Can Wizards Learn Cleric Spells from Scrolls in D&D 5e?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The question of whether a Wizard can learn Cleric spells from scrolls in Dungeons & Dragons 5th Edition (5e) is a recurring one, sparking much debate among players and DMs alike. The short answer, based on the core rules, is nuanced.
While the rules generally restrict spellcasting to spells from a character’s class list, there are exceptions. Wizards can copy spells from scrolls into their spellbooks, but there are critical restrictions:
- The spell must be on the Wizard spell list. If a spell is exclusively on the Cleric spell list and not on the Wizard spell list, generally the Wizard can not learn the spell.
However, some spells appear on multiple class lists. For example, Protection from Evil and Good is on both the Wizard and Cleric list. If the spell is on both the Cleric and Wizard spell lists, a Wizard can copy it from a scroll. This essentially means, if a Wizard finds a scroll of Protection from Evil and Good then he or she may learn it from a scroll.
It’s important to remember that the Dungeon Master (DM) has the final say. A DM can choose to allow a Wizard to learn spells outside their class list, perhaps as part of a specific campaign or storyline. Such a decision deviates from the standard rules but is perfectly acceptable within the framework of D&D’s emphasis on collaborative storytelling.
Delving Deeper: The Spell Scroll Rules
To understand this ruling, it’s essential to understand how spell scrolls work in 5e. A spell scroll is a single-use item that allows a character to cast a spell they don’t normally know. Using a scroll doesn’t teach the spell.
The core rule here is this: To use a scroll you must have that class. You can’t use a Paladin scroll as a Rogue, unless you multi-class, so that the spells are on your character’s list.
Circumventing the Limitations
While directly learning a Cleric spell exclusively to the Cleric spell list is not the norm, here are some ways a Wizard might gain access to such magic:
- Multiclassing: This is the most straightforward approach. A Wizard can take levels in the Cleric class, gaining access to the Cleric spell list and the ability to prepare and cast Cleric spells.
- Magic Initiate Feat: This feat allows a character to learn two cantrips and one 1st-level spell from another class’s spell list. However, the 1st-level spell can only be cast once per long rest.
- DM Discretion: As always, the DM can create situations or grant boons that allow a Wizard to learn spells outside their normal class list. Perhaps a powerful artifact allows the temporary merging of spell lists, or a deity bestows knowledge upon the Wizard.
- Spells on both lists: Some spells are on multiple class lists and, therefore, available to the Wizard class.
Ultimately, the question hinges on adhering to the established rules of the game while also recognizing the flexibility and creative license afforded to the DM and players.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Here are some frequently asked questions to help clarify the topic further.
Can a Wizard Use Divine Scrolls?
Generally, no. The default assumption is that Wizards, as arcane spellcasters, can only use scrolls containing arcane spells. Divine spellcasters, like Clerics, use scrolls containing divine spells. However, if the spell on the scroll is on the Wizard spell list, they can use it.
Can a Wizard Add Exclusively Cleric Spells to Their Spellbook?
No, unless the DM allows it. By default, Wizards cannot add Cleric spells to their spellbook that are exclusively on the Cleric spell list. They can only transcribe Wizard spells or spells that appear on both lists.
Is a Cleric/Wizard Multiclass a Good Option?
It can be, depending on your character concept and playstyle. Multiclassing as a Cleric/Wizard offers access to both divine and arcane spells. A one-level dip into Cleric grants access to minor healing spells and possibly heavy armor proficiency, which is beneficial for a Wizard.
Can a Wizard Cast a Cleric Scroll if the Spell is on Both Lists?
Yes. If the DM allows the scribing of spell scrolls and the spell is on both the Cleric and Wizard spell lists (like Protection from Evil and Good), a Wizard can learn it from the scroll.
Can Wizards Copy Spells from Scrolls into their Spellbook?
Yes. A Wizard spell on a spell scroll can be copied into the spellbook if the Wizard succeeds on an Intelligence (Arcana) check with a DC equal to 10 + the spell’s level.
Can a Wizard Learn Cure Wounds from a Spell Scroll?
The Wizard cannot learn spells that are exclusively on the Cleric spell list. Cure Wounds is exclusively a Cleric spell, unless it appears on the Wizard list some other way, such as through DM ruling or feats.
Can a Wizard Learn a Cantrip from a Scroll?
The Wizard can only copy a cantrip from a scroll into a spellbook if the DM allows it.
Can a Wizard Learn a Druid Spell from a Scroll?
Yes, if the spell is on both the Druid and Wizard spell lists and the DM is allowing the use of the scribing scroll mechanics.
Do Only Wizards Learn Spells from Scrolls in Baldur’s Gate 3?
Yes, in Baldur’s Gate 3, only the Wizard class has the ability to learn new spells from scrolls by transcribing them.
Can Wizards Cast Spells Directly from Their Spellbook?
No, Wizards cannot cast spells directly from their spellbooks. They must prepare spells from their spellbook into their mind for that day.
Does Using a Scroll Count as Casting a Spell?
When using magic items, such as scrolls, you do not count as having cast the spell yourself. The magic item casts the spell using the caster level set in the item.
Can Cleric Spells Be on Scrolls?
Yes. A spell scroll contains a single spell which is only readable and usable if the spell is on the spell list used by your class. For a Cleric this would mean the spell must be on the Cleric spell list.
Can a Sorcerer Learn Cleric Spells?
All Sorcerers, Divine Soul or not, can learn spells which may also be Cleric spells. Divine Soul Sorcerers add the entire Cleric spell list to the Sorcerer spell list for themselves.
Can You Cast Wizard Spells with Cleric Spell Slots?
If you multiclass and prepare a Wizard spell using a Cleric spell slot, then yes. Clerics also have access to some spells based on their divine domain.
Is Multiclassing Worth It for a Wizard?
D&D Clerics and Wizards have to be very careful with their multiclassing. They both rely on their spellcasting for most of their power. A character who tries to take even levels in both will have a lot of low-level spells they can’t use very well.
The Power of Collaboration and Creative License
Remember, the rules of D&D 5e are a framework, not an unbreakable barrier. The DM and players are encouraged to collaborate and create a fun, engaging story. Allowing a Wizard to learn a Cleric spell from a scroll, even if it deviates from the standard rules, can add depth and excitement to the game. The key is to ensure that any such deviation is balanced and contributes to the overall narrative.
Ultimately, the question of whether a Wizard can learn Cleric spells from scrolls is a complex one with no simple yes or no answer. It requires a careful understanding of the rules, a willingness to embrace creative possibilities, and a collaborative spirit between the DM and players. By embracing these principles, you can create a D&D experience that is both engaging and memorable. And if you’re interested in learning more about the educational aspects of gaming, consider visiting the Games Learning Society at https://www.gameslearningsociety.org/.