Becoming a Landed Noble: Can You Be a Thane of All Holds in Skyrim?
Fast answer first. Then use the tabs or video for more detail.
- Watch the video explanation below for a faster overview.
- Game mechanics may change with updates or patches.
- Use this block to get the short answer without scrolling the whole page.
- Read the FAQ section if the article has one.
- Use the table of contents to jump straight to the detailed section you need.
- Watch the video first, then skim the article for specifics.
The frozen peaks and sprawling valleys of Skyrim offer more than just dragon slaying and dungeon crawling. They offer a chance to climb the social ladder, earning renown and titles in each of the nine holds. But is it possible to become a Thane of every hold in Skyrim? The answer, adventurer, is a resounding yes! With enough dedication and a willingness to aid the local populace, you can indeed become a Thane in each of Skyrim’s nine holds, enjoying the benefits and prestige that come with the title.
The Path to Thaneship: Earning the Jarl’s Favor
Becoming a Thane isn’t simply a matter of showing up and declaring yourself worthy. Each hold has its own unique requirements, though some common threads run through them all. Generally, you’ll need to perform tasks that demonstrate your value to the hold and its Jarl. These usually involve a combination of the following:
- Completing quests for the Jarl and other prominent citizens of the hold. These quests can range from clearing out bandit camps to retrieving lost artifacts.
- Assisting the local populace. This involves performing acts of kindness and generosity for the people of the hold. This usually means completing miscellaneous quests like chopping wood, delivering items, or helping farmers harvest their crops. You will usually need to help at least five people in each hold to become Thane.
- Purchasing property. Many holds require you to own a house or other significant property within their borders as a sign of your commitment to the hold. The cost of the property varies from hold to hold.
- Showing allegiance. The Civil War in Skyrim can complicate things. If the Jarl changes due to the war, you may need to repeat some tasks, or even assist the new Jarl, to regain or obtain Thaneship. You may even lose your Thane title if the hold falls on the other side of the Civil War.
Navigating the Civil War: A Thane’s Dilemma
The ongoing Civil War between the Imperials and the Stormcloaks adds a layer of complexity to your quest for Thaneship. As holds change hands, so too do their Jarls. If you become a Thane under one Jarl and their side loses the war, the new Jarl may not recognize your title, and you might have to complete tasks for them anew.
Planning your Thaneship journey around the Civil War can save you some trouble. Consider focusing on holds that are unlikely to change hands, or completing the Civil War questline before pursuing Thaneship in contested territories.
The Exception: Eastmarch’s Complicated Politics
There is one significant exception to the general rule. Eastmarch, with its capital in Windhelm, presents a unique challenge. It is nearly impossible to become Thane of Eastmarch if no side is chosen in the Civil War. To become Thane of Eastmarch, you will typically need to align with the Stormcloaks and complete their questline. This is because Ulfric Stormcloak, the Jarl of Windhelm and leader of the Stormcloaks, is deeply entrenched in the rebellion. Earning his favor requires demonstrating your commitment to the Stormcloak cause.
Benefits of Thaneship: More Than Just a Title
Becoming a Thane isn’t just about bragging rights. It comes with tangible benefits:
- Housecarl: Each hold grants you a personal bodyguard, a loyal Housecarl who will follow you and defend you.
- Increased Favor: You’ll receive preferential treatment from guards and other NPCs within the hold.
- Potential for Unique Dialogue: Some characters may react differently to you, recognizing your elevated status.
Planning Your Path to Nobility
Embarking on the quest to become Thane of every hold requires careful planning and efficient execution. Here are some tips to maximize your success:
- Prioritize Property Acquisition: Purchase homes as early as possible. This not only fulfills a requirement for Thaneship in many holds but also provides valuable storage and crafting facilities.
- Optimize Quest Completion: Look for overlapping quests that can be completed simultaneously. For example, a quest to clear a bandit camp might also fulfill a Jarl’s request for security.
- Exploit Miscellaneous Quests: Keep an eye out for simple tasks that can be completed quickly to boost your reputation with the local populace. Chopping wood, delivering goods, and helping farmers are all easy ways to earn favor.
Becoming a Thane of every hold in Skyrim is an achievable goal. With dedication, strategic planning, and a willingness to lend a helping hand, you can rise through the ranks of Skyrim society and become a true noble of the land. Perhaps studying the gameplay of others could also help to discover creative strategies. To learn more about the impact of game-based learning, visit the Games Learning Society at GamesLearningSociety.org.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Becoming Thane
1. Can I lose my Thane title in Skyrim?
Yes, you can lose your Thane status if the Jarl position changes during a Civil War battle. Specifically, if you are Thane of Whiterun and the Stormcloaks take the city, your Thaneship will be revoked.
2. How do I know how many people I need to help in each hold to become Thane?
There’s no in-game counter. A general rule of thumb is to help at least five residents of the hold. These must be Help People quests that will show up as completed in your quest log. Just doing favors like buying things from merchants doesn’t count.
3. Is it possible to become Thane of Riften?
Yes, it’s possible to become Thane of Riften, although it can be more challenging due to the Thieves Guild’s presence. Completing the Thieves Guild questline can improve your standing in Riften.
4. Can I become Thane of Windhelm without joining the Stormcloaks?
No, generally, you need to align with the Stormcloaks to become Thane of Windhelm, as Ulfric Stormcloak is the Jarl and a staunch supporter of the rebellion.
5. How many Thanes can you be in Skyrim?
You can be Thane of all nine holds in Skyrim. Eastmarch is the only exception, as it can be difficult to obtain Thaneship without aligning with the Stormcloaks.
6. Is it better to side with the Stormcloaks or Imperials for becoming Thane?
Neither side is inherently better. Your choice depends on your roleplaying preferences and the specific holds you prioritize. Siding with the Stormcloaks may make it easier to become Thane of holds like Windhelm, while siding with the Imperials may streamline Thaneship in holds like Solitude.
7. Can I marry the Jarl of Solitude?
No, you cannot marry Elisif the Fair, the Jarl of Solitude, without using mods. Even with mods, the conditions for marrying her are specific, often requiring neutrality or alliance with the Imperial Legion.
8. Who becomes Jarl of Riften if the Imperials win?
If the Imperials win the Civil War and you have captured the Rift, Maven Black-Briar will replace Laila Law-Giver as Jarl of Riften.
9. What happens if I give Riften to the Imperials during Season Unending?
During the Season Unending quest, giving Riften to the Imperials pleases them, while giving Dawnstar pleases the Stormcloaks. This choice affects the balance of power in the Civil War.
10. Which hold is the easiest to become Thane in Skyrim?
Many players find Whiterun to be the easiest hold to become Thane in, as the quest to become Thane occurs automatically during the main questline. Riften is also considered relatively easy, with a cheaper house and straightforward quests.
11. Can I use the Thane excuse to avoid paying bounties more than once?
The Thane excuse to avoid paying bounties typically works only once per hold. After that, you’ll need to pay your dues like everyone else.
12. What’s the best house to buy in Skyrim?
The “best” house is subjective and depends on your preferences. Lakeview Manor is popular for its customization options, while Proudspire Manor in Solitude offers a central location and luxurious amenities.
13. Can you own a house in all holds in Skyrim?
Yes, you can own a house in every hold in Skyrim, plus a home on Solstheim. This allows you to establish a presence in each region and enjoy the benefits of homeownership.
14. Can I marry a Jarl in Skyrim?
No, you cannot marry any of the Jarls in Skyrim without using mods. Jarls are typically essential characters who are not available for marriage.
15. What happens if the Stormcloaks win the Civil War?
If the Stormcloaks win, Ulfric Stormcloak will appoint new Jarls in holds that were previously loyal to the Empire. This can significantly alter the political landscape of Skyrim.