be a commander as long as it is legal in the format.
4. Can you have two commanders in a Commander deck?
Yes, you can have two commanders if both cards have the Partner ability. This allows for more colors and deck construction options.
5. What is the “legendary rule” in Commander?
The legendary rule in Commander means that you can only have one copy of any card except basic lands. If you have two legendary cards with the same name on the battlefield, you must choose one to sacrifice.
6. What does “partner” mean in Commander?
Partner allows a player to have two commanders, provided both commanders have the Partner keyword ability.
7. Does commander tax apply to each partner separately?
Yes, commander tax applies to each partner commander separately.
8. Can you choose which partner a card refers to when it says “your commander?”
Yes, if a card refers to “your commander,” you can choose which partner that effect applies to.
9. Who is Sheldon Menery?
Sheldon Menery is known as the “Godfather of Commander,” and was one of the format’s original creators.
10. What is “Rule 0” in Commander?
Rule 0 in Commander is an unofficial rule that allows players to modify the rules of a game in a non-competitive setting, so long as all participants agree to the change before the game.
11. Can a planeswalker be a commander without explicitly saying so?
No, a planeswalker must have the text “This card can be your commander” to be a legal commander.
12. What is color identity in Commander?
Color identity refers to the color mana symbols that appear on a card. These mana symbols determine which colors of cards may be used in a commander deck.
13. Is Flash banned in Commander?
No, Flash is not currently banned in Commander, however, other cards that synergize with it have been banned.
14. Is Edgar Markov banned as a commander?
Edgar Markov is only banned as a commander in specific situations or with specific groups, depending on the group’s agreed-upon rules. It is not on the official banned list.
15. What happens if my commander leaves the battlefield?
When your commander leaves the battlefield, you can choose to return it to the command zone instead of placing it in the graveyard or exile. From there, you can cast it again for its mana cost, plus an additional 2 mana per time you’ve cast it from the command zone.
Conclusion
While Oko the Trickster might be an appealing card due to its versatility and flavor, it cannot be your commander. The rules of the Commander format require that a card either be a legendary creature or a planeswalker with the explicit text “This card can be your commander.” Oko the Trickster lacks this crucial text, making him ineligible for the command zone. However, he can be a powerful addition to the 99 of your Commander deck. Always be sure to carefully read the text on your cards to ensure a legal and enjoyable game!