Can Old Gen Play with New Gen? A Comprehensive Guide to Cross-Generation Gaming
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The simple answer to the burning question, “Can old gen play with new gen?”, is: it depends on the game. There is no universal answer. In the current gaming landscape, the ability for players on older generation consoles (like PlayStation 4 and Xbox One) to play with players on newer generation consoles (like PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X/S, and often PC) is determined on a game-by-game basis and often involves a variety of factors related to crossplay, cross-progression, and the game itself. Let’s delve deeper into this complex issue.
Cross-Generation Play: A Game-by-Game Situation
The most important thing to understand is that the ability to play across generations is not a standard feature that applies to all games. Game developers make the choice to implement cross-generation play, and this often depends on technical constraints, design decisions, and the game’s overall vision.
Essentially, what we often see is that games are often divided into two or more buckets:
- New Generation Group: This includes PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X/S, and sometimes PC.
- Old Generation Group: This typically includes PlayStation 4 and Xbox One.
- Sometimes there are further splits, like Nintendo Switch versions.
Typically, games will allow crossplay within the same generation bucket, but not necessarily across those buckets. So, a PS5 player can generally play with an Xbox Series X player, but not necessarily with a PS4 player.
Technical Limitations and Gameplay Considerations
The primary reasons why cross-generation play isn’t universally supported revolve around several key factors:
- Hardware Disparities: Newer consoles have significantly more powerful hardware than their predecessors. This can lead to differences in game performance, graphics, and even gameplay mechanics that would be challenging to reconcile in a seamless cross-generation environment.
- Game Design Complexity: Games often need to be specifically designed or significantly modified to support cross-generation play. This can involve significant time and resources for developers.
- Feature Discrepancies: Games on newer consoles often have enhanced features or specific mechanics that aren’t feasible or present on older consoles. Allowing cross-generation play with these discrepancies may present compatibility issues and unfair advantages.
Key Examples: A Look at Different Games
Let’s take a look at specific examples to illustrate how cross-generation play is implemented across a few popular titles:
- EA Sports FC (Formerly FIFA): For the current EA Sports FC, players on PS5, Xbox Series X/S, and PC can all play together. However, PS4 and Xbox One players are restricted to playing with each other. This model has been consistent in recent EA Sports titles, focusing on crossplay within the same platform generation. EA FC also does support cross-progression within the same console family.
- Madden NFL: The trend for Madden is similar to FIFA. Madden 24 only allows crossplay between PS5, Xbox Series X/S, and PC. Players on PS4 and Xbox One cannot play with those on newer consoles or PC, even if playing the same game title. Madden does offer Dual Entitlement for purchasing both versions, so players can experience the new-gen version, but it’s important to note that game progress may not transfer.
- Grand Theft Auto Online (GTA Online): GTA Online has followed a similar platform-generation split to that of EA Sports games. Players of old gen consoles such as the PS4 and Xbox One can only play with their respective group. Whereas the new generation console players (PS5 and Xbox Series X/S) play together.
- Battlefield 2042: This game also adheres to the platform generation rule. PS5, Xbox Series X/S and PC can play together, while PS4 and Xbox One can play together.
Cross-Progression: A Separate Issue
It’s also crucial to distinguish between cross-generation play and cross-progression. While cross-generation play refers to whether you can play with friends across different consoles, cross-progression refers to whether your game progress, stats, and unlocked content can move between different console generations.
Generally, while not always the case, cross-progression is more common within the same console family. For example, you may have your saved progress from PlayStation 4 carry over to PlayStation 5, or Xbox One to Xbox Series X/S, while your cross-progression is not likely to exist with a different system (ie PS to Xbox).
Dual Entitlement: What Does It Mean?
Many games offer a feature called “Dual Entitlement”. This often comes up with cross-gen bundles and this allows players to access both the older and newer generation versions of a game on their respective console. For instance, purchasing a dual-entitlement version of a game on an Xbox Series X/S might grant you access to both the Xbox One and Xbox Series X/S versions of that game. This feature is aimed to accommodate the varying console setups of players in the same household and among their friend groups.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some frequently asked questions to help further clarify the complexities of cross-generation gaming:
1. Can PS4 players play with PS5 players?
Yes, in many cases, as long as the game supports cross-generation play. However, they often will be playing a different version of the game, often with certain feature differences. They’ll be considered as being in the same ‘platform generation’ bucket that will enable them to play with one another.
2. Can Xbox One players play with Xbox Series X/S players?
Again, the answer is yes, in many cases. Similar to the PlayStation setup, as long as the game enables cross-generation play, players on these consoles can often play together, but again it should be noted that they are likely playing different game versions that are optimized for their specific hardware.
3. Why can’t all games have cross-generation play?
As mentioned, it often comes down to technical limitations and development resources. The differences in hardware and features between console generations can require significant effort to manage across various platforms.
4. If a game has cross-generation play, can I use my old saves on the new console?
Not necessarily. This is an issue of cross-progression which is separate from crossplay. While your cross-progression may be available within the same console family, it may not exist between different console platforms (ie, PS to Xbox).
5. Do all games offer “Dual Entitlement”?
No, Dual Entitlement is not a universal feature. It’s a perk that is determined by the game developer and typically offered in specific versions of a game.
6. Can PC players play with console players?
It depends on the game. Crossplay with PC is often grouped with the new generation console pool (PS5/Xbox Series X/S). Therefore, crossplay between PC and the newer consoles is typically more likely than crossplay with older consoles.
7. Will cross-generation play always be free?
Yes, if the feature is present in a game, the cross-generation element is included as part of the standard game functionality. You typically will not need to pay an additional fee for the cross-generation support.
8. Is there a trend towards more cross-generation play in the future?
Yes, it seems like more games are moving towards offering cross-generation play as developers seek to maximize player engagement and create larger online communities. However, it is still very much on a game-by-game basis.
9. Can my older console handle the same graphics as the new consoles?
No, this is not the case. Older consoles have hardware limitations that prevent them from rendering the same level of detail and performance as newer consoles. Therefore, they will likely run on optimized versions of the same game that are tailored to the hardware that they are running on.
10. Can cross-generation play lead to unfair advantages?
If implemented poorly, it can. However, developers often try to balance gameplay by optimizing the game and making it relatively fair between players on different console versions, which will often include some degree of compromises.
11. What is a cross-generation bundle?
A cross-generation bundle is a package that typically allows you to own versions of a game for both current and last-gen consoles. This is not typically related to being able to play with different generations of players, but having access to the game on your device.
12. Does cross-generation always mean crossplay?
Not always. Cross-generation refers to the ability to play on different console generations, but does not always guarantee cross-play with those other consoles. Some games may offer cross-progression without allowing you to play together.
13. How do I know if a game supports cross-generation play?
Check the game’s official website or product description. Often, this information will be readily available. You can also find forums with gamers talking about their specific experiences and if cross-generation play exists.
14. Can I invite friends from the older generation to play with me on the new generation?
Usually, yes, if the game has enabled cross-generation multiplayer, the process is similar to inviting someone on the same console version. However, as mentioned, the group will often be playing on different versions of the same game.
15. Is gameplay better on new-generation consoles?
This will be subjective to the player, but generally, yes. New-generation consoles tend to have better graphics, smoother performance, and improved gameplay. However, this may come at the cost of changing game mechanics that may make a game less or more appealing for each person playing.
Conclusion
The world of cross-generation play can be confusing, but by understanding the nuances and the way that developers are choosing to implement it, you can make more informed decisions about what games and systems to use. Remember, always check the specifics for each game to see if cross-generation is available, and if it works in a way that suits your preferences. As the gaming world continues to evolve, it is likely that cross-generation play will continue to expand and become more common.