Can Shock Target a Planeswalker? The Complete Guide to Planeswalker Targeting in Magic: The Gathering
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The short and direct answer is: yes, Shock can target a Planeswalker. Cards like Shock, Lightning Bolt, and other direct damage spells that say “any target” can absolutely target a Planeswalker. But the rules surrounding Planeswalker targeting have a complex history, so let’s dive deeper into the intricacies of how you can, and cannot, interact with these powerful permanents in Magic: The Gathering.
Understanding Planeswalker Targeting: A Historical Perspective
The concept of targeting Planeswalkers has evolved significantly over time. When Planeswalkers were first introduced in the Lorwyn block, the rules worked differently. Initially, you couldn’t directly target a Planeswalker with a damage spell. Instead, you had to target the Planeswalker’s controller and then, upon the spell’s resolution, you could choose to redirect the damage to the Planeswalker.
This “redirection rule” created some confusion and added an extra layer of complexity to the game. However, the rule was changed. Today, many spells that read “any target” can directly target Planeswalkers. This streamlined approach made the game more intuitive and reduced the number of steps required to deal damage to these powerful permanents.
Direct Damage vs. Indirect Damage: What’s the Difference?
The core concept to grasp is the difference between direct damage and indirect damage.
- Direct damage spells, as the name suggests, directly target a permanent or player. Cards like Shock, Lightning Bolt, and Lava Spike are examples of direct damage spells that can target Planeswalkers, creatures, or players.
- Indirect damage, on the other hand, involves targeting a player and then redirecting the damage to a Planeswalker they control. While this was the only way to damage Planeswalkers initially, it is no longer the primary method.
Beyond Direct Damage: Other Ways to Deal with Planeswalkers
While direct damage spells are a common way to eliminate Planeswalkers, they aren’t the only tools at your disposal. Many other card types and abilities can interact with Planeswalkers, providing a diverse range of strategic options.
Removal Spells
Many removal spells that target “any permanent” can also target Planeswalkers. For example, a card that says “destroy target permanent” can be used to destroy a Planeswalker. Instant-speed spells like the “Swift End” half of Murderous Rider are capable of directly destroying creatures or Planeswalkers.
Combat Damage
Creatures can attack Planeswalkers directly, dealing combat damage that reduces the Planeswalker’s loyalty counters. Declaring an attacking creature to attack a Planeswalker results in a reduction of loyalty equal to the creature’s power.
Planeswalker Abilities
Some Planeswalkers have abilities that directly affect other Planeswalkers. These abilities can be used to support your own Planeswalkers or disrupt your opponent’s strategy.
Common Misconceptions About Planeswalkers
Many misconceptions exist about Planeswalkers, particularly among newer players. Let’s debunk some of these:
- Planeswalkers are creatures: This is incorrect. Planeswalkers are a separate permanent type with their own unique rules.
- You can have multiple copies of the same Planeswalker in play: While you can have multiple Planeswalkers in play, you cannot have two copies of the exact same Planeswalker card, even if they are from different sets. This is due to the “planeswalker uniqueness rule”.
FAQs: Answering Your Burning Planeswalker Questions
Here are some frequently asked questions to address specific scenarios and clarify the rules surrounding Planeswalker targeting:
FAQ 1: Can Fireball target Planeswalkers?
You can’t target the Planeswalker itself with Fireball because Fireball targets a creature or player. However, you can target the Planeswalker’s controller and then redirect the damage to the Planeswalker upon resolution.
FAQ 2: Can Lightning Helix hit Planeswalkers?
Yes, Lightning Helix can target Planeswalkers. It is a versatile spell that can target creatures, Planeswalkers, or players, while also gaining you life.
FAQ 3: Does Deathtouch work on Planeswalkers?
Deathtouch does not automatically destroy Planeswalkers. Deathtouch applies only to creatures. You’ll need an additional ability, like that of Vraska, Swarm’s Eminence, to affect Planeswalkers with deathtouch.
FAQ 4: Can you Terror a Planeswalker?
No, you cannot Terror a Planeswalker, as Terror specifically targets creatures.
FAQ 5: Can you Negate a Planeswalker?
No, you cannot Negate a Planeswalker directly. Negate counters only noncreature spells, not permanents on the battlefield.
FAQ 6: Can you Duress a Planeswalker?
No, you can’t use Duress to discard a Planeswalker from your opponent’s hand. Duress can only target noncreature, nonland cards.
FAQ 7: Can Boros Charm hit Planeswalkers?
Yes, Boros Charm can deal 4 damage to target player or Planeswalker.
FAQ 8: Can Vial Smasher hit Planeswalkers?
Yes, Vial Smasher the Fierce can deal damage to a Planeswalker controlled by an opponent, chosen randomly.
FAQ 9: Does PIR affect Planeswalkers?
Yes, Pir, Imaginative Rascal, increases the number of counters Planeswalkers enter the battlefield with.
FAQ 10: Do board wipes affect Planeswalkers?
Some board wipes do affect Planeswalkers. Board wipes that deal damage to all creatures and Planeswalkers will remove loyalty counters from Planeswalkers on the battlefield.
FAQ 11: Can you have 2 Planeswalkers out at the same time?
Yes, you can have multiple Planeswalkers out at the same time, but you can’t control two Planeswalkers with the exact same name (subtype).
FAQ 12: Can Staff of Nin hit Planeswalkers?
Yes, Staff of Nin can deal 1 damage to target creature, player, or Planeswalker.
FAQ 13: Can Searing Blaze target a Planeswalker?
Yes, Searing Blaze can deal 1 damage to target player or Planeswalker and 1 damage to target creature that player or that Planeswalker’s controller controls.
FAQ 14: Can Walking Ballista target Planeswalkers?
Yes, Walking Ballista’s activated ability allows it to deal 1 damage to any target, including creatures, players, Planeswalkers, or battles.
FAQ 15: What is the “Planeswalker Uniqueness Rule”?
The planeswalker uniqueness rule prevents you from controlling two Planeswalkers with the same subtype at the same time. For example, you can’t control two Planeswalkers that are both named “Jace,” even if they are different cards (e.g., Jace, the Mind Sculptor and Jace Beleren). If you attempt to play a Planeswalker with the same subtype as one you already control, you must choose one to keep and the other is put into your graveyard.
Mastering Planeswalker Interactions: A Key to Victory
Understanding how to interact with Planeswalkers is essential for success in Magic: The Gathering. By mastering the nuances of targeting, removal, and strategic play, you can effectively control the battlefield and secure victory. So, go forth and unleash your Planeswalker prowess! Consider learning more about the educational aspects of gaming through the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org.