Can Old Gen and New Gen Play FIFA 23 Together? A Comprehensive Guide
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The question of whether old generation consoles can play with new generation consoles in FIFA 23 is a common one among fans. The short answer is: Yes, but with a crucial caveat. FIFA 23 does support cross-play, but it’s not fully cross-generational. Players on PlayStation 5 (PS5), Xbox Series X
| S, and PC can play with each other, and players on PlayStation 4 (PS4) and Xbox One can play with each other. However, PS4 and Xbox One players cannot directly play against PS5, Xbox Series X |
|---|
This means that FIFA 23 divides players into two distinct pools. New-gen players (PS5, Xbox Series X|S, and PC) form one pool, while old-gen players (PS4 and Xbox One) form another. This separation is primarily due to the significant technological differences between the console generations, which impact the game’s mechanics, graphics, and overall performance. Essentially, it’s not a straightforward cross-generational bridge, but a cross-platform one within defined generations. This allows for a wider player base but still maintains consistent gameplay experiences within each pool.
Understanding the FIFA 23 Cross-Play System
FIFA 23 was the first title in the franchise to introduce cross-play, a move celebrated by many. Instead of limiting players to their console’s ecosystem, it allows friends on different platforms to play together. However, understanding the specific limitations is crucial. The key point to remember is that cross-play in FIFA 23 is implemented by grouping like generations together.
Cross-Play Compatibility Groups
-
New Gen Group: PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X|S, and PC. Players in this group can play with anyone else in the same group, regardless of their specific console or PC.
-
Old Gen Group: PlayStation 4 and Xbox One. Players in this group can play with anyone else on either console.
The Reason for the Separation
The separation is not a matter of exclusion, but a matter of game compatibility. The new-gen consoles and PC operate on different game engines than the old-gen consoles, meaning that cross-play between the two generations could result in significant gameplay inconsistencies and unfair advantages. This separation ensures a fair and consistent gameplay experience for all players within their respective groups.
Navigating the Cross-Play System
Even though direct old-gen and new-gen cross-play is not available, there are still ways to enjoy playing with friends across different platforms. For example, someone owning both a PS4 and PS5 version of FIFA 23 could opt to play the PS4 version on their PS5 to play with a friend on a PS4. This highlights how the game’s architecture allows for flexibility for players with access to more than one console.
Switching Between Old and New Gen Versions
If you own a new generation console, but also have access to the old-generation version, you can switch between them. Here is a quick guide for those who want to play with old gen friends on their new gen console:
- Start the old-gen version of FIFA 23. For example, if you want to play with your PS4 friend, start the PS4 version of the game on your PS5.
- Access the PSN store via the game. It’s crucial to enter the store through the in-game menu to make sure the correct version of the game is recognized.
- Select the new-gen version of the game. If you have dual entitlement, you should see the PS5 version available for download.
This method allows you to seamlessly switch between versions, enabling you to play with friends on different console generations. The important takeaway is that you are playing the old-gen version of the game if you are playing with an old-gen player, even if you are playing it on a new-gen console.
Limitations within Cross-Play
It’s also worth noting that Pro Clubs in FIFA 23 is the major game mode that does not feature any cross-play. This means that if you and your friends were hoping to create a team and play across different consoles, this is unfortunately not possible. This has been a point of contention for many players who are hoping that cross-play will be integrated into Pro Clubs in future versions.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
To further clarify the intricacies of FIFA 23’s cross-play system, here are some frequently asked questions:
1. Is FIFA 23 fully cross-platform?
Yes, FIFA 23 is cross-platform, but it is not fully cross-generational. Players within the same console generation (PS5/Xbox Series X|S/PC or PS4/Xbox One) can play with each other.
2. Can PS4 players play with PS5 players on FIFA 23?
No, PS4 players can only play with other PS4 players, while PS5 players can only play with PS5, Xbox Series X|S, and PC players.
3. Can Xbox One players play with Xbox Series X|S players on FIFA 23?
No, Xbox One players can only play with other Xbox One players, while Xbox Series X
| S players can only play with PS5, PC, and Xbox Series X |
|---|
4. Can I switch between the PS4 and PS5 versions of FIFA 23 on the same console?
Yes, if you own both versions, you can switch between them using the method described above. This is especially helpful when you want to play with players across the console generation divide.
5. Does cross-play impact gameplay?
No, cross-play doesn’t directly impact gameplay. What separates the new-gen players from the old-gen players is the game versions they are playing, and not their choice of consoles. Therefore, no matter which console you play with, the experience will remain consistent within the version you are playing.
6. How do I enable cross-play in FIFA 23?
Cross-play can be enabled in the settings menu under online settings. Make sure it is toggled on for you to play with other players on your console generation.
7. Does FIFA 23 cross-play include Pro Clubs?
No, Pro Clubs does not support cross-play in FIFA 23, which is a major disappointment for many fans.
8. Why doesn’t FIFA 23 have full cross-generational play?
This limitation is mainly due to the technological differences between old-gen and new-gen consoles, which use different game engines. Allowing play across generations could lead to inconsistencies in gameplay and fairness.
9. Can I play with my friend on PC if I am on PS5?
Yes, if you are on PS5 and your friend is on PC, you can play together as they are within the same cross-play group.
10. Is there cross-progression in FIFA 23?
No, there is no cross-progression, which means you cannot carry your saved progress from one console generation to another. If you switch versions, you will start a new profile.
11. Will FIFA 24 have cross-generational play?
No, similar to FIFA 23, EA Sports FC 24 (formerly FIFA 24) does not have cross-generational play. The same crossplay grouping persists.
12. Does the age of a player matter in FIFA 23?
Yes, as a player ages in the game, their stats will begin to decline. However, with effective development plans, you can mitigate this decline.
13. What if I can’t invite my friend on FIFA 23?
Ensure that you are both friends on the network (e.g., PSN or Xbox Live), online, and have cross-play enabled. If issues persist, restart the game or console.
14. Does FIFA 23 on the Switch have cross-play?
No, FIFA 23 does not support cross-play on the Nintendo Switch.
15. Is FIFA 23 better on new gen or old gen?
This is a subjective question, but many players have stated that the new-gen version offers better graphics and gameplay. However, some players prefer the old-gen version as they claim it is a smoother and more enjoyable experience. The best choice will depend on your preference.
Conclusion
While FIFA 23 doesn’t offer full cross-generational play, it does provide a robust cross-play system that unites players across different platforms within the same console generation. Understanding these limitations is key to enjoying the game with friends. Although the separation might be frustrating for some, it is a necessary measure to maintain gameplay fairness and consistency across various console generations.